which 3rd generation group have most hit songs Bts, Twice, BP or Red velvet

Bts - idol,fake love, dna ,bst, dynamite,bwl,spring day,mic drop,slr,on

blackpink- pwf , aiiyl,hylt,ktl,d4,forever young,ice cream,whistle

twice-kk, cu,tt,fsl,dtna,fancy,yoy,loa

Quote from hueningkaiskai

Bts - idol,fake love, dna ,bst, dynamite,bwl,spring day,mic drop,slr

blackpink- pwf , aiiyl,hylt,ktl,d4,forever young,ice cream

twice-kk, cu,tt,yoy,wil,dtna,fancy

blackpink- whistle,pwf , aiiyl,hylt,(ktl),d4,forever young,(ice cream), lovesick girls, SOLO
ktl was a moderate hit, ice cream was sub par.

again the question depends on what you define as hit songs

Depends on what level of success you define a hit as.


If the cut off is really low, BTS or Twice since they release a lot and do generally well.
If the cut off is a bit higher, getting rid of some of the normal level hits like most of Twice's and some of BTS' earlier stuff, it would be BP for sure.
If the cut off is really high (like Spring Day level), most songs are out and only a few remain, probably BTS or maybeeee BP depending on how HYLT and LSG end up doing in the long run.

Twice, they have the most no.1 hits on Gaon.

BTS

Quote from king-in-north

I am talking about normal hits only like fancy,Hip,ktl. Big level hits depend upon song and hype around the song and public likeness

In that case it's pretty even between all three groups.

Quote from king-in-north

I am talking about normal hits only like fancy,Hip,ktl. Big level hits depend upon song and hype around the song and public likeness

well you still haven't defined what a normal hit is?

is it charting based?

it is youtube?

is it albums sold?

is it top 50 melon a normal hit?

top 20 melon?

how many UL?

is it streams?

does spotify count?

All BTS singles were hits except before I need U era

BP has hits since their debut. The only disadvantage is their discography is smaller.

I'm not sure about bts but twice has about 11 hits.

I think BP has 8? They would have more if they came back more often.

I think all 3 are probably at a similar level tbh.

since everyone is gonne call their faves then MY FAVES

That depends on if international figures are included or not. If its included its either Bp or Bts.

If its just based on korea it could be either of the 3 depending on the cutoff for hit size

Quote from hueningkaiskai

Bts - idol,fake love, dna ,bst, dynamite,bwl,spring day,mic drop,slr

blackpink- pwf , aiiyl,hylt,ktl,d4,forever young,ice cream

twice-kk, cu,tt,yoy,wil,dtna,fancy

not u forgetting bwl and lsg

Quote from guineverebp

not u forgetting bwl and lsg

i didnt forget bwl

and ill give lsg some more time before i call it a hit

Quote from ill-pray-4-u

Depends on what level of success you define a hit as.


If the cut off is really low, BTS or Twice since they release a lot and do generally well.
If the cut off is a bit higher, getting rid of some of the normal level hits like most of Twice's and some of BTS' earlier stuff, it would be BP for sure.
If the cut off is really high (like Spring Day level), most songs are out and only a few remain, probably BTS or maybeeee BP depending on how HYLT and LSG end up doing in the long run.

also this https://mobile.twitter.com/chartsblackpink/status/1356261514236325894

bts and bp

Quote from hueningkaiskai

i didnt forget bwl

and ill give lsg some more time before i call it a hit

on is a bigger hit than mic drop

Quote from guineverebp

on is a bigger hit than mic drop

on kcharts

mic drop did better on bb100 and does better on other streaming sites

Quote from hueningkaiskai

on kcharts

mic drop did better on bb100 and does better on other streaming sites

on did peak higher on bb though. add on

Quote from guineverebp

on did peak higher on bb though. add on

hmm okay

Quote from hueningkaiskai

i didnt forget bwl

and ill give lsg some more time before i call it a hit

You put SLR and its like three weeks at the bottom of the melon top 10 as a "hit" yet LSG breaking records you need to give more time?

There's some clear lack of objectivity there.

Quote from ill-pray-4-u

You put SLR and it's like three weeks at the bottom of the melon top 10 as a "hit" yet LSG breaking records you need to give more time?

There's some clear lack of objectivity there.

im counting international achievements too and it went #1 on bb

Quote from hueningkaiskai

im counting international achievements too and it went #1 on bb

Convenient but alright then please explain the logic behind putting BS&T up because LSG did better internationally and so far domestically.

Quote from ill-pray-4-u

Convenient but alright then please explain the logic behind putting BS&T up because LSG did better internationally and so far domestically.

ill remove it

Twice

BTS

BP

Red velvet

I always assumed it was Twice tbh. But BTS has always been downplayed before so I don’t know. Only now I realised BTS has really good digitals since Fire or Dope? BP is also known to be a digimon so I guess all 3.

(Tired of “which is the best” threads Let’s split the prize into 3, people)

BTS, tho i think Twice still has the most number ones i think BTS will end with the most based on current digitals

Quote from hueningkaiskai

Bts - idol,fake love, dna ,bst, dynamite,bwl,spring day,mic drop,slr,on

blackpink- pwf , aiiyl,hylt,ktl,d4,forever young,ice cream

twice-kk, cu,tt,yoy,wil,dtna,fancy

Also LOA for Twice

Quote from sadsavely

BTS, tho i think Twice still has the most number ones i think BTS will end with the most based on current digitals

Also LOA for Twice

nope and number ones doesnt mean much a lot of twices hits were front loaded with not much longevity

Quote from hueningkaiskai

Bts - idol,fake love, dna ,bst, dynamite,bwl,spring day,mic drop,slr,on

blackpink- pwf , aiiyl,hylt,ktl,d4,forever young,ice cream

twice-kk, cu,tt,yoy,wil,dtna,fancy

How is whistle not a hit? It is at least on the same level as songs like ice cream, fancy and WIL and on the same level as Forever young if both international and korea is included and is bigger than all of them in korea

I think LOA is bigger than YOY or WIL tbh it simply has way better longetivity

Quote from hueningkaiskai

im counting international achievements too and it went #1 on bb

I'm curious, since international achievements are being considered would you include FS for Twice since it was the most streamed korean song last year and recieved a platinum cert one of only 3 songs to do so, plus its hella long longetivity on BB (over 65 weeks)?

most likely BTS as they have 3 entire years of only releasing hit songs (with much more releases than BP).

Quote from sadsavely

I'm curious, since international achievements are being considered would you include FS for Twice since it was the most streamed korean song last year and recieved a platinum cert one of only 3 songs to do so, plus its hella long longetivity on BB (over 65 weeks)?

nope it didnt do well on the kcharts if it had i wouldve included it

Quote from hueningkaiskai

nope it didnt do well on the kcharts if it had i wouldve included it

You do realise the only song by a korean act that is bigger than Feel Special in Japan is Dynamite. Thats it. Thats how big the song is in Japan. If Ice Cream is included based on its US achievements than Feel Special should cause of its Japanese ones.

Quote from worldlove27

You do realise the only song by a korean act that is bigger than Feel Special in Japan is Dynamite. Thats it. Thats how big the song is in Japan. If Ice Cream is included based on its US achievements than Feel Special should cause of its Japanese ones.

no one cares

go make your own if youre so bothered smh

Quote from hueningkaiskai

nope and number ones doesnt mean much a lot of twices hits were front loaded with not much longevity

It has both streaming and download certs and made it to Melon's top 100 of the decade