RE: So why did Seulgi solo flop (but Wendy didn’t)?

Quote from centen

firemonster246 - What B side did you like the most? You always find the good ones.

Anywhere But Home

It's one of the best mini-albums of the year.

Will the anons ever use correct info? 28 Reasons sold more than Like Water.

It’s not flopping in my house. I’m still thoroughly enjoying it. One of the best kpop albums of the year for me.

Anywhere but home, bad boy sad girl are great b sides.

My wife flopping? Not even in your dreams anon-kun.

28 reasons is excellent the mini not so much.

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

My wife flopping? Not even in your dreams anon-kun.

How many wives do you have?

Quote from One-and-only

How many wives do you have?

I'll say it after you give me your main account

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

I'll say it after you give me your main account

main account? I have only one account u can see that in my username too. But ocurse it is not your main account

Quote from One-and-only

main account? I have only one account u can see that in my username too. But ocurse it is not your main account

Then use a DP so that I won't consider you as an alt

It depends on how you define flop. Kpop fans tend to call something a flop if it doesn’t chart well, regardless of sales. Seulgi has sold really well, so I personally wouldn’t call it a flop.

From the company’s perspective, it’s a hit - the album has sold 205K copies, which would make it platinum in sales, This is pretty damn impressive for a soloist - male or female - where numbers are typically lower (Baek’s million is the exception, not the rule but I think it’s made people think soloists sell more than they actually do) and more so since she is not the main vocalist or the most popular member.

Just to put this in perspective about soloist numbers. This list was just as Seulgi was releasing, so she’d be 4th for women and 7th for men. (It’s worth noting the top three men are trot/ballad singers, so if you’re trying to compare apples to apples, you should probably start at #4 for men for comparisons.)

The tt, while not charting well in Korea, is charting well on QQ Music in China - it was #1 on QQ music for a month before dropping to #6. Most of the bsides also charted in the top 10. (Dead Man Runnin) definitely had longevity.

A few other notes, because I went poking around on this question beyond sales..

Apparently the song had some virality, making Spotify’s viral charts.

And this is kind of a neat one