Rate NewJeans talent wise out of 10

Do u want to get kidnapped by min heejin?

I'll rate them as a multiple of Twice's talent:

2.35x

Let's start by comparing encore stages between them and Twice

Quote from versatile

Like I said their songs are really easy to sing.. they don't hit any high notes.

Twices into discography is a high note. A random off the street could sing ditto.

I'll take not hitting high notes over not hitting any notes

Targeting NewJeans won't get you the clout points or hit thread you're hoping for. Not with threads like these.

Quote from versatile

New jeans could not perform this rn..

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Yea because they only perform good songs

Quote from versatile

I was actually pretty nice tbh I gave them a 6 a solid average group only a year into their debut.

No clout seeking I'm just curious where people rank them.

I'm being even nicer than you are.

Your curiosity has a very interesting way of manifesting itself into the form of bait and hate. How odd.

You're not going to get any legitimate answers if you choose to frame everything within your poorly hidden agenda from the start.

Come on, Rip. You've been doing this for way too long to not know any better. Don't end up like SeulgisAbs.

I bid you adieu

Quote from VanDamme4Life

I'll rate them as a multiple of Twice's talent:

2.35x

multiplying by 0 always gives 0

Quote from versatile

Did I hear an itzy fan say something

yes i can repeat if you want. Twice have no talent and same for Newjeans

Their concept is to be the teen girls who live down the street who are BFFs.

The more easily teen girls, their target market, can sing and dance to their songs, the more effective they are.

However they have better than average visuals for idols, so are more likely to make teen girls jealous of them. This is where Ive has an advantage over them.

Quote from versatile

Well as long as you're saying it for both

I dont hide it, i'm agree with you Newjeans have no talent.

Quote from K-PL

However they have better than average visuals for idols, so are more likely to make teen girls jealous of them. This is where Ive has an advantage over them.

The ive shade lmao 😂

5/10

Quote from versatile

Like I said their songs are really easy to sing.. they don't hit any high notes.

Twices into discography is a high note. A random off the street could sing ditto.

So sis, lets hear your cover. I want to hear you out sing the falsettos if Hyein and Hanni while dancing.

Id love to hear momo do it too. Or Sana. Or nayeon for the matter.

I’d actually like to hear anybody in twice sing in their first year but id have to watch sixteen for that and i’m just not a masochist.

Also youre a garbage troll. You on the same page as your OP say you arent comparing them to twice and we’re assuming based on your DP but you literally say “id love to hear them sing cheer up” …so in comparison to who?

Twice couldnt do this encore stage first comeback

As for skills

Vocals: 7/10 theyre pretty solid but at the moment a lot of their music stylistically is very breathy so it doesnt show whether they have like supported belting ability. I guess i know Danielle does but i need more proof

Rap: ?/10 idk ive never seen it and i dont want to unless it makes sense for song composition.

Dance: 10/10 they show us a new style of choreography all the time. Even in the same performances or for the same song in different performances. They master multiple Ditto Choreos to reflect different eras of dance, theyve shown countless dance breaks that are extremely difficult, and they even sing live usually.

Stage presence: 10/10 again. Theyre very organic, fluid and comfortable on stage. They easily move in and out of official choreography to interact with crowds. Theyve gained this skill quickly from their Lollapalooza concert and their university concerts. Its very apparent they know how to work a physical stage

7/10+10/10+10/10=

27/30

9/10. 90%

7/10. Their skill set is average according to the kpop standards, possibly including rapping.

1.9/10

Quote from versatile

Nayeom jihyo vocally >>

Momo dance >>

Chaeyoung rap>>

This isn't 2016 twice are a bit above average these days.

The bars are in hell if twice is winning the rap and vocal category. Btw you say “this isn’t 2016 twice” doesn’t make sense. Cuz then why you comparing an 8 years old grp to a year old grp???

3/10

Vocals - 4/10

Dance 4/10

Visuals - 10/10

Overall - 5/10

Saying average dancing with the footwork NewJeans have to do is crazy

Quote from Daileemidzy

Saying average dancing with the footwork NewJeans have to do is crazy

It's literally a haters gonna hate situation

Better than Aespa. (Except in vocals ofc, im not delulu)

Normally, it takes an average of about 5 posts for a thread to devolve into a fanwar and 3 at the least, but here it basically started with the first post.

Quote from K-PL

Their concept is to be the teen girls who live down the street who are BFFs.

The more easily teen girls, their target market, can sing and dance to their songs, the more effective they are.

However they have better than average visuals for idols, so are more likely to make teen girls jealous of them. This is where Ive has an advantage over them.

'subtle' IVE shade.

I think this will be a long thread...