WHo is better? IVE or NewJeans?

Eleven >>> NJ whole discography

Idk, you tell me

You didn't even publicize the participants.

I demand a do-over. Close this thread.

I like both groups, but personal taste, I’d say new jeans. I like their title tracks more.

Quote from ellenote

I like both groups, but personal taste, I’d say new jeans. I like their title tracks more.

You are delusional and need help.

Quote from OnceMidzy4ever

Nah.

Okay.

Quote from Polarize

You are delusional and need help.

That wasn't very nice

New Jeans.

Tier 1 members = Wonyoung, Yujin, Minji

Tier 2 members = Liz, Rei, Leeseo, Gaeul, Dany

Tier 3 members = Hanni, Haerin, Hyein

Song Rankings:

S Tier = I AM, Off the Record, I Want, Afterlike

A Tier = Kitsch, OMG

B Tier = Eleven

C Tier = Love Dive, Either Way, Hybe Boy, Baddie, Attention

D Tier = Super Shy, Ditto

F Tier = ETA, Cookie, Hurt

Ive songs are dopamine

Newjeans songs are seratonin

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

Tier 1 members = Wonyoung, Yujin, Minji

Tier 2 members = Liz, Rei, Leeseo, Gaeul, Dany

Tier 3 members = Hanni, Haerin, Hyein

Song Rankings:

S Tier = I AM, Off the Record, I Want, Afterlike

A Tier = Kitsch, OMG

B Tier = Eleven

C Tier = Love Dive, Either Way, Hybe Boy, Baddie, Attention

D Tier = Super Shy, Ditto

F Tier = ETA, Cookie, Hurt

Display More

I was expecting a full write up for each of your tiers.

This was only a D Tier post from you. Not your best work, brother

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

Tier 1 members = Wonyoung, Yujin, Minji

Tier 2 members = Liz, Rei, Leeseo, Gaeul, Dany

Tier 3 members = Hanni, Haerin, Hyein

Song Rankings:

S Tier = I AM, Off the Record, I Want, Afterlike

A Tier = Kitsch, OMG

B Tier = Eleven

C Tier = Love Dive, Either Way, Hybe Boy, Baddie, Attention

D Tier = Super Shy, Ditto

F Tier = ETA, Cookie, Hurt

Display More

You can try to trick people but you're even on a Hybe group guild

So you clearly prefer Hybe style

Quote from Jasque-O-Part2

You can try to trick people but you're even on a Hybe group guild

So you clearly prefer Hybe style

Actually, it's more about loyalty to Ssamkkura, my BFF eunchaepower, and this SOTY:

bphouse dont care about nj or ive but rather the izone girls. just remember that.

I wanted to vote for I've since Yujin was my bias in izone, but I think objectively it's New Jeans. Their discography is impressively consistent, more than half of members are competent vocalists (even though neither group is a vocal powerhouse), and the members are more equal in their popularity. To be fair, it's not really reasonable to expect every I've member to be as popular as Wonyoung who got a big head start, but overall I'd just say New Jeans is a more consistent group.

I think I accidentally voted for IVE

Quote from YamaChwan

I think I accidentally voted for IVE

sometimes our hearts betray us

Quote from Rarami

bphouse dont care about nj or ive but rather the izone girls. just remember that.

Poor I've girls

Quote from OnceMidzy4ever

??? I already say who is better IMO. Boy, kpop fans sometimes are so weird.

But aren’t you a K-pop fan? You’re so weird man

I like ive so I think Ive is better

people who like nj will think nj is better...

wait a second there's a phrase for that!!!

different strokes for different folks????

I’ve is the best

honestly we won’t know until new jeans has more music. i’ve has proved they can retain a core following with a lot of music.

c’mon min hee jin this is ridiculous

with all due respect IVE is miles ahead better. New Jeans can stick their to tiktok music that doesn't have bridge or longer than 2.30 minutes to themselves

Quote from exspn

with all due respect IVE is miles ahead better. New Jeans can stick their to tiktok music that doesn't have bridge or longer than 2.30 minutes to themselves

bruh short music is an art form too. just say you’ve never listened to punk music

At what ? Baking?

Cook-off when?

I vote G-idle.

Quote from Drew_B

Eleven >>> NJ whole discography

You can prefer IVE, but ELEVEN?! Love Dive is genuinely better than like 99% of other songs but ELEVEN?!

I feel like both have really quality music but I don't like NewJeans' streak of having 2 minute long songs. But to balance it out, I think NewJeans' concepts are far more original and stimulating than Ive's. I think ultimately NewJeans win for me.

Quote from BEG4DAWIN

I vote G-idle.

why you lion for

Quote from exspn

with all due respect IVE is miles ahead better. New Jeans can stick their to tiktok music that doesn't have bridge or longer than 2.30 minutes to themselves

Ive is doing that with Baddie too

Quote from gerrard174

Ive is doing that with Baddie too

where?

Quote from Polarize

You are delusional and need help.

???

for only title track IVE >>>>

Their TT never fail for me (except Baddie but i will pretend their last comeback TT is OTR/EW)

But for overall songs and concept i think NJ is more interesting