Karina vs Wonyoung vs yeji vs chuu vs soojin vs Miyeon vs soyeon (it girl)

Shouldn’t Winter be there instead of Karina

Yeji is my it girl

Chuu is cute but I will pick Yeji. I love her dancing, her energy when she performs, her cat eyes and overall look

So she’s my IT Girl.

If there's Yuna in the poll, I'll pick her. But in the poll, I prefer Yeji

Yeji!

Soyeon is the biggest ace in all of Kpop right now.

Miyeon is the second greatest visual in Kpop right now.

Soojin and Miyeon world domination

Human sunshine herself

Quote from tornpet

Shouldn’t Winter be there instead of Karina

Karina has “IT girl” aura, tbh. I think Winter will be known for her vocals more kind of like Jennie and Rosé.

Quote from karinaknows

Karina has “IT girl” aura, tbh. I think Winter will be known for her vocals more kind of like Jennie and Rosé.

Winter is the most popular and SM sees that, that's why theyre giving her more promotions.

Let’s be honest, the real IT girl on that list currently is IZ*ONE wonyoung. Her popularity in korea is unmatched by any of these other girls.

Quote from tornpet

Winter is the most popular and SM sees that, that's why theyre giving her more promotions.

I’m not going to argue with you about future potential. Winter only had the MAMA stage.

Karina will be the “IT girl” of the group. It’s obvious. Winter will still be popular to the public but as a visual/vocalist more. An “IT girl” is popular because of her presence and overall persona.

Y’all call anyone an it girl or it boy when in reality they’re unknown in Korea

Quote from karinaknows

I’m not going to argue with you about future potential. Winter only had the MAMA stage.

Karina will be the “IT girl” of the group. It’s obvious. Winter will still be popular to the public but as a visual/vocalist more. An “IT girl” is popular because of her presence and overall persona.

Winter is still the most popular at the end of the day, an IT GIRL is the most popular in Korea.

Quote from pull-up

Let’s be honest, the real IT girl on that list currently is IZ*ONE wonyoung. Her popularity in korea is unmatched by any of these other girls.

Exactly

the only ‘it girls’ here are wonyoung and yeji, maybe soyeon but i wouldnt call her an it girl. i’d just say soyeon is the most well known and appreciated for her talents.

yall be throwing around the term it girl on this forum a lot. an it girl is the most popular member who the gp loves and knows, people wanna look like her and be her,everyone wants to date her or be her friend, thats what it means to be an it girl. perfect examples are jennie, irene and even hwasa (she doesnt have the typical face u see but ppl like that, thats her charm), everything these three do becomes a trend.

Quote from tornpet

Winter is still the most popular at the end of the day, an IT GIRL is the most popular in Korea.

Anything can happen. It’s just a poll. No need to be mad about it. Some people believe that Karina has the most potential and SM seems to think the same thing since she’s the FOTG.

Quote from karinaknows

I’m not going to argue with you about future potential. Winter only had the MAMA stage.

Karina will be the “IT girl” of the group. It’s obvious. Winter will still be popular to the public but as a visual/vocalist more. An “IT girl” is popular because of her presence and overall persona.

Karina was the most promoted and propped by SM to be the star of from the jump and still got out paced by Winter. She’s never gonna be the “IT girl”. Your opinion =/= the reality going on in Korea.

Quote from karinaknows

Anything can happen. It’s just a poll. No need to be mad about it. Some people believe that Karina has the most potential and SM seems to think the same thing since she’s the FOTG.

sm does the same with taeyong, but look the most popular member is jaehyun. so just because someone is the center doesnt mean theyre guaranteed to be the ‘it’ girl/boy of the group.

Quote from karinaknows

Anything can happen. It’s just a poll. No need to be mad about it. Some people believe that Karina has the most potential and SM seems to think the same thing since she’s the FOTG.

That was before SM saw how big Winter became though. You're right it's just a poll, but I'm talking as of right now. I'm not using potential or anything, I'm using facts. And the fact is, is that Winter is the most popular in Korea so she has a higher chance.

Quote from raizcharms

Karina was the most promoted and propped by SM to be the star of from the jump and still got out paced by Winter. She’s never gonna be the “IT girl”. Your opinion =/= the reality going on in Korea.

Once again, anything can happen. Lisa was YG and Korea’s least favourite member and look at how popular she is now.

The reality of what’s going on in Korea is that both Karina and Winter are popular. For two different reasons. I don’t know why you’re trying to drag me just for defending OP’s choice.

Quote from tornpet

That was before SM saw how big Winter became though. You're right it's just a poll, but I'm talking as of right now. I'm not using potential or anything, I'm using facts. And the fact is, is that Winter is the most popular in Korea so she has a higher chance.

How do you know what SM is thinking? You’re acting like Winter suddenly got thousand photoshoots and brand deals.

It seems like SM is just deciding to promote all members now instead of just Karina. Which is a logical reason but has nothing to do with whatever you’re trying to say.

Quote from karinaknows

How do you know what SM is thinking? You’re acting like Winter suddenly got thousand photoshoots and brand deals.

It seems like SM is just deciding to promote all members now instead of just Karina. Which is a logical reason but has nothing to do with whatever you’re trying to say.

It's funny how they start doing it right after Winter's popularity surge. And where is Giselle and Ningning's promotion then if they're doing it for ALL of the members.

Quote from dokyeomhive

sm does the same with taeyong, but look the most popular member is jaehyun. so just because someone is the center doesnt mean theyre guaranteed to be the ‘it’ girl/boy of the group.

Yes but nothing guarantees that Winter will be the IT girl of Aespa. People are just saying that as a way to diss Karina.

Obviously, she’s going to get compliments on her visuals because she’s... the visual. But, Karina gets the same thing.

Anyway. Some people clearly agree with me and Winter’s persona doesn’t give me IT girl.

There can be more than one “IT” member in a group and I think Karina will be the one that does the most CFs etc.

Quote from karinaknows

Yes but nothing guarantees that Winter will be the IT girl of Aespa. People are just saying that as a way to diss Karina.

Obviously, she’s going to get compliments on her visuals because she’s... the visual. But, Karina gets the same thing.

Anyway. Some people clearly agree with me and Winter’s persona doesn’t give me IT girl.

There can be more than one “IT” member in a group and I think Karina will be the one that does the most CFs etc.

Display More

being an it girl isnt a 'vibe' or 'persona', youre an it girl when the results reflect that. rn there isnt much to go off of for aespa but winter has had the most positive reaction and she's the most popular so its more likely for her to be an it girl as of rn.

Quote from dokyeomhive

being an it girl isnt a 'vibe' or 'persona', youre an it girl when the results reflect that. rn there isnt much to go off of for aespa but winter has had the most positive reaction and she's the most popular so its more likely for her to be an it girl as of rn.

Yes but you can have an intuition about someone. Anyway. If you want to argue about this, then speak to OP. I didn’t make the poll.

Quote from karinaknows

Karina has “IT girl” aura, tbh. I think Winter will be known for her vocals more kind of like Jennie and Rosé.

Jennie is more it girl than karina will ever be, she's the whole package. Her channel with a random vlog already has more subs than your favs in less than a day

Quote from karinaknows

Yes but you can have an intuition about someone. Anyway. If you want to argue about this, then speak to OP. I didn’t make the poll.

but you responded ME lol when I was clearly talking to OP

Quote from karinaknows

Karina has “IT girl” aura, tbh. I think Winter will be known for her vocals more kind of like Jennie and Rosé.

miss karinadoesn'tknow back at it again being delusional with her clapped theories of Jennie and Karina ever existing as both IT girls in an alternate universe. How about you get your girlies their first win before you start comparing them to one of the biggest musical acts to ever exist, next

Quote from mangata

miss karinadoesn'tknow back at it again being delusional with her clapped theories of Jennie and Karina ever existing as both IT girls in an alternate universe. How about you get your girlies their first win before you start comparing them to one of the biggest musical acts to ever exist, next

MISSKARINADOESN'TKNOW

Quote from tornpet

but you responded ME lol when I was clearly talking to OP

I was just trying to defend OP’s choice. I wasn’t asking for multiple people to diss Karina and her popularity when I wasn’t even being an annoying stan.

OP should've added Yuna and Winter

Quote from mangata

miss karinadoesn'tknow back at it again being delusional with her clapped theories of Jennie and Karina ever existing as both IT girls in an alternate universe. How about you get your girlies their first win before you start comparing them to one of the biggest musical acts to ever exist, next

It was a COMPARISON. Stop gatekeeping Jennie, acting like no one can say her name.

You want Jennie to be recognised as an IT girl but you also don’t want people to use her an example of a top IT girl? make it make sense.

“biggest musical act to ever exist?” Stop being so delusional.

Quote from karinaknows

It was a COMPARISON. Stop gatekeeping Jennie, acting like no one can say her name.

You want Jennie to be recognised as an IT girl but you also don’t want people to use her an example of a top IT girl? make it make sense.

“biggest musical act to ever exist?” Stop being so delusional.

you're not even a blink though sooo????????????

Quote from tornpet

you're not even a blink though sooo????????????

And? So you’re telling me that I have to be a blink to say Jennie’s name? Lol. That’s too funny.

I was using Jennie and Rosé as simple examples of what Winter and Karina’s dynamic could be.

Jennie being the IT girl because of her fashion, worldwide brand deals and visuals.

And, Rosé being recognised for her unique vocals and ethereal aura the most.

I think that is what Winter and Karina “will be” because there can be more than one member that gets recognised by the public.

Quote from karinaknows

It was a COMPARISON. Stop gatekeeping Jennie, acting like no one can say her name.

You want Jennie to be recognised as an IT girl but you also don’t want people to use her an example of a top IT girl? make it make sense.

“biggest musical act to ever exist?” Stop being so delusional.

you blind, dumb and illiterate i see. learn how to read before you have the audacity to quote me miss girl

i'll stop gate-keeping Jennie's IT girl status when you learn that not everyone with cat-like yes and a mean girl aura is going to achieve 'top-dog' status.

again, these "comparisons" are irrelevant when you're comapring a girl group that could barely chart in their HOME country, to one that is recognised as to being THE top girl group

Quote from karinaknows

And? So you’re telling me that I have to be a blink to say Jennie’s name? Lol. That’s too funny.

I was using Jennie and Rosé as simple examples of what Winter and Karina’s dynamic could be.

Jennie being the IT girl because of her fashion, worldwide brand deals and visuals.

And, Rosé being recognised for her unique vocals and ethereal aura the most.

I think that is what Winter and Karina “will be” because there can be more than one member that gets recognised by the public.

Display More

They will never be them.. please don't even compare