NWJNs stans are delulu, this is not how 14 yos dress

Quote from ghostings

Note: I am a 14 year old myself

When people voiced concerns about how they dressed here, they all rallied and tried to say that it was just the way people saw it and that they were the dirty ones. If HYBE genuinely cared about their safety and shit, they would not have made her dress this way. People use "This is how teenagers dress" as an excuse when they literally do not dress like this. Where do you guys live?

Have you never seen actual teenagers? Instead of defending HYBE for everything, go outside for once.

Display Spoiler

example1.png

It also reminds me of how JYP dressed Yuna during the ICY era, when she was still a minor and was dressed in a weird top with mesh.

i didn't even notice wth

and you can tell by how it's cut at the top that the original garmet was supposed to cover that whole area; they cut it out on purpose. JAIL

Honestly 14yos that go to malls or just anywhere in general do actually dress like that so long as they have parents who don't say anything about it lol

I mean yeah of course fourteen year olds and other teenagers not actually wear this, since they mostly wear a t-shirt and baggy jeans that's it

//from what I am from of course

Quote from Bpsosoro

I agree, honestly adults be thinking we all dress up half naked constantly and doing crazy stuff like euphoria….

Wait, we don't? Dang it! I have to return my teenage clown kit I bought online then.

ive seen even younger using that type of clothe in summer specially in the mall lol

also it's clear Ador want this group to be international everything about the MV of Attention screams American Teen Movie

It’s gonna vary from place to place

Where I live it’s normal

Where you might live it might not be

Quote from MissBehave

you're what? (Tries to remember if I was ever mean to you or something)

Anyway, some of their outfits look normal, but the one you posted goes too far imo

I agree with this take. Also, you're a pretty good person on here, you're probably fine.

Quote from Bpsosoro

I agree, honestly adults be thinking we all dress up half naked constantly and doing crazy stuff like euphoria….

some teens where i live use crop tops that show their belly button, das it. and those are the rebellious ones. take into account the area i live in is surrounded by rich kids and you'd think they'd dress differently but nope. still teens just dressing casual

Quote from ripia

I think people need to realize the difference in cultures, korean standards and western standards are completely different. Your local mall in New york is definitely not the same as Seoul this is a country that bans the use of words on music shows that even imply something sexual, you cant measure up the standards on your country vs Korea, please talk about korea if its normal there or not I have no idea personally but I would assume not much.

Sk is way more conservative than u think

Quote from ghostings

Young people don't go to malls anymore lol

Speak for yourself.

Quote from ghostings

Young people don't go to malls anymore lol

maybe in your country but in LA it's flooded lol

Did you see how dress Kourtney Kardashian’s step daughter ?

Quote from Daileemidzy

Speak for yourself.

Agreed! I love going to the mall!

Quote from ripia

It stems from the company using their minors for gross purposes, and fans justify it by saying 'Thats just how teens dress at my common mall' there are so many things to take into consideration, shes on TV and on MV for milliions watching, that means perverts as well. And I'm almost certain that Korean teens do not walk around like that, I bet even adult koreans dont walk around like that.

Also, in my country new zealand it is very rare to see it even among adults, and usually most who dress like that get side eyed.

since I am also new zealand, ripia is kinda right lmao

//rare ripia W

Quote from Jenchulichaengbp

Sk is way more conservative than u think

you used the same gif here as in the other thread lol

Even if that were how 14 year olds dress irl I don't think adults should allow it in the unique situation of performance videos online for god knows who to watch across the globe

I have raised a teen daughter but luckily she didn't dress in skimpy barely there clothing that most young girls seem to love to do. I don't think it's appropriate even if it is K pop. The ages of this group is just questionable to begin with in my opinion.

Quote from Wench

Even if that were how 14 year olds dress irl I don't think adults should allow it in the unique situation of performance videos online for god knows who to watch across the globe

this is the take I agree with most so far

saying it’s not what teenagers wear is pretty easily proven wrong

All the mentions of teenagers being side eyed on the street isn’t that teenagers fault and is a non-issue in this case

But the deliberate choice to style her like that, while /accurate/ to her demographic, could have been more tastefully done in the context of an MV, because it isn’t the only /accurate/ choice out there

Best case scenario is the company learns and moves away from that - I’ll share my

Observation that Hyein has been more conservatively dressed for subsequent performances. And if we’re taking the stance that nothing a company does is accidental then I interpret that as them knowing better and acting on it.

Quote from ripia

I think people need to realize the difference in cultures, korean standards and western standards are completely different. Your local mall in New york is definitely not the same as Seoul this is a country that bans the use of words on music shows that even imply something sexual, you cant measure up the standards on your country vs Korea, please talk about korea if its normal there or not I have no idea personally but I would assume not much.

bruh this one of the reasons i got into k-pop was because i was raised in a conservative family and wasn't able to watch / listen to most music without getting in trouble, but when i found k-pop, aside from mini skirts, there wasn't really anything too immodest about it. i was so surprised (and grateful) to learn the cultural difference, because i was literally afraid to watch american MVs.

Quote from selfmate

you used the same gif here as in the other thread lol

I will be using it a lot

Quote from prettydaisy

ill try to explain it as clear as i can:

i totally agree with calling out the stylists but i disagree that what she was wearing is inappropriate for a teenage girl. and thats the problem i have with kpop fans and how theyre treating new jeans. min heejin is a weirdo and i tried to give her the benefit of the doubt but after cookie, she lost any benefit i gave her. but the way kpop fans keep sexualizing the girls is annoying. no there isn't anything wrong with what hyein is wearing but there is something wrong with a company specifically deciding to put her into that outfit.

thats what people are trying to say

If she choose to wear that in her vacation time or any off time from idol work, it doesnt matter

If its given to her by the company and stylist for promotional reasons, then thats when people dont like it

Quote from YouChanDoThis

Agreed! I love going to the mall!

Quote from quarkie

I like how some of the knetz comments were like "it's the trend!" but then some knetz are also mad because Jennie (a 26 year old woman) is "too revealing" in the Pink Venom teasers.

make it make sense

The same woman who had a CF in only Calvin Klein underwear, which some people were praising. Like....make up your mind.

Quote from prettydaisy

sighs...im not defending the stylist. im defending teen girls who wear outfits like that. i just didnt like how op was like "this outfit is sooo inappropriate, teen girls shouldnt wear this" like let teen girls wear whatever they want.

I don't think that was ghostings point lmao

20-25 years from now, my non-existent lover and I will not condone our non-existent teen wear that.

On the more important note, you can e-mail Ador about your concerns.

Even the excuse of "Oh teenage girls dress like that all the time" wouldn't work. Just because they dress themselves like that doesn't mean it's fine for a literal minor to be exposing themselves in that way. Also, a lot of the teenage girls I've seen would have just a crop top on and that's it. This top on Hyein looks like a sports bra.

Kpop industry can't never get better I guess..

Quote from prettydaisy

sighs...im not defending the stylist. im defending teen girls who wear outfits like that. i just didnt like how op was like "this outfit is sooo inappropriate, teen girls shouldnt wear this" like let teen girls wear whatever they want.

however as u said, hyein doesnt choose her outfits and a company dressing her like that purposefully is weird so go ahead and call the company out. but i just disliked how op chose to do so by dictating how teen girls usually dress and how inappropriate a sports bra is

Because it straight up is inappropriate. I'm all for freedom of style and of course we're not just gonna demand a teenage girl on the street to change her outfit but we can't just ignore that it is still weird for a minor to be wearing that kind of clothing. We are not dictating at all.

Wait, y'all are making a false comparison. 14 y/o that are wearing similar outfits aren't in the context of marketing to a large and varied audience of all ages. There's a reason why all those teens are wearing those outfits in a crowd of similar ages.

If you saw adults looking over at them for too long that would be hella sus.

It's taking something that is shared between those of that age and then exporting it out to everyone else commercially.

Quote from ghostings

Young people don't go to malls anymore lol

The people I saw there were fake then.

I'm not saying the way they're dressing is right or wrong. I'm just saying that I have personally seen it. We all have different perspectives in life and grow up in different places, so we see different things. I live in a more affluent area where parents tend to be a bit more lax with their kids, which is why I likely have seen kids dress up like that.

i think for me i just don't really see this shirt as "revealing" in the way people are insinuating. like wow...her stomach is out...like it would be if she wore a bikini to the beach. her chest is properly covered and the shirt isn't tight. her pants are not low waisted. for me "revealing" clothing is something low cut or extremely tight that is meant to be sexy. but i guess thats just semantics. i do think ador should not dress hyein like this bc of the context though. because regardless of how i see it a creep will see it exactly how they want. and the girls need to be protected from that. none of their stage outfits have been bad tho so i think we don't need to worry too much rn.

It's summer here right now, and this is exactly how kids my age are dressing. Obviously you're not gonna see it at schools when dress codes are strict af. At age 7 they had me wearing shorts under skirts in summer heat for my protection as if I wasn't a literal fetus and men being creeps would be my fault

Anyways, point is that just because you haven't seen 14 year olds dress like that doesn't mean it doesn't happen, it happens a lot actually.

Naw, this is almost the norm when they're outside of school, at least where I'm from. In fact, the girls I went to school with dressed like this AT school. Now, whether they're parents were cool with this or not is another story....