Which "Big Five" girl groups do you prefer? 3rd Gen or 4th Gen?

The music from the 4th Gen vibes with me more personally - I listen to all 4 out of 5 groups. Whereas for 3rd gen, I only listen to a few songs from each casually.

3rd gen was FUN and FRESH. 4th gen is as lackluster as it could get. you ain't get no singing, no talent, no training for 10 years just to debut in a flop group that sells 500 copies each comeback, no interacting with other idols at award shows, no smiling, no happiness, no life, no good music, no SM paving the way, no trend setters, no nothing.

Really, I only like one 3rd gen group and that is Twice.

I don't care about others or from other gens.

Twice and BP alone have more 9s and 10s amongst their singles and promoted B sides than all five 4th gen GGs combined. Hell, Twice or BP alone have more.

Twice:

WIL

Heartshaker

Cry For Me

Scientist

Knock Knock

Signal

DTNA

More and More

Feel Special

Blackpink:

BBY

AIIYL

PWF

HYLT

KTL

Lovesick Girls

Ice Cream

Ready For Love

Pink Venom

vs

4th Gen:

Dumdi

OMG

Next Level

Impurities

I Am

Kitsch

Afterlike

OMG

But 4th gen groups trounce the 3rd gen groups when it comes to other stuff that is just as important as the music, like fanservice content.

I pick 4th Gen GG Big 5

IVE - my favorite , I like all members and main center is Wonyoung and Yujin

all 5 GG from 4th gen are considered a visual group

in terms of song discography
TWICE 2015-2018 will hard carry the 3rd gen to win this for me

or better replaced Mamamoo and G Friend with

I.O.I and Momoland
w Somi , Nancy and Yeonwoo

or AOA Seolhyun (3rd Gen?)

Quote from YamaChwan

REALLY tough choice

Blackpink is my ult group, above all, but the only other 3rd gen group that I really love is Dreamcatcher. Otherwise I only like a few RV and Twice songs.

But while I like a good number of songs from most of the Top 5 groups, none of the groups are in MY personal Top listing.

I'm split

This is so hard because Gfriend is my favorite kpop gg ever... but I like Lesserafim, G idle and Ive more than the other 3rd gen gg.

Ofc 3gen... few hit song but more memorable!!

4gen is a bit boring

Discography-wise, fourth generation girl groups keep serving me music most consistently; from debut to present.

I stan Mamamoo, Red Velvet and kinda Twice so the choice is easy. I also really like Gfriend and Blackpink songs. I am also a fan of aespa and (G)-Idle.

3rd genn >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 4th gen

I vote Blackpink

3rd gen has more memorable hits to me but i only like Twice.

4th gen i have no favorite but like most groups

A tie for me

3rd gen I like RV and Mamamoo, like a bit GFriend, dislike Twice and Blackpink

In 4th gen I like New Jeans and Les Serafim, like a bit G Idle, dislike Aespa and Ive