Talent vs Good Song, which group do you prefer?

Good songs. Less talent doesnt mean no talent. And whats the use of talent if it doesnt show?

Quote from Bananapple

Extra talented group with no good songs

for what?

since I mainly consume audio while doing something else, then good song is a must

(heck I even start stanning because of their song)

my faves have both

I don't stan nor groups I recognize the skills and don't like the songs neither groups I like the songs and don't appreaciate the skills. So they are on the same boat

if a group doesn't have anyone that can somewhat sing i am not listening to their songs

im done with that

i also don't listen to songs i dislike though but i don't need to

Good songs.

Talent doesn’t matter if I don’t wanna listen to your song.

Talent.

nmixx has incredibly talented members but their songs are horrendous

vs ive who has less talented members in comparison, but some of the best if not the best songs of all 4th gen ggs

i'm going to pick the good songs ofc

Good songs arent enough, talent isnt enough.

Members have to grab me via fanservice. That's how I really got into BP, Twice and Izone.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

Good songs arent enough, talent isnt enough.

Members have to grab me via fanservice. That's how I really got into BP, Twice and Izone.

Blackpink and fanservice ?

Quote from Bananapple

Extra talented group with no good songs or group with very good songs but less talented? Which group that you prefer more?

Very good songs but less talented, good songs will keep me interested in the group and make me stay in the fandom, no good songs won't even make me interested in the group.

Talent is important too, but for me good songs take the most priority, if the songs aren't up to my taste, then I wouldn't be interested in them.

Quote from killthisfenty

Blackpink and fanservice ?

Blackpinkhouse literally got me into Kpop. Without it, y'all wouldnt be blessed everyday with my presence on AKP

And yes, i see the irony lol. The group that got me into Kpop with fanservice ends up to have the least fanservice of any idol group in history

Good song. I think often people overestimate how much talent you really need for music to be enjoyable. No matter how much talent you throw at a song, if everything else isn't good, nobody will want to listen to it.

It's like people who force themselves to listen to classical music because it makes them seem classier but they don't really enjoy it but they do it for the social status.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

And yes, i see the irony lol. The group that got me into Kpop with fanservice ends up to have the least fanservice of any idol group in history

This was me...