This is wild, I found a translation from the belift CEO's defence of the returning thing and its just plain funny
House of Representatives: You know about pushing out the sound board, right??
One of the two methods used by Hive to increase initial sales is to sell the album with a return condition, and the other is to dispose of the album through lucky draws, events, etc.
Kim Tae-ho (CEO of Belief Lab): We have never sold albums with a return condition.
Rep. Min: Then I will show you the internal information. It is an email dated January 4, 2024. You wrote exactly that this is a project scheduled for return.
Kim Tae-ho: A return for an album sold in 2023 was made in early 2024. We looked into this and decided not to make sales like this in the future...
Rep. Min: Let me show you one more.
This is a return condition. The additional quantity is a minimum of 70,000 pieces and a maximum of 200,000 pieces. What is this?
Kim: We confirmed that these discussions were taking place, so this kind of thing should not happen.
Min: You used to do it, but you don't do it now?
Kim: We have confirmed that some returns were made based on the judgment of our employees rather than our company's policy, and we have established guidelines as part of our company regulations to ensure that sales like this never happen again.