BABYMONSTER "Batter Up" Was Really Flop Asf For Me

Yesterday...

BP Batter Up: 1,018,748

mina (@minazwki) on X

ou podemos nos orgulhar disso; streams de ontem: drama: 1,164,263 baddie: 459,754 off the record: 232,267 either way: 156,606 total: 848,627 detalhe q…

twitter.com

Ive Baddie: 459,754

Aespa Drama: 1,164,263

You already told your opinion in previous thread.

Thread

My Unpopular Opinions On BABYMONSTER "Batter Up" M/V...

forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/277695/


Music Video :

Pretty all over the place.
Same like their outfits, no clear direction as you can see.
The sets individually was cute and well put together.
Definitely reminded me of a BlackPink music video with the change of set every 30 seconds haha

Song/Lyrics :

Now for the song, I gotta be real here....i wasnt too impressed.
It felt like any regular girl crush song. Nothing to really make you think twice or anything to make you feel like "oouuu they did the…

tokki-swag

Nov 26th 2023

If you don't want to support them fine, but instead making multiple negative threads about them, you should leave them alone. The girls just debuted three weeks ago, they don't deserve that kind of behavior.

I only listen to Blackpink's version it's just so much better

Quote from tokki-swag

ma'am what does that have to do with me, idgaf about that..so........

It means if they flopped af, then globally another "big" group flopped even harder, and another "big" group is the same level.

Dupe thread?

Thread

My Unpopular Opinions On BABYMONSTER "Batter Up" M/V...

forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/277695/


Music Video :

Pretty all over the place.
Same like their outfits, no clear direction as you can see.
The sets individually was cute and well put together.
Definitely reminded me of a BlackPink music video with the change of set every 30 seconds haha

Song/Lyrics :

Now for the song, I gotta be real here....i wasnt too impressed.
It felt like any regular girl crush song. Nothing to really make you think twice or anything to make you feel like "oouuu they did the…

tokki-swag

Nov 26th 2023

Anyways, anyone think the attention in the beginning of the MV is them trying to copy newjeans?

Like it feels like it was added last minute after the creators of the MV saw Newjeans attention debut song.

Not surprised coming from a hybe stan, no one asked you to play it anyway lmao

Quote from L0ok

Dupe thread?

Thread

My Unpopular Opinions On BABYMONSTER "Batter Up" M/V...

forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/277695/


Music Video :

Pretty all over the place.
Same like their outfits, no clear direction as you can see.
The sets individually was cute and well put together.
Definitely reminded me of a BlackPink music video with the change of set every 30 seconds haha

Song/Lyrics :

Now for the song, I gotta be real here....i wasnt too impressed.
It felt like any regular girl crush song. Nothing to really make you think twice or anything to make you feel like "oouuu they did the…

tokki-swag

Nov 26th 2023

Anyways, anyone think the attention in the beginning of the MV is them trying to copy newjeans?

Like it feels like it was added last minute after the creators of the MV saw Newjeans attention debut song.

This is like saying Newjeans wanted to copy Gidle, because they have "Oh My God" MV as well. And wait Newjeans got league collab just like Gidle. I guess Newjeans are copying Gidle after all.

Quote from kirishiki

This is like saying Newjeans wanted to copy Gidle, because they have "Oh My God" MV as well. And wait Newjeans got league collab just like Gidle. I guess Newjeans are copying Gidle after all.

Mate omg were used in completely different ways with different meanings and Riot asked newjeans to do the collab.

Both Attention and Batter up are debut songs from their own respective groups and they both used attention as a way to bring attention to the new group.

Dont say ''for me'' say FOR ALL OF US. Cuz yikessssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss

The song was okay for me but when their fandom was bragging on how BM would end the top 4th gen ggs when they haven't even debut yet, them doing okay in spotify/youtube will be considered a flop.

Biggest flop debut in the history of the big 3 for a reason, it was a flop for all of us....no matter how many views YG pays for.

Quote from Locke1

The song was okay for me but when their fandom was bragging on how BM would end the top 4th gen ggs when they haven't even debut yet, them doing okay in spotify/youtube will be considered a flop.

The already ended one 4th gen group globally. The receipts are in an above post.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5. BabyMonster

6. Ive

and fyi Korea hasn't mattered since BTS and BP started doing stadium concerts globally, the point at which Korean revenue drops below 2%-3% of total revenue. So the only charts that really matter now are the global billboard/spotify/youtube streaming charts.

I did not like it that much, but it got a bit better after some listenings I think.

Quote from L0ok

Both Attention and Batter up are debut songs

Actually they are not. Cookie was first digital release for NewJeans while Batter Up was for Babymonster

Attention and Hype Boy was pre-releases, while Babymonster got Dream as pre-release

Yall would've made it a hit if BM was a 4 member group and song was released an year earlier (before newjeans debut). It really isn't worse than Boombayah which was saved by Lisa and Jennie.

Quote from TheBotter

Biggest flop debut in the history of the big 3 for a reason, it was a flop for all of us....no matter how many views YG pays for.

ah this is so dramatic response

Quote from TheBotter

Biggest flop debut in the history of the big 3 for a reason, it was a flop for all of us....no matter how many views YG pays for.

lol, that's an overreaction.

They are still doing better than O.O stats-wise.

I am looking forward to their first cb.

Quote from elliejr

Yall would've made it a hit if BM was a 4 member group and song was released an year earlier (before newjeans debut). It really isn't worse than Boombayah which was saved by Lisa and Jennie.

Boombayah was miles better. But they have barely lifted a finger, and already taken out one 4th gen girl group, at the global level.

It's YG formula again, they will be in top 2 in a year or two.

I think the reason you think like that is because of Baby Monster didnt promote their song Batter Up in music shows but i think it doesnt means that they flop, the song was actually good for a debut song, it was not perfect but was good enough for a debut song. and also they have lots of fans all over the world

Quote from K-PL

Boombayah was miles better. But they have barely lifted a finger, and already taken out one 4th gen girl group, at the global level.

I never liked bbmbya.

I think its decent and grows and I think if they perfrormed it on music shows would have turned into a mini hit.

Quote from TheBotter

Biggest flop debut in the history of the big 3 for a reason, it was a flop for all of us....no matter how many views YG pays for.

Yeah no Treasure debut was worse, YG paid for views like the others have done and even without the ad views they are ahead of everyone else so..

Quote from Locke1

The song was okay for me but when their fandom was bragging on how BM would end the top 4th gen ggs when they haven't even debut yet, them doing okay in spotify/youtube will be considered a flop.

If YG had to pick global or Korea they would pick global.

Quote from hieuken

lol, that's an overreaction.

They are still doing better than O.O stats-wise.

I am looking forward to their first cb.

If your comparing them to Nmixx, who was widely laughed off the kpop scene during their debut, then you’ve already lost

Being “better than O.O” isn’t an achievement

YG share price ready trending back down to it's yearly low. Small company things I guess

Quote from tokki-swag

im still tryna get the point of how that has something to do with me.

i said a OPINION for MEEEEEEE.

if they were flop for ME, then that has nothing to do with whoever else or whatever u tryna show me...because i don't care

Sure but numbers dont lie

Quote from Kouss

If your comparing them to Nmixx, who was widely laughed off the kpop scene during their debut, then you’ve already lost

Being “better than O.O” isn’t an achievement

Okay how about globally they are doing better then any gen 4 girl group,boygroup ?

Quote from K-PL

Boombayah was miles better. But they have barely lifted a finger, and already taken out one 4th gen girl group, at the global level.

It was a time when I didn't know kpop. I remember thinking that I would try a Blackpink song for the first time and listening to Boombayah, and finding the song very boring. Yes, the rap parts were good, but the song did not appeal to me very much. Debut song ranking for me was Happiness > Like Ohh Ahh > Boombayah. Batter Up was definitely in this style. But I found Whistle more interesting. Maybe their next song will be more unique like Whistle.

Quote from ForgottenSoul

Okay how about globally they are doing better then any gen 4 girl group,boygroup ?

Batter up already got over 2 million likes in 3 weeks which is like top 5 most liked gg MV this year and you can not buy likes like views. Let people cope it flopped hard

Still on repeat.

Quote from ForgottenSoul

Okay how about globally they are doing better then any gen 4 girl group,boygroup ?

Spotify and Youtube are there only metrics tho.

We can just correct the criticism to they flopped in Korea, which no one would argue against.

Quote from ForgottenSoul

If YG had to pick global or Korea they would pick global.

I'm sorry, but if they plan to be Stray Kids (popular globally, irrelevant in Korea) then fine, but i don't think any GG currently survives on that model and i'd be surprised in BM was the first one to try it and succeed.

It's indeed a pretty bad song

Not O.O-level of bad, but YG-level of bad

Anyway

Baemon is YG's TxT

Right now their decent digital performance on YB and Spotify can be resumed as Blinks streaming

They are not flopping, but it's clear they failed to reach the main audience and are surviving from a bubble

This is degraded quickly. If YG wants them to survive, Baemon will need to crave their own market niche. They will have several opportunities to do that, there is no need for despair. TxT found their market niche eventually, BM can do too I think

Typical YG crap music. Exactly the reason I don't listen to YG groups.

Quote from ForgottenSoul

Okay how about globally they are doing better then any gen 4 girl group,boygroup ?

When wotad is making more sense than you, you know you fucked up