Who will have a bigger solo career: Nayeon vs Rose?

I feel nayeon will be more successful.

If we are talking idol career then Nayeon because JYP will actually give her comebacks.

Jihyo.

depends of the song but to be fair on the ground was in English

good luck to nayeon she will need it. She will definetely be feeling a lot of pressure.

me

Nayeon without a doubt.

BP music career will never reach to their full potentials thanks to their label

Kinda sad, Rose really felt in her place when I was watching sea of hope. She seem to really just like to jam and immerse herself in music.

It’s hard to compare when one hasn’t even released her solo debut yet. I think both will have very successful solo careers!

Quote from TheBotter

Well JYPE famously doesn't do solos much anymore. So we'll see if Nayeon even gets more songs after this.

This could be 1 and done.

Yeap, half of million seller. One and done.......

Yes, I like Nayeon.

Quote from TheBotter

You have to think of it through the eyes of a company as greedy as JYPE.

They won't see half a million, they'll see it as 400k less than a group comeback for a similar time and money investment.

I think you're being a little pessimistic here. The contract expiration is only a few months away and JYPE is basically at Twice's mercy if they want them to stay. It would be pretty damaging not to allow Nayeon to continue her solo career if they want her to stick around. And, mind you, she's arguably the most popular member in Korea. It would be a financial loss to do something to make her want to leave.

Both

Those 2 Rose songs were middling at best. Taylor Swift would be embarrassed.

Rose for sure

at least its guaranteed nayeon will have more songs more cbs, while its uncertain for any bp member because their label would rather jump off a cliff than give them music

Nayeon already has more songs. Rose has international appeal with her voice though.

I could list all of rosé achievements with gone and the ground but that would take hours

Personally I think nayeon will do like joy and a lil better internationally

Why are y'all saying Nayeon will have cbs? Are you guys forgetting TWICE is a group of nine which focuses mainly on group activities? This solo debut was in the vault for 2 years. The only reason it's seeing the light of the day is because contract renewals are close.

After Nayeon, it has been emphasized several times that Twice will have an OT9 cb and unit activities. Pretty sure if they are really renewing, another world tour is coming next year so yeah NOLO 2.0 won't be coming until the next two years.

It's a toss up for me, really. Both are extremely talented at different genres imho.

that being said, Rosé is an accomplished musician and her predominant language proficiency is English.

so in terms of exploring markets, she may have a slight edge on that front.

If we purely stick to Kpop, then Nayeon could possibly have more opportunities to grow a solo career.

Jihyo says Nayeon!

Not people understimating Rosé here as if she wasn't the second most listened kpop female artist behind BP when she debuted, as if she didn't sold 600k without the 2nd kpop boom sales, as if she doesn't have the 3rd most streamed kpop female soloist album behind Somi with an actual Full and Lisa only, as if she didn't topped billboard global 200, as if she didn't peaked in 450k uls with an english song and managed to chart her english bside too.

Please the whole incertainity about yg not letting her release music excuse is even more bs, because if she leaves yg, she will release more music and if she stays she will have the power on her side to decide her contract.

wouldn't be better to wait till the album is released first? lol

Yes, I love Nayeon and Rosé

Nayeon for me ..

On one hand jyp is infamously bad with solo careers. On the other yg doesn't give anyone comebacks least of all Blackpink members. So it's a tie for me.

Rosé obvvvvvv... they might hit similar range in Korea or Nayeon might have a little more edge as the songs will cater to their domestic audience but internationally it isn't even a competition...

Definitely Nayeon, her title track is better and she’s just generally more popular than rose in Korea.

after finally getting through Nayeons album. I can honestly say I think Nayeon will have the better career. Even her b-sides were more interesting than Rosè's songs to me. I might be biased bc I really like Nayeons voice. But I'm sure Rosè is going to do really well in her own way with the brand deals and whatever else she decides to do.

Let me get my magic ball real quick

In Korea, probably Nayeon.

Worldwide, Rosé.

I didn't vote. I think their careers have the potential to be big in two different ways. Nayeon's doing something within K-Pop and Rosé having potential doing her singer-songwriter thing more outside of K-Pop.

Quote from nahadoth

On one hand jyp is infamously bad with solo careers. On the other yg doesn't give anyone comebacks least of all Blackpink members. So it's a tie for me.

Yeah but Twice is the most successful JYP acts of all time. They should be hold into different standard. JYP is dumb but they are not totally braindead when it comes to management

idk why some people think Rosé wouldn't be very successful in Sk when she is actually one of the most popular 3rd gen idols and have gotten viral several times in sk for her voice and koreans generally love her singing, also her solo debut charting in kr was good considering both the songs were in english. The only thing I am personally concerned is if she stays with yg, how many solo cbs she can get, that's all.

Must we always pit women against one another just cuz

It's a big planet, more than one person can be successful and carve out their own niche

Quote from Wench

Must we always pit women against one another just cuz

It's a big planet, more than one person can be successful and carve out their own niche

Exactly! Like not more than one solo female artist can be really succesful or more than one girl group lol Meanwhile female solos and girl groups are thriving We've had 3 female soloists with over 500k album sales in the past 2 years and multiple girl groups are surpassing 1m album sales do u guys realize how amazing that is in general