The maknae is only 12. This might be a record. Girl is not even a teenager yet. 
the media over here in the ph is celebrating all that. i think they missed the fact that the whole thing is so bizarre
She literally looks like a toddler. The fact that she was voted by fans to be in the group is even more crazy to me. The kpop stan community has failed.
i guess a record for kpop...jpop been debuting 9 year olds for ages already.
the media over here in the ph is celebrating all that. i think they missed the fact that the whole thing is so bizarre
I hate everyone who was involved in her selection to the group. Her parents, the company, her fans, all of them.
I hate everyone who was involved in her selection to the group. Her parents, the company, her fans, all of them.
i'm with you on that. especially the parents since they have the final say in everything including the contract signing
Think about this. When T-ara released Roly Poly some of them has yet to inhale a single molecule of oxygen
first what article missed is that she has 13th birthday on january 27th
second pretty sure that as usual for final episodes Knetz had more to say than ifans during voting, plus the judges were there
third as article is also pointing age gap, I already wrote it in different thread, age gap in IZ*ONE between Eunbi and Wonyoung was 9 years, and age gap in Kep1er between Yujin and Yeseo was 9 years as well
so yeah technically speaking this is the highest gap but it shouldn't be shocking for people
another point is we are in 2024 and time flies fast
we had IVE Leeseo (born in 2007) debuting in 2021
we had NewJeans Hyein (born in 2008) debuting in 2022
same with CLASS:y's Boeun and Seonyou
Young Posse Jieun born in 2009 debuted in 2023
Babymonster Chiquita born in 2009 debuted in 2023...
it is what it is, it's just US who are getting older, and this way it seems that kids are getting younger
to the moment when k-government will make a certain decision about minimal debut age we will see things like this happening...
GP Basic Janey paved the way.
Feel a bit sad for the girl that is 22/23..... She can't be happy to be with girls that are 6-10 years younger. Crazy stuff.
If I’m not this girl was already famous before the show she took part in that trot show for kids and she sang After like by Ive trot version
Imagine being 22 and having to be in a group with a 12 year old 
free choice and free will and all that...
ultimately it's up to her and her parents...
she obviously wanted to do this and apparently she's getting her wish...
I'm not sure if this universe show will have a standard 7 year contract but if they do she'll be 19 when she completes her contract which is younger than a lot of other kpop debutees!!!
If I’m not this girl was already famous before the show she took part in that trot show for kids and she sang After like by Ive trot version
Yes, she was a staple of trot shows for children before.
Therefore a dual standard exists - it is OK for Koreans to debut children as trot singers to sing before older people, but not to debut them as KPop idols!
free choice and free will and all that...
ultimately it's up to her and her parents...
she obviously wanted to do this and apparently she's getting her wish...
I'm not sure if this universe show will have a standard 7 year contract but if they do she'll be 19 when she completes her contract which is younger than a lot of other kpop debutees!!!
And she already has considerable trot experience so she can choose which way to take.
I hate everyone who was involved in her selection to the group. Her parents, the company, her fans, all of them.
Her parents are the only ones to blame for this. They aren't acting in their child's best interest, they only care about fame and money. If they don't care, why would her company care?
12 yo. Jfc
Imagine being 22 and having to be in a group with a 12 year old
I would cryy, I hope she is well compensated for this.
If I’m not this girl was already famous before the show she took part in that trot show for kids and she sang After like by Ive trot version
Wait it's that one girl?
Wait it's that one girl?
yeah she’s this girl
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
