Mamamoo vs NMixx vs Babymonster - which group is the most talented? which group is the most well rounded?

Quote from David33

Oh, so you have a gambling problem, I see? 🤣

I do like a gamble or two lol

Quote from selfmate

I do like a gamble or two lol

We're more alike than I thought, but I only bet on (European) football games.😂

Neither Mamamoo or BaeMon have done an a cappella teaser for their albums so NMIXX wins Vocals. Mamamoo is supposed to be good at Vocals but they were struggling doing an AoA song in the original key on Queendom.

Neither Mamamoo or Baemon have done live Vocals and Choreo for a Dance Practise so NMIXX wins for Vocals while Dancing.

As for Dancing..... well... their Thunderous cover was the best BG cover I've seen but they did have Jinni, I have to watch more of BM but Mamamoo weren't the best Dancers.

Quote from jimeous

Neither Mamamoo or BaeMon have done an a cappella teaser for their albums so NMIXX wins Vocals. Mamamoo is supposed to be good at Vocals but they were struggling doing an AoA song in the original key on Queendom.

Neither Mamamoo or Baemon have done live Vocals and Choreo for a Dance Practise so NMIXX wins for Vocals while Dancing.

As for Dancing..... well... their Thunderous cover was the best BG cover I've seen but they did have Jinni, I have to watch more of BM but Mamamoo weren't the best Dancers.

This is like the worst trolling I've EVER seen! If you don't know anything about MAMAMOO, at least don't say anything! MAMAMOO is literally the Queens of acapella since debut days! The whole industry raving about them and their unique introduction! They did acapella on LIVE television and everywhere more times than how many Kpop groups ever existed since the beginning!

Quote

Mamamoo is supposed to be good at Vocals but they were struggling doing an AoA song in the original key on Queendom.

If you don't know what COVER actually means, you should shut up! They're literally called the Queens of covers, because they're done more than anyone else, and they always make those songs sounds like their own, not to mention, a LOT of their covers made the original artists cry.🤣

But since you said this, here's the proof! Also, why do you think NMIXX basically debuted on Hwasa Show, and why the members always say their biggest Idols are MAMAMOO?

This is MAMAMOO when they're having fun at a karaoke, singing better than most people, also rap!🤣

About dancing: This is what the best choreographers said about MAMAMOO!

And this is what Lee Hyori said about them!

I can go on all day about this if you want!🤣

Quote from SooYoung

Mamamoo = they are last in dancing, and vocally i actually think that the duo Solar/wheein isn't that far ahead of Lily/Haewon what gave them the advantage is that they have a rapper in the group

What I said above! Their vocals usually outshine how amazing dancers they are. Not my words, btw, it was said by the industry and other Idols.

As for vocals, everyone in MAMAMOO are far ahead of both NMIXX and Babymon, especially nowadays. Not to mention Solar, since she developed much more since her 2 musical roles. A couple of years ago she only had 3 octave range, but now she has 4.

And for the rap, not only between these groups, but in Kpop in general, there aren't as many REAL rappers whom are more versatile than Moonbyul, and I didn't mention the other official rapper, Hwasa, and when they do it properly, Solar and Wheein are easily can outdo almost everyone! Especially these groups!

Just watch their raps.

Quote from David33

This is like the worst trolling I've EVER seen! If you don't know anything about MAMAMOO, at least don't say anything! MAMAMOO is literally the Queens of acapella since debut days! The whole industry raving about them and their unique introduction! They did acapella on LIVE television and everywhere more times than how many Kpop groups ever existed since the beginning!

If you don't know what COVER actually means, you should shut up! They're literally called the Queens of covers, because they're done more than anyone else, and they always make those songs sounds like their own, not to mention, a LOT of their covers made the original artists cry.🤣

But since you said this, here's the proof! Also, why do you think NMIXX basically debuted on Hwasa Show, and why the members always say their biggest Idols are MAMAMOO?

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

This is MAMAMOO when they're having fun at a karaoke, singing better than most people, also rap!🤣

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

About dancing: This is what the best choreographers said about MAMAMOO!

External Content x.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content x.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

And this is what Lee Hyori said about them!

External Content x.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

I can go on all day about this if you want!🤣

What I said above! Their vocals usually outshine how amazing dancers they are. Not my words, btw, it was said by the industry and other Idols.

As for vocals, everyone in MAMAMOO are far ahead of both NMIXX and Babymon, especially nowadays. Not to mention Solar, since she developed much more since her 2 musical roles. A couple of years ago she only had 3 octave range, but now she has 4.

And for the rap, not only between these groups, but in Kpop in general, there aren't as many REAL rappers whom are more versatile than Moonbyul, and I didn't mention the other official rapper, Hwasa, and when they do it properly, Solar and Wheein are easily can outdo almost everyone! Especially these groups!

Just watch their raps.

Display More

You've given evidence of Mamamoo's a capella but not of an Album Teaser which I stated, the difference is an Album Teaser shows the different Song structures and genre because it's easy to do a capella for a single song.

Whether an Individual is better at dancing is irrelevant since we are comparing the Group Dancing and Mamamoo couldn't do Thunderous at NMIXX's level, whom were singing at the same time so it wasn't just a Dance Cover.

NMIXX can cover any Mamamoo song and choreo but I don't think Mamamoo could do the same with NMIXX especially as Mamamoo had to lower the chord when they covered AoA on Queendom, NMIXX wouldn't have to.

BUT..............

Rapping...

NMIXX is dead last for Rapping

Quote from David33

We're more alike than I thought, but I only bet on (European) football games.😂

I prefer in person gambling like blackjack or poker or mahjong lol

Quote from jimeous

You've given evidence of Mamamoo's a capella but not of an Album Teaser which I stated, the difference is an Album Teaser shows the different Song structures and genre because it's easy to do a capella for a single song.

Whether an Individual is better at dancing is irrelevant since we are comparing the Group Dancing and Mamamoo couldn't do Thunderous at NMIXX's level, whom were singing at the same time so it wasn't just a Dance Cover.

NMIXX can cover any Mamamoo song and choreo but I don't think Mamamoo could do the same with NMIXX especially as

BUT..............

Rapping...

NMIXX is dead last for Rapping

Display More

Are you blind or something? Dude, it's literally the FIRST VIDEO! White Wind EP medley! And they did that multiple times!

You really want to embarrass yourself, do you? MAMAMOO never did a cover of Thunderous.

But can you show ANY Kpop group that did an 11 minute long medley at a 4 HOUR long concert in high heels and still sing perfectly? No, you can't!

This is NMIXX covering the HARDEST Kpop song ever existed! MAMAMOO's Decalcomanie! I LOVE them, but they failed! Still 10 times better than pretty much everyone else (except other RBW groups), but still.

Also, let's not forget about Solar's FIRE cover, she was literally flying in air and then covered BTS perfectly!🤣

Meanwhile, this is what Lily the strongest vocalist in NMIXX said about MAMAMOO!🤣

I don't think MAMAMOO ever did a cover of an NMIXX song tho!

Seriously, I think you just want to rile me up! It won't happen my friend, but I can educate you if you're a newbie.😂

Quote

Mamamoo had to lower the chord when they covered AoA on Queendom, NMIXX wouldn't have to.

Again, wrong! MAMAMOO never sing anything the same way as the original, that's the whole point of doing a cover! Did AOA did "Egotistic" in the same way or anyone on Queendom? No, they didn't. So, what's your point exactly?

I don't think you realize why MAMAMOO is called the Queens of Covers in Korea, but here are some examples!

Byul and EXY, doing a hard choreo while singing live!😂

They made the original artist cry, Part 1 and Part 2!😂

And they're making everyone else cry as well!

Quote from selfmate

I prefer in person gambling like blackjack or poker or mahjong lol

I did that too like 15 years ago, but I stop doing it, because it's not good for my health, not to mention my bank account balance. 😂

Quote from David33

I did that too like 15 years ago, but I stop doing it, because it's not good for my health, not to mention my bank account balance. 😂

I've always gambled with the philosophy that I'm going to lose...and thus the monies I gamble I consider entertainment.

I guess I could spend my money on other forms of entertainment - sports, food, movies, games hell even kpop but gambling is merely one more form of entertainment but I guess one has to show great restraint when winning or losing!!!

Quote from selfmate

I've always gambled with the philosophy that I'm going to lose...and thus the monies I gamble I consider entertainment.

I guess I could spend my money on other forms of entertainment - sports, food, movies, games hell even kpop but gambling is merely one more form of entertainment but I guess one has to show great restraint when winning or losing!!!

That's why only bet on sport nowadays, I don't spent a lot of money or lose.😅

Quote from David33

That's why only bet on sport nowadays, I don't spent a lot of money or lose.😅

ahhh I've actually never placed a sports bet before whether in person or online

I’d say bm overall, but this poll feels a bit disrespectful since mamamoo holds a special place in kpop history with their unique style and color. it’s not always about being the most talented, sometimes impact matters more. in this case, both nmixx and bm still have a long way to go.

Quote from jimeous

Neither Mamamoo or BaeMon have done an a cappella teaser for their albums so NMIXX wins Vocals. Mamamoo is supposed to be good at Vocals but they were struggling doing an AoA song in the original key on Queendom.

Neither Mamamoo or Baemon have done live Vocals and Choreo for a Dance Practise so NMIXX wins for Vocals while Dancing.

As for Dancing..... well... their Thunderous cover was the best BG cover I've seen but they did have Jinni, I have to watch more of BM but Mamamoo weren't the best Dancers.

Singing high does not always mean singing well or being the best singer. They went for a lower key in Queendom to be comfortable. They have covered songs with a higher key or even some of theirs songs are. They won Immortal Songs three times with more challenging songs than Good Luck.

Queendom is edited so we did not see the whole practice of the song but they were doing fine with the original key.

As for singing and dancing practice, here for you.

Quote from SooYoung

It's definitely BabyMonster by far

it's not best vocalist but most talented

BabyMonster = They are the most well rounded, yes their vocal line doesn't compare to Mamamoo or NMIXX vocal line, but Rora, Rami and Ahyeon still are a pretty solid vocal line, they just doesn't have a big vocalist that leaves you speechless

They have by far the best rapper from the three groups

and i would say i think they are also better dancer as a group than MMM and NMIXX

Mamamoo = they are last in dancing, and vocally i actually think that the duo Solar/wheein isn't that far ahead of Lily/Haewon

what gave them the advantage is that they have a rapper in the group

NMIXX = NMIXX have a strong vocal line but i think that their vocal line doesn't compare to MMM vocal line yet

the reason why i would put them last

is that they have no rapper in their group in comparison of MMM and BM, Jiwoo do the rapper role but it's more like we don't know what to give her so let's give her rap parts

But in term of dancing they are way above mamamoo dancing skills

to me the final ranking is :

BM > MMM > NMIXX

Display More

Hwasa is actually a better singer than Lily and Haewon too. There is a tiny gap between her and Wheein/Solar.