Is Bahiyyih the most unfortunate idol?

Quote from Onewbias

no it's not facts because i can play that 'if' game too:

"if she has more screen time, she would have more fans"

"if she's more of Korean-type beauty, she would have more fans"

"if x girl gets less screen time, she wouldn't be voted in the group"

"if x girl didn't get evil edited, she would have been in the line-up"

and so on

at the end of the day, it's a popularity show, accept it or not. She won fair and square like the rest of the girls based on circumstances/opportunities given. that's facts. all these 'if' and 'what could have been' aren't facts, just alternative scenarios you think would have happened in your narrow view point.

Display More

Lol, this is not 'an if' question because clearly with less screentime, no important roles and mnet clearly doesn't want her to be in that group she obviously will not make it without her brother's popularity. I don't say she win by cheating, I just pointing out that she's not unlucky or hated by anyone in this thread because what people said here is just a fact. Like you said, she clearly win this fair and square so I don't think saying she win this because of her brother is a shame too.

Well fans didn’t want her expect her fans now she’s in a flop group which has actually talented members. She deserves her lines and st

Quote from hruaiic

as if people won't went ballistic if what they said here would be said about their favs.

Then those people are just blind and stupid lol if they denied big privileged like this. And again, no one hate her in this thread. No one said she's talentless. We all just saying what is so crystal clear in gp999. I mean, you're lying to yourself if you said she was doing great there or having so much star power and will debut without her privileged.

I'd say anyone who makes it in survival groups are fortunate

Out of 1000s of applicants 100 go through the show and less than 10 usually make it to final group

Also wasn't Kepler doing well in Japan?

Quote from icyruios

The thing about Bahi and every other Produce groups, rank rarely plays a role in line distribution.

I'm not familiar with I.O.I/Wanna One so I'll talk about IZ*ONE and Kep1er

From IZ*ONE itself, Sakura who was rank 2, gets very little lines. Nako who is 6th, gets very little lines compared to other members below her. What I can say is that final ranking of the group is not a fair representation on how lines are distributed.

And I suppose the same could be said for Kep1er.

Regardless, since this is a temporary group, one of the important things is what is it going to be like after Kep1er disband. You see Chaewon who was rank 11th thriving in LSFM, Sakura who got very little lines thriving as well. Wonyoung/Yujin, don't need say they are doing very well in IVE. Other IZ*ONE members are doing fairly well (compared to many other solo acts) actually by themselves.

What matters for Bahi is after Kep1er, which company is she going to join if she were to continue the idol life.

A lot of the ruckus tbh is created by a lot of toxic Bahi stans

Display More

I agree that the ranking doesn't correlate to the line distribution or the amount of spotlight, as the ranking of a show is obviously different from who will have the main positions and who might be the most popular as time passes. So whoever was voted #1 or last in the public voting, it doesn't mean they will actually be the center or have the lowest lines (unless something in the show says #1 = center).

"most unfortunate" is a very exaggerated phrase. She is just as "unlucky" as her teammates. And tbh, it's amusing how the reality is opposite. They are way fortunate than the other gp999 trainees who didn't get into kep1er.

Bahiyyih solo stans need to stop acting like she's superior and way better than her teammates. This is why other member fans get annoyed and call her talentless.

Quote from kingkook

"most unfortunate" is a very exaggerated phrase. She is just as "unlucky" as her teammates. And tbh, it's amusing how the reality is opposite. They are way fortunate than the other gp999 trainees who didn't get into kep1er.

Bahiyyih solo stans need to stop acting like she's superior and way better than her teammates. This is why other member fans get annoyed and call her talentless.

Oh god she is already called talentless or some nasty thing way before her fans goes rabid and toxic. Don't just blame her fans for the unjustified hate she gets

Quote from hruaiic

Oh god she is already called talentless or some nasty thing way before her fans goes rabid and toxic. Don't just blame her fans for the unjustified hate she gets

This thread on the forum is actually a huge example. Nobody would've even said anything negative about her if it weren't for op saying how she's unfortunate compared to the other members. Xiaoting is much more popular than her but I don't see her stans complaining as much as Bahiyyih's.

She basic af. It girl my ass

nope

not Bahiyyih

Garam

Is the most unfortunate idol

or

Rise & Eunb

of
LADIES CODE

Well the entire group is unlucky they got to debut through a very ambitious show with a lot of buzz from Mnet to only ending up as popular as Loona

Quote from kingkook

This thread on the forum is actually a huge example. Nobody would've even said anything negative about her if it weren't for op saying how she's unfortunate compared to the other members. Xiaoting is much more popular than her but I don't see her stans complaining as much as Bahiyyih's.

Whether a thread is negative or positive, ifs its about bahiyyih there is always people dragging her anyway. And i agree that her fans are super toxic and annoying but its not the reason why she got hate in the first place, they just put it out as a reason to justify their hate. I never hated idols because of their fans so i honestly don't get it.

Its really funny and weird to me how this girl really only got popular because she got hated on

I hate that Bahiyyih gets hated so much. She really doesn't deserve it.

But, it is true that she isn't really the most popular member outside of Twitter hype. I never really see anyone talk about her on K-forums, and I don't think she is that popular in Japan either. Korea, Japan, and China were the main targets for GP999, and Bahiyyih isn't the most loved member in either of those areas. There are also members who are popular in those areas who have standout talents such as Chaehyun vocally and Xiaoting dance wise. (Not sure who the most popular is in Japan tbh?)

Most groups could stand to have fairer line distributions, but that's never going to happen in a group with more than 7 members. We've seen it time and time again. As a Jeongyeon/Twice stan, I know this well lmao.

If she's not a vocal standout, she's not going to get lines. If she's not a visual/dance standout or an insanely popular member, she's not going to get screentime.

I do think they could definitely do better with the line distribution though, so hopefully she will get her era/opportunity to shine before disbandment.

what is viral exactly bc I never see of her unless kepler release some awful song (again) or she do smth with therr brother

Quote from kazuyakamenashi

But is this definitive fact, that she got into kelper because her brother is in TXT?

yes it is, I don't know why people like to pretend it isn't

nobody would have noticed her if her brother wasn't in TXT

Quote from topicsryo

yes it is, I don't know why people like to pretend it isn't

nobody would have noticed her if her brother wasn't in TXT

Ok well can I see the proof that nepotism is the primary culprit for her success?