Without too much backlash?
Are there any idols who have left/been removed from a group that you think could go back and have fans embrace them?
-
-
SNSD OT9
-
Kim Woojin.
I appreciate the sentiment, but I also doubt that. A lot.
-
DreamNote’s former Habin and Hanbyeol. Habin left due to an ankle injury and needed time to heal, while Hanbyeol was only 14 when she debuted, and decided the idol life just wasn’t for her. From what I understand, Pages were upset they left and worried how it would affect the group, but accepted what happened very well and were still respectful to the former members. I think Pages though (including me) would be happy if they could come back and/or decided they want to. Hanbyeol was so cute!
-
I appreciate the sentiment, but I also doubt that. A lot.
I'm conducting an experiment.
-
I'm conducting an experiment.
In that case I wish you good luck!
-
-
-
-
-
-
that one member of apink who got kicked out because of buisiness or something. she did say she would be willing to rejoin. (someone please tell me if I'm thinking of the right group)
gaga from nature. there aren't that many toxic leafs so she should be fine. I think they all left anyways after rica rica came out.
this will never happen but maybe linlin or kokoro could come back without backlash. ella i doubt.
lastly, daisy, taeha, and yeonwoo. merrys would be celebrating and we would be very happy.
-
just giving a thumbs up cuz i don't really know about his scandal so can't tell if this is serious or not lol
It's not serious.
Their fans hate the guy and we still don't know what he did. -
-
It's not serious.
Their fans hate the guy and we still don't know what he did.the vast majority just want people to stop bringing him up because of the amount of speculation and ambiguity around what happened. yes, some people hate him and that's their choice, but the rest of us just want people to stop bringing him because of how sensitive it is for everyone.
i'd rather you not joke about things like that so the rest of us don't have to get upset over things that happened years ago..
esp because you knew exactly what kind of response you were going to get when you brought him up in the first place.
-
-
what do you think about jinE?
-
I agree with Wonho and B.I. Yes, some people would be against it, but I feel like their core fanbase would welcome it and the groups would survive.
The Oh My Girl member who recently left. People were disappointed, but understanding of her reasons so I think they would welcome her back. idk how it went over in Korea though.
-
-
what do you think about jinE?
if she chose to return i think fans would welcome her back
-
-
jiho??and prob jine??they both left for personal reasons and nothing controversial, so they probably wont return(wishing that both of them are doing well) but ig to many, they're still viewed pretty positively
also, i see a lot of bi above, personally, idk abt bi since it's been so long alr, i have no more hard feelings left but i still feel a bit hmphh seeing him
-
the vast majority just want people to stop bringing him up because of the amount of speculation and ambiguity around what happened. yes, some people hate him and that's their choice, but the rest of us just want people to stop bringing him because of how sensitive it is for everyone.
i'd rather you not joke about things like that so the rest of us don't have to get upset over things that happened years ago..
esp because you knew exactly what kind of response you were going to get when you brought him up in the first place.
Why is it sensitive if you guys don't even know why he left? You get upset over nothing. People are still going to bring him up, so it's better to take it easy.
-
What about the guy from VIXX? I feel like that whole situation just got out of control really fast and and it was deeper issues from the company that lead to him leaving (I know he's talked about having issues getting some kind of documentation from Jellyfish showing his contract was termed or something.) I don't know a ton of VIXX fans, but the couple that I do want him to come back.
-
What Zuzu meant is not about reasons, but consequences the departure brought for the group. The fans watched and they end up feeling empathy towards the members who doesn't like the subject to be brought up themselves.
Not saying you can't say whatever you want or can't want to be funny, tho. Just explaining why It's not a good topic for many people. But It's very obvious why he wouldn't be welcomed. Because he wouldn't even by the own members and It was made clear publicly.
-
me neither, and i know what he did might've been wrong- but they're approach to it was so wrong, esp because they let so many other idols under the same company stay in their groups... bi seems like a nice guy
I mean, I'm not Korean so my view doesn't matter, but I personally wouldn't have ruined this guy's career and pretty much kneecapped the careers of everyone else in ikon over pot. But then, I think pot should be legal and I feel that smoking pot is pretty much a victimless offense. Again, I'm not Korean though so it's not really for me to understand I suppose.
-
I mean, I'm not Korean so my view doesn't matter, but I personally wouldn't have ruined this guy's career and pretty much kneecapped the careers of everyone else in ikon over pot. But then, I think pot should be legal and I feel that smoking pot is pretty much a victimless offense. Again, I'm not Korean though so it's not really for me to understand I suppose.
i agree with you
-
-
-
-
Ohhhh yes we would!
-
Anyone but Seungri, i guess
-
There's always members that leave nugu groups for whatever reason. Could be stress + anxiety, not wanting to live the idol life, etc. Usually those leavings are sad and non controversial so if said members were to rejoin, I feel it would probably be fine.
Now, idols leaving bigger groups, those tend to have controversy behind it. Hence why it's difficult to assess.
-
-
-
-
-
Probably Laun
As he had left ONF and some months later opend an Instagram account people where randly very happy to see him back online. No idea how he had felt about that cause altho he removed his entire past with ONF and went by his realname, most people really went all out saying they were suporting him trought the fact that they knew him since he was in ONF and altho some people said they shouldn't remind him since he had his reasons to leave the group, people still did that
If he would ever consider to come back and they would let him rejoin, I bet most of the fans would be happy
-
cant think of any
some part of the fandoms will raise a stink
-
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
