So as you know BTS, Twice and Mamamoo and several other idols of the 3rd gen have many song writing credits to their name. Mamamoo having quite a bit. Red velvet and BP haven’t gotten much opportunity to write music as other groups. Do you think this album which could be their last full album will be a time where BP can finally show their writing skills
Finally See BP writing their own music
-
-
-
-
-
-
lol same
-
-
I never said they didn’t have credits. Rose is credited for her solo songs and so is Lisa. I believe Jisoo and Jennie also had credits for Kill this Love. Who knows how much they actually put into the other two songs which might be why they were not credited. I imagine if they had serious writing credits for either song they would have been included
-
-
-
-
I never said they didn’t have credits. Rose is credited for her solo songs and so is Lisa. I believe Jisoo and Jennie also had credits for Kill this Love. Who knows how much they actually put into the other two songs which might be why they were not credited. I imagine if they had serious writing credits for either song they would have been included
you kinda implied it though, you made it sound like they haven't, specially with this shady ass remark:
"Do you think this album which could be their last full album will be a time where BP can finally show their writing skills"
"finally show", they already showed it.
About the not crediting, yeah that is not an excuse, they should be credited cause they expressed they did participate in writing.
-
I never said they didn’t have credits. Rose is credited for her solo songs and so is Lisa. I believe Jisoo and Jennie also had credits for Kill this Love. Who knows how much they actually put into the other two songs which might be why they were not credited. I imagine if they had serious writing credits for either song they would have been included
*Lovesick girls
-
-
Display More
Jennie and Jisoo are on the credit list for songs in The Album.
Rosie's wrote her solos.
At this point, they're no longer nugus that have no voice in the company so if they do, I'm good.
If not, I'm good too.
It's the end product that mattered to me.
For real I mean that’s good If they’re credited but who cares lol we just want new music
-
you kinda implied it though, you made it sound like they haven't, specially with this shady ass remark:
"Do you think this album which could be their last full album will be a time where BP can finally show their writing skills"
"finally show", they already showed it.
About the not crediting, yeah that is not an excuse, they should be credited cause they expressed they did participate in writing.
Yeah that want being shady. They haven’t shown their ability. Half their writing credits have been with like 10 other writers. That isn’t shade it’s the truth. Learn the difference. Rose I believe is the only one with a song credit that is all her. I don’t say this because I don’t think they have the ability. I think they do and haven’t been allowed. It depends we do t know what was used of their writing in those songs. But again I want to see BP writing not twenty writers jumbled together and BP happened to write one line. I think they are very capable of it and YG won’t let them. No shade at all
-
-
Nope it'll still be Teddy and a bunch of writers
-
Yeah that want being shady. They haven’t shown their ability. Half their writing credits have been with like 10 other writers.
acting as if all the groups you mentioned hasn't done that too except for BTS. You know seeing you in the other thread trying to stirr some shit saying blink this and that when it was a troll and then this thread, it speaks volume of how desperate you are trying to drag BP
-
A good group should be writing their own music imo.
-
-
Half their writing credits have been with like 10 other writers.
Rose I believe is the only one with a song credit that is all her. I don’t say this because I don’t think they have the ability. I think they do and haven’t been allowed. It depends we do t know what was used of their writing in those songs. But again I want to see BP writing not twenty writers jumbled together and BP happened to write one line. I think they are very capable of it and YG won’t let them. No shade at all
I think I see your point now. When someone else pointed out that specific wording, I was a bit confused by it, but after you said this and cleared it up, I understand why. I would also like to see more of them writing huge parts of a song or a whole song by themselves (only if they want to, but I think they do), but I don't know if or when we'll ever get that sadly.
-
Did you mean bops or boobs?
-
Did you mean bops or boobs?
fixed
-
-
So first its about them writing lyrics, then when people tell u they have, its abt them writing lyrics without other writers in the credits?
-
-
-
i don't know maybe from olens or mise en scène
-
Idc as long as I get some ass shaking titty bouncing pleasure inducing music
-
Quote
OP : Half their writing credits have been with like 10 other writers.
Rose I believe is the only one with a song credit that is all her. I don’t say this because I don’t think they have the ability. I think they do and haven’t been allowed. It depends we do t know what was used of their writing in those songs. But again I want to see BP writing not twenty writers jumbled together and BP happened to write one line. I think they are very capable of it and YG won’t let them. No shade at all
Acting like twice also wrote an whole song themselves once in their life when we know they also wrote a few lines (in their b-side) and the rest is made by jyp with their 10 producers
Plus , did you ever walk into bp studio to say it's just one line , did you see exactly on paper how many lines jennie wrote
Are you there when they wrote the song ?
You didn't even know if it was Ktl or Lsg where they were credited.... its shows that you don't follow them and have no clout about them but you come here to make a thread on their work ...Lol , what a joke -
-
idc if they wrote the song or not just deliver the bops
-
-
How am I dragging BP? Twice have all written lyrics and several members have written entire songs for their albums. Mamamoo I believe have many credits including song writing credits for other artists. How is saying I want BP to write their own music because I think they are more than capable considered shading. It’s a fact that them and RV haven’t written nearly been allowed to contribute to their albums nearly as much as other 3rd gen groups. I think they can do more. Also me thinking Some blinks are annoying has nothing to do with BP. Fandom does not equal group. BP are some of the nicest idols by all accounts. It’s not their fault they have a decent percentage of shit fans.
-
Display More
Acting like twice also wrote an whole song themselves once in their life when we know they also wrote a few lines (in their b-side) and the rest is made by jyp with their 10 producers
Plus , did you ever walk into bp studio to say it's just one line , did you see exactly on paper how many lines jennie wrote
Are you there when they wrote the song ?
You didn't even know if it was Ktl or Lsg where they were credited.... its shows that you don't follow them and have no clout about them but you come here to make a thread on their work ...Lol , what a jokeTwice has written entire songs for their albums. Yes they are b sides, and I hope one day JYPE trusts them to write their own title tracks.
Idk, neither do fucking you know. However, I find it unlikely that if they contributed a significant portion of the writing that they would just not be credited. But it’s pointless as they have been credited and they have written some songs like Rose and Lisa and they were good songs. What I am saying is that I want to see them put those talents that we have seen in their solo work into their group album. How the fuck is that shade.
-
Acting like twice also wrote an whole song themselves once in their life when we know they also wrote a few lines (in their b-side) and the rest is made by jyp with their 10 producers
Twice has 29 songs written ONLY by the girls themselves, and 38 songs as main writers with other co-writers. You can defend Blackpink without speaking on things you don't know about
-
-
idc if they wrote the song or not just deliver the bops
This is a fine opinion to have. I think BP have shown they can write great lyrics and I think it would be fantastic if they were given more artistic freedom in their albums. I love Somgs written by others too but my favorite songs from most groups are those written by the artists themselves especially from Twice and BTS m. Some of their best besides were written by the members
-
-
OP.... Am surprised people don't see OP being shady. They have been shady towards bp since the old forum. I remember them quite well.
Nah I’m not being shady. Unless being shady is saying that I want BP to write more of their songs and that from the songs they have written in their solo albums they are more than capable of doing so. Is that shade?
I do however shade blinks as I think it is a pretty shit fandom. Or should I say it has one of the highest proportion of shit fans out of most fandoms.
-
This is a fine opinion to have. I think BP have shown they can write great lyrics and I think it would be fantastic if they were given more artistic freedom in their albums. I love Somgs written by others too but my favorite songs from most groups are those written by the artists themselves especially from Twice and BTS m. Some of their best besides were written by the members
i don't mind if the artist doesn't write their song so long as it isn't a song about their personal journey, then it just doesn't have the same effect as it would've had if they had written it themselves
kinda like born singer by bts where the rap was written by the membersExternal Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy. -
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
