Fans in New York going crazy over NingNing

Ningning you will always be famous

Concussion is temporary Kwangya is eternal

They're gorgeous, that's why! It's so cute that she seemed a little shy to see such fans' reactions

Hit me too.

I heard some American Mys were fighting over Ningning pcs, the buns one especially is so hard to ship. This is probably a shock to her because she’s the least popular in Korea.

Quote from SooYoung

new york My are so lucky

I live nearby but I’m not going to go see them — I’m just happy we’re breathing the same air haha. My friend lives nearby and said there were so many fans around, she could see them a block away.

They're really pretty I'm so happy fans were able to welcome them

Quote from SendFoodPics

I heard some American Mys were fighting over Ningning pcs, the buns one especially is so hard to ship. This is probably a shock to her because she’s the least popular in Korea.

Really? How even

Quote from Wench

Really? How even

Karina and Winter are super popular it girl level in South Korea. There’s a popularity gap and then it’s Giselle. Giselle has had more fans since Savage (it is her era) and she’s very effortlessly funny. Her Korean is also a lot stronger than her Japanese — she reminds netizens of SES’s Shoo a lot. She’s also become more confident on camera now. Well for starters Ningning is Chinese and her visuals are more internationally friendly — while Karina/Winter/Giselle follow more k beauty standards. Also it’s not that she isn’t popular it’s just that Karina and Winter are on another level. I believe there were a lot of OT3 fans at the beginning because of Ningning’s nationality but I’m unsure as if that still remains so.

Quote from SendFoodPics

Karina and Winter are super popular it girl level in South Korea. There’s a popularity gap and then it’s Giselle. Giselle has had more fans since Savage (it is her era) and she’s very effortlessly funny. Her Korean is also a lot stronger than her Japanese — she reminds netizens of SES’s Shoo a lot. She’s also become more confident on camera now. Well for starters Ningning is Chinese and her visuals are more internationally friendly — while Karina/Winter/Giselle follow more k beauty standards. Also it’s not that she isn’t popular it’s just that Karina and Winter are on another level. I believe there were a lot of OT3 fans at the beginning because of Ningning’s nationality but I’m unsure as if that still remains so.

That all makes sense, especially with her being Chinese. And least popular in a group like aespa is still firmly one percenter territory.

Quote from SendFoodPics

I heard some American Mys were fighting over Ningning pcs, the buns one especially is so hard to ship. This is probably a shock to her because she’s the least popular in Korea.

wait I think that’s one of the ones I got lol (and I didn’t bulk buy). I am gonna go check

nice

Quote from SendFoodPics

I heard some American Mys were fighting over Ningning pcs, the buns one especially is so hard to ship. This is probably a shock to her because she’s the least popular in Korea.

she's chinese after all. she kind of reminds me of lisa in terms of popularity, they are both the least popular in korea but more popular internationally.

i don't follow anything aespa, i heard their title songs and listened to their album but i don't plan on stanning them or following extra context. but ningning is the cutest and prettiest, i cannot take eyes of her :) i'm not surprised she got the reaction she got, her twitter likes also prove she's internationally popular

Why do people need to have a problem with her nationality

She's gorgeous and cute that's what matters not where she's from.

Quote from Yumeku

wait I think that’s one of the ones I got lol (and I didn’t bulk buy). I am gonna go check

LUCKY

Do you have this?

I really want

Leftmost PC

Quote from bartkun

this comment ended me :D "One of the fansite hit me in the head with their camera but I saw NingNing"

why care about being hit in the head? when it's more important to see NingNing!!

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Display More

I am sorry but my eyes are stuck at Karina. She is so beautiful.

glad ningning got much love in NYC