Why does it feel like MissA is more iconic than Itzy?
-
-
I think hindsight is 20/20 my friend
miss a had their run and did really really well (from what I hear) but itzy's legacy (if one can call it that) is still to be determined
regardless of where itzy ends up in the "kpop hierarchy" they are and were very successful and hopefully in 20/30 years down the track maybe someone will call them iconic too
-
-
Well, same label mates are usually a product of their predecessors. Maybe what JYPe couldn't do with MissA, they are trying it with Itzy. Suzy got really really popular and the rest of the members are essentially non-existent. Which one of them still remains beside Suzy?
With Itzy, you get a healthy dose -somewhat- of everyone. Different stroke for different folks, maybe Miss A is more of your timeline .
-
Because they are
-
Yeah by every Metric I know Itzy are more successful but people don't think of them that way
But I will say this, Miss A is universally considered a Top 10 Girl Group of their Generation
I suspect many people are doubtful Itzy will ultimately be remembered the same way amongst the 4th Gen especially considering the perception that they have been trending downwards coupled with the rise of several newer groups who have seemingly taken their shine
-
-
Always thought that JYPE's "barely any solo gig" strategy that started with TWICE was extremely harmful to their artists longterm. Right now, GOT7 are thriving as solo artists, and that's largely due to the fact that they've always done solo stuff. Endorsements, photoshoots, solo variety, you name it, a member had done it. I can't imagine all members of Stray Kids going solo and not having 2/3 flop.
-
They’re also more iconic than Twice
-
-
-
I actually feel the contrary even if i know Miss A were big with a lot of hits
I feel as a group Itzy is bigger because the group is more well know, the members are popular individually etc....
While as a group i feel Miss A wasn't really successfull that's why their sales were so low i guess, they were mostly hard carry by Suzy
-
-
-
-
-
-
Yeah by every Metric I know Itzy are more successful but people don't think of them that way
But I will say this, Miss A is universally considered a Top 10 Girl Group of their Generation
I suspect many people are doubtful Itzy will ultimately be remembered the same way amongst the 4th Gen especially considering the perception that they have been trending downwards coupled with the rise of several newer groups who have seemingly taken their shine
Something else I just thought of that might make me think this way is that groups during 2nd gen had a longer shelf life.
While today groups tend to peak after year 2 and then everyone moves on to the next new hot thing.
-
I don't know how you come up with ITZY is "10 times more succesful"?....
Miss A's album Clas A is probably one of the best album in kpop, it have a lot of good songs. But they did follow it up with the same high standard, even if they had some good stuff after that. And they had Suzy that ITZY is not close to have anyone at her level of popularity.
Also, because Miss A was part of the early 2nd generation wave of girlgroups it feels they hade bigger impact on kpop ingeneral compared to ITZY today that is more like one group amoung many groups and they don't really bring anything new to the table.
-
-
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!