Why did Beautiful Monster flop but Attention became a huge hit?

people liked attention more idk what answer do u want

Newjeans hype

younger and newer = better

welcome to kpop

People don't want this sound from stayc. Stereotype also didn't do well.

Starship knew what they were doing when they rejected this for sistar.

I love Stayc but you don’t comeback like that after you got your biggest hit singe Asap. They need upbeat songs not soft music.

just because two songs are similar vibe doesnt mean they are the same attention is just a song people like more that simple

i think attention got better promo

Novelty

Quote from caratnotcarrot

i think attention got better promo

That's far from the true, stayc been in many shows for this singke specially yt ones

People just like new shiny things ...until they dont

how do these two songs correlate

I don't know but I still don't understand why StayC's worst two title tracks are hits while their amazing songs like Stereotype or Beautiful Monster get paid dust

the beautiful monster chorus is kinda difficult to listen to.

Quote from kb801

the beautiful monster chorus is kinda difficult to listen to.

Right. I know the girls are good at singing but that chorus did not suit their voices at all.

Attention is the better song imo and it has a nostalgic feel that most kpop title tracks don't have.

They are different genres. I don't get the comparison.

In chorus tho....yoon and sieun's straing vocal isn't that cause they didn't sing in their vocal range....

Im worried if their vocal will being damaged...

Newjeans have hybe supporters and look younger.The people forget stayc have 01-04 line members. (They re teenagers tho)

Is beautiful monster flopping though?

Anyway agree with others - the vocal delivery in the chorus grates

Tbh i saw this video that was the worst voices in Kpop and they put Sieun and Yoon in there because they have a shouting match on the mic and i think that is almost correct. I think the issue is that both of them are too powerful for the other. It takes away the build up and overwhelms the listener when both of them are adlibbing at the same time, or when one of them is belting and the other is adlibbing.