Read Link first - Is "sexy, effeminate Asians" reason for the success of Kpop?

  • "We Asians really have only three routes when it comes to dominating “international popularity” - comedic caricature, kungfu masters, or sexy, effeminate Asians. Korea and Japan lean into the last one. Hong Kong did the first two, which is why everyone remembers Bruce Lee and Jackie Chan."


    Why isn’t Chinese and Vietnamese pop culture as internationally popular as Korean or Japanese pop culture?
    Answer (1 of 4): Simple - China and Vietnam are pretty normal. It’s Korea and Japan who are the major exceptions to the rule, because they depend heavily on…
    www.quora.com


    Topic for discussion.


    Edit: There is little point in discussing without reading the linked post, which already discusses politics, export orientation etc.

    Edited once, last by bbgc ().

  • welp the consumer base in china is MASSIVE so even if there is interesting stuff they aren't in a rush to export to anyone; the US market is smaller than the chinese market whereas the dynamic for korea is that the US market is bigger than the Korean market, for example. There would be more children in china than the whole population of US, given time.


    Idk for vietnam.

  • "We Asians really have only three routes when it comes to dominating “international popularity” - comedic caricature, kungfu masters, or sexy, effeminate Asians. Korea and Japan lean into the last one. Hong Kong did the first two, which is why everyone remembers Bruce Lee and Jackie Chan."


    https://www.quora.com/Why-isn-…n-or-Japanese-pop-culture


    Topic for discussion.

    That quote is so sad yet true </3

  • I think it depends on the medium.



    Chinese live action film is pretty popular and there's a lot of historical cross over there with directors, actresses, and Chinese movies.



    I think it's in a general sense this:



    Japan: anime / animation


    Chinese: film


    Korea: film/ dramas / kpop.




    With respect to Korean popularity. They've made a concerted effort to export abroad on global scale.



    *I don't know much about the Vietnamese pop culture status.

  • welp the consumer base in china is MASSIVE so even if there is interesting stuff they aren't in a rush to export to anyone; the US market is smaller than the chinese market whereas the dynamic for korea is that the US market is bigger than the Korean market, for example. There would be more children in china than the whole population of US, given time.


    Idk for vietnam.

    Yes, the answer mentions that. Japan and SOKOR are export oriented, while China need not be.

  • look people all over the world do find certain cultures more appealing than others and you can't really do anything about it


    Btw the richer a country, the higher their production value and marketing and people are drawn to visual and production quality too


    And marketing aka soft power is extremely powerful

    Certain nations choose to spend more time and effort on it than others and it gives them more soft power globally so..

    u r m o m g a y

    1e1282e4806e9f6f1080ccc53055ea21c0a98974.gifv6cc52730ebd88d19753cac6a9c1436f129e99705.gifv

  • it also seems international - political alignment. SK and JPN are both tight allies with USA but Vietnam is somewhat neutral and China stands in opposition. There is a kinda "oh you suppport *those* people?" if you like things from opposing countries. At least from my experience tooting the horn of chinese tv dramas in the US.

  • find certain cultures more appealing than others

    Yes, but the 'why' can be explored.


    There is definitely a White-Western fascination for the sexualized Asian, it is a known fetish.

    So porn-adjacent anime/effeminate Kpop, is it catering to that? Is that the reason for the popularity?


    That is what this answer is positing.

  • yea that and some countries prefer hard power for the simple reason that its a bit more reliable in an aggressive global environment. Money seems to be china's choice, seconded by military.

  • it also seems international - political alignment. SK and JPN are both tight allies with USA but Vietnam is somewhat neutral and China stands in opposition. There is a kinda "oh you suppport *those* people?" if you like things from opposing countries. At least from my experience tooting the horn of chinese tv dramas in the US.

    I also think there are political biases against both Vietnam and China.: communism (Vietnam war and now current conflict in China)

  • yea that and some countries prefer hard power for the simple reason that its a bit more reliable in an aggressive global environment. Money seems to be china's choice, seconded by military.

    True

    I mean there's so many rich European nations whose media isn't popular at all and that's because they don't really invest in marketing it globally

    u r m o m g a y

    1e1282e4806e9f6f1080ccc53055ea21c0a98974.gifv6cc52730ebd88d19753cac6a9c1436f129e99705.gifv

  • very easy


    China ? it’s HARD to follow Cpop if ur not chinese

    no it’s not that China isn’t appealing , YWY2 was massively popular just look at the views on the performances and episodes ( their cover of The Eve has 20 MILLION views ) and THE9 are decently popular outside of China for a Cpop group , they were rlly popular when the show ended but thing is there is barely any translated content of them

    how do u keep up w a group when you don’t get any content

    China is too closed . not enough content for ifans bc they don’t rlly care about promoting overseas they don’t even have their groups songs on Spotify

  • I wouldn't personally count liking anime and kpop as being appreciative of Korean and Japanese culture. Most people who consume those things don't actually care about the culture itself which is why the myth of Japan as a Utopia persists among anime fans (I honestly don't know if kpop/kdramas share something similar but I wouldn't be surprised.)

  • Yeah, I would tend to agree that it's due to a concerted effort by the industries and Korean government to become cultural exporters.


    For kpop in particular, I would also say that kpop embraces a lot of western influences following a lot of western trends and even incorporating a lot of English lyrics. Plus, the sounds of Korean are closer to the sounds of latin-based languages than Vietnamese or Mandarin so the western listeners may have an easier time with the transition.

  • Globally I think China as a country isn’t appealing, and Vietnam just needs to put in more work.

    Actually, I think they are quite appealing. Their Manhua's/Donghua's King's Avatar and Mo Dao Zu Shi/Grandmaster of demonic cultivation/TheUntamed and Heaven's Official Blessing were extremely popular intenationally. They also have games like Genshin Impact that is hugely successful.


    The problem with China is that as soon as something is doing well they ruin it by making a bunch of asinine regulations. They ruined their idol market because "effeminate men" and idols have too much influence or something like that, and then they ruin the BL market for similar reasons. The old fart in power in China is out of touch with younger people.


    As for Vietnam, I don't know anything about that. I think the most images (at least Americans) have about Vietnam is stuff about the War. That's the only time I think it's really mentioned in pop culture.

  • this quote is so yucky :huuh:


    are they really feeling superior about the fact that the men who became famous from their country aren't "effeminate" ( yikes cant believe they used that word)

    Where did you get that from


    The quote is clearly pointing out that yhe rest of the world clearly only interested in parts of asian media that are unique and interesting to them

    And all other cultures push for masculinity so that distinction has certainly helped kpop and such to attract a huge hungry niche

    u r m o m g a y

    1e1282e4806e9f6f1080ccc53055ea21c0a98974.gifv6cc52730ebd88d19753cac6a9c1436f129e99705.gifv

  • yea its like the prereq is to be overseas chinese or fluent in chinese and chinese culture haha

  • I have watched Youth With You it was amazing show the trainees are so talented, i was crazy Xin Liu fan, but after the show ended they just call it a day giving them cheap ass mv and few songs, there are no ready market system for cpop groups in china, members make most of their money through advertisements, endorsements, cf deals, reality shows and dramas/films etc not music, and its fucking hard to find their contents u need chinese apps for everything u need to learn chinese

    they just don't try to export but idk why they put some of their chinese dramas free on youtube with eng sub :melon_think: if they didn't use to i would miss so much cus some chinese dramas are very good

  • yea its like the prereq is to be overseas chinese or fluent in chinese and chinese culture haha

    yep they rlly don’t gaf

    idk if i can blame them bc technically china is such a big country that u don’t need oversea fans . the groups will be selling 5M with ease in their home country so why bother — like it’s frustrating but im not surprised that they’re like this 🥲🥲🥲

  • I don’t know what you mean but Chinese dramas are really popular. And Chinese movies have been popular decades before Korean movies. Like stuff like crouching Tiger hidden dragon are cult classic long before Korean media ever picked up. And pretty sure untamed is bigger than all kdrama sans maybe like squid game.


    Sure cpop isn’t as big as kpop. But as far as other media is concerned it is very much consumed.

  • I have watched Youth With You it was amazing show the trainees are so talented, i was crazy Xin Liu fan, but after the show ended they just call it a day giving them cheap ass mv and few songs, there are no ready market system for cpop groups in china, members make most of their money through advertisements, endorsements, cf deals, reality shows and dramas/films etc not music, and its fucking hard to find their contents u need chinese apps for everything u need to learn chinese

    they just don't try to export but idk why they put some of their chinese dramas free on youtube with eng sub :melon_think: if they didn't use to i would miss so much cus some chinese dramas are very good

    It's only very recently that kdramas started getting released with subs. I remember having to find bootlegged pirated sites for years to watch kdramas. I'm glad that netflix seems to be investing in more international shows nowadays.

  • Happy someone mentioned politics.


    Korea/Japan: Capitalist/Democratic Societies


    Vietnam/China: Socialiast/Communist Societies


    China and US relations are weird, and China only exports products but has a tight reign on media. They have no problem exporting shows, but they don't seem to care much about promoting Chinese musical artists.


    As far as Vietnam,...China, Japan, and Korea are all first world/developed countries. Vietnam is not. So it would be even harder for their artists to have any influence or prominence in the international market. That requires money.

    PGDPGT PRETTY GIRLS DOING PRETTY GIRL THINGS

    fc48bd06c65bdda5a70662a95298c58967e2efac.gifv2388a663244f2a30b386bac2c9600bc97508161c.gifv


  • Chinese pop culture have all the ingredients to be popular BUT also all the reason that stop them


    1. Politics - and to some extent social acceptance/ they do not align with western values so it is a hard pill for audience to swallow and for the media to promote

    2. They a work in progress - China economic growth is after both Korea and Japan, and the Chinese government have only put in effort to promote the film industry. The music industry and others are still developing and in its infancy.

    3. Strict censorship - this really kill a lot of creativity and ability to produce better pop culture content if people are so restrict on what can create

    4. Protectionism - China is a rising consumer market. So their primary focus is to be able to harvest their own consumption using domestic production FIRST, before they can venture out and capture foreign consumption. There is a priority that just make sense.


    China is a huge country with potentially huge influence so that get them attention from the world. They also have an old culture that exotic enough to peak people interest. The older days of HK entertainment show you they can make good pop content (which is based on Chinese culture). But right now, is not the time or priority for them.


    As for Vietnam, they are still a developing country that is focusing on increasing their domestic production and economy. They have other industries they are busy improving before they can care about exporting their own pop culture anyway. They are kind of like China but 1-2 steps behind.

  • I don’t know what you mean but Chinese dramas are really popular. And Chinese movies have been popular decades before Korean movies. Like stuff like crouching Tiger hidden dragon are cult classic long before Korean media ever picked up. And pretty sure untamed is bigger than all kdrama sans maybe like squid game.


    Sure cpop isn’t as big as kpop. But as far as other media is concerned it is very much consumed.

    Those are the kungfu types mentioned. Chinese myth/fantasy do well, but not contemporary culture.

  • If liberal politics, then Taiwanese is not popular either. Please read the linked answer fully.

  • It's only very recently that kdramas started getting released with subs. I remember having to find bootlegged pirated sites for years to watch kdramas. I'm glad that netflix seems to be investing in more international shows nowadays.

    kdramas? i was saying chinese dramas :-)

    some chinese dramas are free on youtube with eng sub on we tv english, yoyo english channel, youku english etc, i have watched so many chinese dramas on youtube like that, so i was just wondering if they don't like export their media why they bother to release it free in youtube with eng sub, they even have indo, arabic, spanish, viet, thai channel to release their dramas with those language subs

  • kdramas? i was saying chinese dramas :-)

    some chinese dramas are free on youtube with eng sub on we tv english, yoyo english channel, youku english etc, i have watched so many chinese dramas on youtube like that, so i was just wondering if they don't like export their media why they bother to release it free in youtube with eng sub, they even have indo, arabic, spanish, viet, thai channel to release their dramas with those language subs

    You brought up a good point. I start seeing so many of these Chinese drama with Eng subs flooding on YouTube since early 2020. I really wonder what’s the point? But most of these are also low quality web drama anyway. I wonder if they earn much money posting on YouTube and why is it allow when YouTube is blocked in China?


    It would be nice if someone has answer for that.

  • This thread contains 63 more posts that have been hidden for guests, please register yourself or login to continue reading.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!