Disagree. There are plenty of good/interesting covers.
I didn't say there are not, I like covers, it was just me being ironic (I guess not clearly enough)
Disagree. There are plenty of good/interesting covers.
I didn't say there are not, I like covers, it was just me being ironic (I guess not clearly enough)
sorry, I didn't get the irony
I'm bad at it haha, I know...
But whenever idols do a cover of a popular song, they're dragged as not good enough, compared to the original artist etc, so it would be better if they don't even do the covers
some covers are really nice tho (I got the humor of your comment dw)
I'm a Shawol, but for example, I prefer EXO's Why So Serious cover than the original version (I've never thought this song fit SHINee's discography much, so I think it fit really well for that EXO unit).
I agree that Monsta X is one of the best and I agree that TXT was one of the worst. Their performance was fine, but they just can't pull it off imo.
Moonbin and Woodz were the best part of the SBS cover.
Honestly Mitotic covers are made or broke by two things and that's the vibe if the group matching the song and whether or not they go for the high note. Like I don't even care so much if they can't get as high or as loud as Changmin. Few people can. I just appreciate the attempt.
Yesterday's cover was not it. But I don't even like when HoMin perform that song, so there's that.
wow the comments made me curious now i'm going to check the covers lol
I agree, I also like some covers better, and I get that some covers might not be that nice to people, but when idols cover my faves, it makes me happy, even if I prefer the original, I try not to compare it to it the original or say that it was totally bad etc.
the worst one is the latest sbs one, they did good but their vocals are all a miss for me
It seems we have different criteria of what makes a good Mirotic cover. Is it vocals? Strong eye contact with the camera? Sexiness?
Good vocals isn't enough for me, I need eye contact and sexiness. I also need a certain vibe. One of the dancers in the SBS Gayo was too fluid (yes, fluidity gives a different vibe than slight clunkiness), while another added too much of the equivalent of dancing ad-libs.
This might be a weird description but I feel like for Mirotic you need individuals who have very masculine type singing voice and dance skills/appeal. If you watch TVXQ’s Mirotic performances the members all look more mature and sound more mature than idols now covering the song. TVXQ were in their early 20s singing this song similar to all these idols covering the song .
This might be a weird description but I feel like for Mirotic you need individuals who have very masculine type singing voice and dance skills/appeal. If you watch TVXQ’s Mirotic performances the members all look more mature and sound more mature than idols now covering the song. TVXQ were in their early 20s singing this song similar to all these idols covering the song .
Not weird at all. I share the same thoughts.
This might be a weird description but I feel like for Mirotic you need individuals who have very masculine type singing voice and dance skills/appeal. If you watch TVXQ’s Mirotic performances the members all look more mature and sound more mature than idols now covering the song. TVXQ were in their early 20s singing this song similar to all these idols covering the song .
Hmmm, maybe that's why so many in this thread prefer the MX cover. Their vibe and image leans more masculine and mature.
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!