My versions of aespa, IVE, LSFM & NewJeans

Quote from doesitneedsaying

i'm 90% it wasn't kazuha. people were saying that if minju accepted kazuha wouldn't be in the final line up, but iirc she was the 4th member that was added to the group. or maybe i dreamt it all is there anyone to confirm this? not that i dreamt it but about the joining order lol

I honestly don’t know, but i feel like Garam was like a replacement to Minju because she declined. They kid have the same position of main visual but they also kibda look like Tzuyu.

Quote from thelightoftruth

The only thing Aespa needs is more comebacks!

If we are adding members however, I do think a powerhouse performer would be a strong addition, and I'd add Yeji to the group. Her and Karina doing some powerful dance breaks together would be fireee! I think she'd fit the concept well, and she is stunning as well, she'd fit right in honestly.

Ive, I agree that a strong vocalist would be a great addition. Perhaps Haewon from NMixx? She's got that cute/sultry kinda vibe going on like Ive and would add a nice dimension vocally as most of Ive is higher pitched.

LSF could probably use a rapper, maybe NMixx Jinni or Lightsum Sangah? They seem to be pretty good dancers as well and would fit in well with their strong visuals. I agree Minju fits too.

New Jeans, Sullyoon comes to mind as a good fit.

All the groups are great as they are though.

Display More

Yeji is amazing but i feel like her visual would kinda overlap with Karina, but she would have been great as a main dancer thought.

Yeah Heawon doesn’t sound bad.

Mmm i don’t think NJ needs another visual tho, they have a lot already lol. And i think Sullyoon fits with sm and aespa better. She has that perfect ae sort of beauty, she is tall with a great body. I truly think she could have taken aespa to the next level lol. And i do feel like she is kinda wasted in nmix .

Quote from Tenken101

I think Minju would've fit very well visually with LSFM. But at the same time, I'm not exactly sure if she would fit that well with their concept. I love the girl but she didn't do that well with stronger girl crush concepts during IZ*One. She would need to level up but maybe HYBE/Source's trainers could do it. Sad we will never know...

I think she could have leveled up if the had the fire. Which she doesn’t

Quote from Ves

Everyone keeps talking about her visual but then adding that she has professed to have no passion for dance? Le Sserafim is praised for their live stage presence that I'm pretty sure comes from their strong and coordinated dancing, esp for a gg - so how does Minju fit? Wouldn't she just bring that aspect down? And hello, wasn't she in talks with Hybe, but declined? If she didn't want to join, why not respect her decision?

Well this all fictional thought that's why

Quote from sassily

Ive kinda needs Gaeul because they lack in dance even more than in vocals (you can polish vocals in post production) and Gaeul is one of only 2 people in the group who can dance. Then again if they had Yuri I guess they could just be a vocals-focused group (with 3 good to semi-decent singers) and keep the choreo even more basic than it already is.

also I'll be honest your version of aespa maybe doesn't need Giselle. Just make Karina the rapper and the group would probably look more cohesive.

they may be lacking in dancing but i think vocals are more important in their case. Their dancing seems decent if not fine but vocal wise they are i think seriously lacking. Quite the contrary with hardwork most people can dance decently but for singing you need some core talent.

Mmm intersting, aespa without Giselle. But you know i like the idea of them being a pair number group because then they czn have two main/lead visuals. In this case Sullyoon and Karina instead of Karina and Winter in the middle.

So it would be like?

Ning Sullyoon Karina Winter

Mmm, not bad. But a japanese multilangual member whose raping is not too bad is not a bad addiction either. Giselle just needs to work harder and be a more clean dancer. Also having two english speaking members would be nice to. With Helen and Giselle. I dont know...

Quote from sassily

to be honest, I find Ive's dancing almost distractingly bad in performances. I'd say since most Kpop groups rarely ever sing live, you can fake vocals more easily, but with ive even with their easy choreo you can tell they're not good dancers.

I can see why Giselle is there, I just don't think she is essential. A Ningning - Sullyoon - Karina - Winter group actually sounds very intriguing, you'd still have 4 strong singers, so a vocals focused group with ai visuals. tbh with aespas sound they are not really appealing to the Western market anyway and the Japanese market only cares about visuals (Winter is the most popular there I think?) so I think they'd still be as popular.

Yeah i agree.

yeaah, the more you talk about it the more it sounds better. Karina could definitly have the rapper and main dancer position with Sullyoon > Giselle yup. This group sounds really good abd i cant even start to imagine the visual Sully&Karina duo. Damn they both look like ae s seriously they look unreal and this groups vocals would be bomb too 👌

Quote from trollacc

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

You're going to need to watch this and then explain to me what exactly is so bad about this encore.

They do sound quite better than the one i have heard indeed. They do look like they're trying pretty hard for a song that doesn’t sound that difficult tho. Yet its okay if the visual members are a bit weak but overall they just need a proper lead vocal. Liz is a bit weak and Rei too.

Quote from trollacc

It's a fair point, hopefully they will develop in the future. I can't deny Yuri did slay every encore and pretty much do backing vocals for the entire song every time.

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Yeah we can only hope for improvement right.

Yup Yuri sounds good and is very passionated, could have been the perfect addition to Ive both in terms of vocals and visuals👌