Posts by Yama-Chan

Quote from Sugary-Salt

Dude, JYP don't care about your or someone's else opinion except their shareholders. Either you should become shareholder or just stop buying their albums, so JYP will start thinking about improvements.

Overall, there is no rule to stay focused on BIG-4 only, because their content is not better, or their idols are not more talented than non-big-4 colleagues. The only diff that BIG-4 can spend unlimited money for nonsense "achievements" like 100M views or streams to ensure you to listen them because they are "popular".

Huh? I see actually zero correlation between what I said in the OP and your response. I...never said that JYP cares about my opinion, but how do you know I'm not a shareholder?

Regardless, it's just a harmless thought exercise. No K-Pop executive cares about what gets posted on the AKP forums. I think we're all cognizant of that lol

Quote from SooYoung

Huge decline in digital and love ? Nmixx ?

Declining suppose that the artist used to be at the top at one point

JYP girl groups used to be synonymous with chart dominance. That basically hasn't been the case for the entire 2020s.

Yeah that's a decline. The year end numbers for JYP groups were carried by Stray Kids and only internationally

Everybody loves pointing out the huge decline in digital performance and love from the general public for Twice, Itzy and NMIXX

Well does anyone have any ideas for how they'd get these groups moving in the right direction (and can speculate why what JYP has tried hasn't worked)? 🤔

Quote from draggehz

none of these three groups have a good vocalist what is there to argue about

Hanni and Danielle are good vocalists. What are you people on? Are they the best of the best? No, but they're both very capable singers, and even IU was blown away by Hyein's voice and potential.

I'm about to unleash stan hell on this forum, if people keep coming for NJ's vocals.

I have heard nearly all of these groups in person. Some multiple times. Stop the cap.

Quote from gerrard174

Maybe only mamamoo

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

Wut? It was literally the SOTY for 2023, remember that Ditto had 3 months to accumulate extra ULs and pad its lead before I AM released. If you look at standardized time frames (the first 30 days of release), I AM is 10 percent higher.

GBMyLwhbUAAxmGZ.jpg

I beg you. Please don't let this cope bleed into all of 2024. Let it go

Quote from blossom9990

I'm lazy and not their fans too. I'm just thinking that what a waste of data to show the dominance of Newjeans this year when you can post everything of it rather than only one achievements like this.

I already did that. And then reposted it on Reddit. Just check my history.

Quote from wsoet

I will admit that I don't think I've purchased a new CD since the late 1990s. In most cases these days, are they still just selling CDs in a basic jewel case format in the US?

I haven't bought a CD in ages, but I'm fairly certain that the basic jewel case format is still standard. Kind of crazy honestly.

Quote from blossom9990

You should post that article from Pannchoa where they list all top 4th gen girl groups achievements domestically and internationally last year.

It actually more impressive to look at overall data of who doing the best last year.

You could post it too. I don't usually scroll through Pannchoa

Quote from wsoet

What seems more surprising is that 70% of that list is K-pop. I suppose CD sales really are quite dead in the US.

Look at the effort put into the CDs sold by your typical artist in the U.S. vs. the creative playground that is the K-Pop album.

Not surprising really

NewJeans — 118 weeks (2023)

IVE — 68 weeks (2023)

IU — 67 weeks (2021)

IVE — 62 weeks (2022)

BIGBANG — 56 weeks (2008)

BTS — 55 weeks (2021)

SGWANNABE — 50 weeks (2005)

NewJeans — 49 weeks (2022)

IU — 48 weeks (2020)

BIGBANG — 46 weeks (2015)

BunniesTaglist

Quote from killthisfenty

Considering I saw worse hatred toward BP/Twice during their rookie years about their skills. NJ/IVE/LSR are pretty much barely criticized.

It's about the same. You weren't the only one there

This isn't a fight worth picking.

The only people going after NJ vocals are fans of groups that were never even known for their vocals. It's the spiderman meme in full effect. Well besides the fact that NewJeans do have good vocals.

They know who they are, and they'd like for us to ignore the fact Mamamoo, Red Velvet and GFriend had the strongest vocal lines by light years.

But you don't see fans of those groups obsessing over vocals nearly as much as others. Almost as if the latter group simply has an agenda

But nothing good will come from this thread.

BunniesTaglist

This is the 2nd most of any female artist in the country, behind only Taylor Swift.

They are also surging back up the Billboard 200, despite it being roughly 6 months since Get Up released.

This is on pace to be the best-selling and most successful girl group album in Billboard history, and it's flown under the radar a bit.

Imagine accomplishing this when you're not even 2 years old and haven't reached your peak yet

Quote from Daileemidzy

Saying average dancing with the footwork NewJeans have to do is crazy

It's literally a haters gonna hate situation

Quote from catzi

I'm pretty sure you're not even old enough to legally drink alcohol.

Please use your time more productively, student. Getting schooled on AKP regularly is no substitute for your actual in classroom education

IVE will survive without your constant shit posting.

Quote from catzi

i already talked about it in this thread. I hated how the promo in us felt forced specially that macy parade thing and i was very vocal about it; i can guarantee it wouldnt be different if ive did another stupid gig like that. Releasing just an english song however I 100% support I mean if you had the effort to search about how i felt with aespa us promo you can search how i felt about hold on tight. And loving wonyoungism thriving on tiktok means i love how relevant my girl is despite all the hate, it has zero correlation with how my faves are promoted lol

All this essay thinkpiece just to both this not even be related at all, but at least you tried.

This was barely coherent, and you had the audacity to use a semicolon during this nonsensical stream of consciousness rant. Are you allergic to space bars and enter keys?

You aren't convincing anyone IVE gets proportionally more hate than other groups

That's a fate reserved for the absolute most popular girl groups like NewJeans and BlackPink.

catzi is having one of the worst starts to a year in AKP history. There really should be a trophy for biggest L takes to start the year. They'd sweep the category unanimously.

Really out here putting their everything into winning the Hate Olympics.

Quote from versatile

I was actually pretty nice tbh I gave them a 6 a solid average group only a year into their debut.

No clout seeking I'm just curious where people rank them.

I'm being even nicer than you are.

Your curiosity has a very interesting way of manifesting itself into the form of bait and hate. How odd.

You're not going to get any legitimate answers if you choose to frame everything within your poorly hidden agenda from the start.

Come on, Rip. You've been doing this for way too long to not know any better. Don't end up like SeulgisAbs.

I bid you adieu

Quote from versatile

Like I said their songs are really easy to sing.. they don't hit any high notes.

Twices into discography is a high note. A random off the street could sing ditto.

I'll take not hitting high notes over not hitting any notes

Targeting NewJeans won't get you the clout points or hit thread you're hoping for. Not with threads like these.