[theqoo] (G)I-DLE's Miyeon performance from MBC Drama Awards deleted on Naver + Miyeon posts apologize on IG saying she was nervous

It wasn't terribly bad it was just very pitchy and you could tell she was nervous singing fully live. she needs more vocal training that's all.

Because of stress or not it shows she really needs more experience singing live without a loud backtrack.

Heartbreaking to see her feel bad about it.. She's my bias in G-IDLE

This is probably a downside of doing too many prerecorded or loud backtrack performances. She's also been quite busy for a long time now MC'ing and doing variety shows so I can kind of understand getting complacent over time.

I just hope she doesn't start fearing singing live because of this. I get that she's nervous but that in itself is a problem, a main vocal can't be nervous about singing. There's really no other solution but to practice more and then sing live more.

Miyeon-ah

The main vocal was nervous to sing live after over 5 years since debut... I hope she does not get nervous anymore.

This is how almost everyone sounds truly live if they're nervous.

We've been so conditioned to listen to autotuned vocals and loud backtracks that the sound of an actual human being singing sounds off to us.

This doesnt impact how i feel about Miyeon, not only is she in the highest tier of visuals, she is also in the highest tier of vocals for me, i value vocal color over vocal technique. And her tone is so unique, so distinctive unlike 98 percent of the rest of Kpop, that it will take a lot for me to bring her down a tier.

It was ok.

Better than a group lip-syncing in perfect pitch every single note, and their company astroturfing they are live.

Even if she failed a stage, it doesn't deserve bashing. Miyeon fighting

Quote from K-PL

It was ok.

Better than a group lip-syncing in perfect pitch every single note, and their company astroturfing they are live.

One of your best comments yet tbh. The amount of times i see fan comments on Kpop vids screaming about their faves singing live and sounding so good...omg, it just makes me realize that they have all grown up in the age of autotune and backtracks and dont have a clue what a real human voice sounds like, esp one that is forced to do choreo at the same time.

There is a reason why you never see literal legends like Pavarotti doing the running man while singing Nessun Dorma.

Below is what a live performance with some backtracks thrown in sounds like. Singers will almost always sing flat when they're live and esp when they have to focus on choreo. Plus the obvious shakiness and inability to support their vocals while dancing, they end up having to shout sing. All in all Stayc did a wonderful job given the difficulty of this song and them having to dance while doing it.

It’s not that bad honestly

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

One of your best comments yet tbh. The amount of times i see fan comments on Kpop vids screaming about their faves singing live and sounding so good...omg, it just makes me realize that they have all grown up in the age of autotune and backtracks and dont have a clue what a real human voice sounds like, esp one that is forced to do choreo at the same time.

There is a reason why you never see literal legends like Pavarotti doing the running man while singing Nessun Dorma.

Below is what a live performance with some backtracks thrown in sounds like. Singers will almost always sing flat when they're live and esp when they have to focus on choreo. Plus the obvious shakiness and inability to support their vocals while dancing, they end up having to shout sing. All in all Stayc did a wonderful job given the difficulty of this song and them having to dance while doing it.

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Display More

How tf do Sieun and Yoon sound even better during all those chest contractions

I've heard way worse live vocals in kpop, and being praised tbh.

She was nervous, started off-key and stayed off-key, unfortunate but it's understandable. She still has a very pretty vocal color, kudos for actually singing live.

Quote from Wench

How tf do Sieun and Yoon sound even better during all those chest contractions

Facts. They sound effortless with their upper register belting.

99 percent of idols cant do this live, which i'm fine with, i dont mind lip syncing or loud backtracks. What i do object to are fans listening to obvious lip sync or loud backtrack stages and then praising them for having "insane vocals omg" .

As everyone keeps saying visuals trump vocals any day of the week

I guess it's easier to sing in a group.

She just needs to practice more and she'll get better.

I remember Seulgi being so nervous at her first concert solo performance.

15-year-old BoA faced the same thing in Japan so it's normal.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

One of your best comments yet tbh. The amount of times i see fan comments on Kpop vids screaming about their faves singing live and sounding so good...omg, it just makes me realize that they have all grown up in the age of autotune and backtracks and dont have a clue what a real human voice sounds like, esp one that is forced to do choreo at the same time.

There is a reason why you never see literal legends like Pavarotti doing the running man while singing Nessun Dorma.

Below is what a live performance with some backtracks thrown in sounds like. Singers will almost always sing flat when they're live and esp when they have to focus on choreo. Plus the obvious shakiness and inability to support their vocals while dancing, they end up having to shout sing. All in all Stayc did a wonderful job given the difficulty of this song and them having to dance while doing it.

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Display More

Isa is sush an underrated vocal