Ahyeon, Pharita and Rora - 'Golden' 2025 MAMA

That was an... interesting note to end on.

Rami would've done perfect covering Rumis part

I like ahyeon

With the right teacher she can be ariana

Before superyeah asking my opinion, I'm here faster, LOL! Are you okay mate, you're a bit slow today.😂

Anyway, here are my two cents.

Ahyeon, Rora and Pharita did well. Their voices are shaky, because they're not used to perform like this, but it's 100% LIVE and not bad. This was a well-balanced "GOLDEN" cover, but that last high note from Ahyeon was unnecessary and bad!

Which one is the pink hair girl? She was the best!

I miss Rami, but let's be real, YG would never give her a chance in this cover, because she should've been in Ahyeon's place to handle the hard parts of the song.

Also, it's good they didn't do the cover in the original way. That would be much harder.

There's a slight chance people won't hate on them much, because that one last high note from Ahyeon is too short for a Tiktok or Insta reel. 🤣

Quote from David33

Before superyeah asking my opinion, I'm here faster, LOL! Are you okay mate, you're a bit slow today.😂

Anyway, here are my two cents.

Ahyeon, Rora and Pharita did well. Their voices are shaky, because they're not used to perform like this, but it's 100% LIVE and not bad. This was a well-balanced "GOLDEN" cover, but that last high note from Ahyeon was unnecessary and bad!

Which one is the pink hair girl? She was the best!

I miss Rami, but let's be real, YG would never give her a chance in this cover, because she should've been in Ahyeon's place to handle the hard parts of the song.

Also, it's good they didn't do the cover in the original way. That would be much harder.

There's a slight chance people won't hate on them much, because that one last high note from Ahyeon is too short for a Tiktok or Insta reel. 🤣

Display More

I'll tell you right now, even if Rami is still in the group, she won't get Rumi's parts.

The same reason why Ahyeon has all the high notes in their title tracks even with Rami in the group

Quote from QueenMaknae27

I'll tell you right now, even if Rami is still in the group, she won't get Rumi's parts.

The same reason why Ahyeon has all the high notes in their title tracks even with Rami in the group

At least we can agree on something. Must be Christmas already. 😂

To be honest, it's not like Ahyeon is bad, it's just Rami is much better, but she can't go viral so YG doesn't care about her.

Quote from David33

At least we can agree on something. Must be Christmas already. 😂

To be honest, it's not like Ahyeon is bad, it's just Rami is much better, but she can't go viral so YG doesn't care about her.

Agree on what??

Ahyeon would have an easier time to hit the original notes of Golden, which they did, compared to Rami

what the hell

that was great! I was nervous about it but they all sounded really good, I felt rora really shined. And Ahyeons china popularity is seriously no joke lol crowd goes wild for her.

I was scrolling and found this

She needs a new vocal coach.

All the haters on X stan groups who can't even sing live

I think we forget that this is the first time and the only time this song has been covered in kpop completely live in original key. Even the original singers can't

Only handful of artists in the world can cover this song flawlessly

Ahyeon's last note was intentional. Do I think it's necessary? Absolutely not, but it's not because of technique

Quote from QueenMaknae27

All the haters on X stan groups who can't even sing live

I think we forget that this is the first time and the only time this song has been covered in kpop completely live in original key. Even the original singers can't

Only handful of artists in the world can cover this song flawlessly

Ahyeon's last note was intentional. Do I think it's necessary? Absolutely not, but it's not because of technique

The original singer is sick 

Quote from CaraFIMIE

The original singer is sick 

I know. But that doesn't prove anything. They have to show that they can do it

Quote from QueenMaknae27

I know. But that doesn't prove anything. They have to show that they can do it

Quote from QueenMaknae27

Agree on what??

Ahyeon would have an easier time to hit the original notes of Golden, which they did, compared to Rami

Not in a million years, sorry. Did you hear her last note? That was really bad. This song doesn't suit Ahyeon at all, not the original version.

Quote from David33

Not in a million years, sorry. Did you hear her last note? That was really bad. This song doesn't suit Ahyeon at all, not the original version.

Like I said, the last note was intentional. Without that note, it is a very very good cover

Even the director praised their cover

Quote from QueenMaknae27

Like I said, the last note was intentional. Without that note, it is a very very good cover

Even the director praised their cover

So you're saying she did a bad job on porpoise, are you mad?

That's literally what I said, didn't you read my 1st comment? I said they did a good job, except that one note. Even you said it was unnecessary.

Quote from QueenMaknae27

I think we forget that this is the first time and the only time this song has been covered in kpop completely live in original key. Even the original singers can't

This isn't true. This was an ENCORE, and a fan request, and she added "IC" as well.😂

And no, I'm not comparing Ahyeong with Solar, that would be nonsense, I'm just saying they're not the first one who covered the song 100% live. And she did this after she sang her other song, "BLUES" twice. That's even harder than "GOLDEN", btw.

Quote from QueenMaknae27

I'll tell you right now, even if Rami is still in the group, she won't get Rumi's parts.

The same reason why Ahyeon has all the high notes in their title tracks even with Rami in the group

they can just lower the pitch. it’s way too high anw, even the og singer lowered the pitch in her live performances. ahyeon is good if she sings in a comfortable range. once she’s out of her range, she sounds so nasal and squeaky

Minju instead of Pharita would have been better

YG's Thai obsession created an awkward situation

Quote from superyeah

I was too tired from staying up the night before. I fell asleep, so I missed watching the stream.

And thank you. Pharita is the girl with pink hair. She and Rora (the other one in this performance) have been filling in for Rami nicely during live performances, including the concerts.

Yeah, she was great, but sadly Babymon feels unbalanced for me without Rami. Her vocal and overall performance adds a lot to the group. I said this before, but she's the backbone of BM like Wheein for Mamamoo.

Quote from justscrolling

I was scrolling and found this

External Content x.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Armys are attacking them?

Maybe it's a sign girl are finally hitting big

I wish there was a section for how it's done. I feel that song is very underrated. I would've loved to hear Asa or Ruka on that.

That was a very good performance and I'm happy for them. Pharita seems to have improved imo and it's nice to see a group that's confident and having fun with a song.

Quote from Jasque-O-Part2

Armys are attacking them?

Maybe it's a sign girl are finally hitting big

People need to realize Twitter is not the whole word, it's not even a dried up lake.😂

Quote from David33

So you're saying she did a bad job on porpoise, are you mad?

That's literally what I said, didn't you read my 1st comment? I said they did a good job, except that one note. Even you said it was unnecessary.

This isn't true. This was an ENCORE, and a fan request, and she added "IC" as well.😂

External Content x.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

And no, I'm not comparing Ahyeong with Solar, that would be nonsense, I'm just saying they're not the first one who covered the song 100% live. And she did this after she sang her other song, "BLUES" twice. That's even harder than "GOLDEN", btw.

Display More

What in "completely" you don't understand?

Thank you for showing this. I more than satisfied with how Ahyeon sounded

Quote from msmelon

they can just lower the pitch. it’s way too high anw, even the og singer lowered the pitch in her live performances. ahyeon is good if she sings in a comfortable range. once she’s out of her range, she sounds so nasal and squeaky

To be fair, Golden is really hard to sing in the 5th Gmaj note. If they lowered the key, then that's cupcake for them. Even Pharita can be Rumi.

Quote from QueenMaknae27

What in "completely" you don't understand?

Thank you for showing this. I more than satisfied with how Ahyeon sounded

She didn't perform the whole song, just the hardest part. So, what's your point exactly?

You can prefer anything you want, I don't care about that. Ahyeon wasn't bad until that last note. That's all. It's not that deep.

Quote from David33

So you're saying she did a bad job on porpoise, are you mad?

That's literally what I said, didn't you read my 1st comment? I said they did a good job, except that one note. Even you said it was unnecessary.

Yep, not a fan of it when she does that. As someone who watches every fancam of her from the entire tour, I’ve noticed she tends to overdo it when she’s excited. And YG himself doesn’t stop her. Drip’s 3-octave note even came from that, because YG heard her ‘overdoing’ her notes.

I am not worried about her. She's young and relatively new, in 2 years, she's going to be untouchable

Quote from QueenMaknae27

Yep, not a fan of it when she does that. As someone who watches every fancam of her from the entire tour, I’ve noticed she tends to overdo it when she’s excited. And YG himself doesn’t stop her. Drip’s 3-octave note even came from that, because YG heard her ‘overdoing’ her notes.

I am not worried about her. She's young and relatively new, in 2 years, she's going to be untouchable

That's not a 3 octave mate, just 3 note. 3 octaves is different. People said this about IU's "Good Day" back in the day, they always mix the two things. 3 octaves is much harder.

That's my problem, YG doesn't stop her, and that's why I'm actually worried, because much better vocalists ruined their vocal cords, and if no one protects her she can lose her career if she's lucky, if not she can lose her voice as well. Singing is not just fun and games, it's a hard job, just like any physical sport.

Also, as you said, she's young, that's why it's even worse for her.

Quote from David33

She didn't perform the whole song, just the hardest part. So, what's your point exactly?

You can prefer anything you want, I don't care about that. Ahyeon wasn't bad until that last note. That's all. It's not that deep.

Solar was struggling in the chorus compared to Ahyeon who made it look easier

That's what I've said from the start.

Quote from David33

That's not a 3 octave mate, just 3 note. 3 octaves is different. People said this about IU's "Good Day" back in the day, they always mix the two things. 3 octaves is much harder.

That's my problem, YG doesn't stop her, and that's why I'm actually worried, because much better vocalists ruined their vocal cords, and if no one protects her she can lose her career if she's lucky, if not she can lose her voice as well. Singing is not just fun and games, it's a hard job, just like any physical sport.

Also, as you said, she's young, that's why it's even worse for her.

I meant it as 3 notes in the same octave

Guess what? that's the same as Good Day

If YG listens, then they would've change Rose's singing style from the start

I'm sure she will learn how to control her big voice in the future

If I am wrong, then that's YG's fault