Who’s Bigger in SK? Aespa now or Red Velvet at their peak?

Aespa has been described as one of the biggest celebrities in South Korea today. Red Velvet was one of the biggest girl groups domestically for several years. So I have a question for 3rd gen stans who are still around today. Is the popularity in Korea Aespa has today comparable to the popularity Red Velvet had during their peak

Quote from Beesknees

RV at their peak.

They topped the charts and had Irene

Karina is more popular than Irene though…….

Quote from Beesknees

No she isn’t…

Irene’s peak was unbelievably high.

Barely anyone knew her

Quote from Beesknees

Sure Jan. Still salty about Twice’s lack of legacy it seems

Twice cant help it they are a nugu group. They did the best from what they had. Irene is from SM so it's surprising how unknown she is.

Quote from butterbutterfly

Thread

Is Aespa bigger than Red velvet?

whos the biggest girl group from SM entertaiment (after snsd ofcourse).. is it aespa or red velvet ? and in term of legacy, who have it bigger in your opinion ?

girlgroupstan21

Aug 8th 2023

Thread

Is aespa bigger than red velvet now?

Thoughts?

twicesuuuu

Aug 21st 2021

what this tells me is another thread was due

Quote from SooYoung

people are really obsess with trying to pit red velvet against Aespa

why you all don't have the same energy with Twice x itzy or 2NE1 x BP -_-

Twice x Itzy= Twice higher peak

2NE1 x BP= BP higher peak

Ok those questions answered now answer the question.

Quote from SooYoung

yeah that's my point

people are so obsess with trying to pit Aespa and red velvet against each other

but doesn't have the same energy with other groups

where are the thread about :

" Who had the quickest fall in korea itzy or Twice"

"who have more chance to get a hit again itzy or twice"

etc.....

no it's always just red velvet and aespa

Display More

Itzy had a quicker fall

Maybe Itzy since they are younger

ok both questions answered again. Now answer the question

Quote from likeastarr

op gotta be trolling saying barely anyone knew irene lol she was super popular during her peak. though karina has not reached her peak yet so we'll see

name 22 people that knew Irene that arent celebrities

Quote from thelightoftruth

Lmao OP trying to be slick.

I heard JYP's still copping grief over his embarrassing clownery a couple of days ago.

Don't you have a protecc JYP thread to be in?

The paycheck from JYP already cleared so im good now. Answer the question already

Quote from SooYoung

I think OP is just not over the JYP blacklash and the NJ vs Twice thread yet

it was too much for him in a such short amount of time

NJ peaked higher than Twice.

now answer the question coward

Quote from likeastarr

bob rob maria lara rachel ross joey chandler monica phoebe gunther mike mary susan blair serena chuck nate jenny dan linda & anna

damn.... alright maybe Irene was popular didn't think you could actually do it.

Quote from thelightoftruth

Lmao, the thing is you're mistaking me for a success stan. Both groups are my faves and I don't spend a second of my day thinking about which group is bigger.

I'd have to go and research this, so instead of being lazy, why don't you go research it yourself, come back and post something with substance, and then I can agree with whatever your take is.

Nice try though, imagine being so desperate to try and bait a couple of fandoms into arguing.

Display More

Why would two fandoms fight over asking who is at a peak? Once and Bunnies, that's new jeans fandom right?, didn't really fight at all. I only want peaceful and nice discussions stating the obvious that Red Velvet clears Aespa without much competition. I dont need research I lived through both times. But that's just my opinion though.

Quote from kingkook

I remember you making a thread saying only people who have visited Korea can give their opinion about a kpop group's popularity in Korea, hence I'm gonna refrain from answering this question.

have you seen a picture of Korea? Then you get a pass

Quote from alexS

too old, won't merge.

But to keep on thread:

Irene became the Visual.

what's the time limit on merging of similar threads?

Quote from thelightoftruth

Nah opinion won't cut it. Go out and do the research. Don't be lazy about it.

Dont need research. I lived through it. You wouldnt ask Jesus to do research on turning water into wine or walking on water. He has been through it already.