Is soyeon the only female kpop idol to have a 100% self written song hit PAKs?
-
-
-
It’s actually a really cool achievement, so I am very happy for her. I will say though that I think lyrically, it’s not her best - but the way everything came together has worked out really well and she deserves her accolades.
-
-
-
-
-
isn't IU considered and idol? Anyway, congrats, legends only
On odd days, she is
On even days, she isn't
Depending on what the person wants to pitch.
Typically, if flaunting their own faves achievements, then she won't be an idol, for she would beat them.
But if to challenge another fandom claiming any achievement, IU will be an idol, to beat them with.
She is like "Schroedinger's Cat", both idol/not-idol, you have to know the intention/context.
-
-
-
-
Display More
On odd days, she is
On even days, she isn't
Depending on what the person wants to pitch.
Typically, if flaunting their own faves achievements, then she won't be an idol, for she would beat them.
But if to challenge another fandom claiming any achievement, IU will be an idol, to beat them with.
She is like "Schroedinger's Cat", both idol/not-idol, you have to know the intention/context.
I'd consider her an idol because of her rookie day gigs and stuff, she used to do very idol like things. But I wouldn't say she is in the kpop genre tho, much like Ailee or Hyolyn. Alexa is someone that comes to mind when I think of a female soloist who sings Kpop.. it's actually really strange and a grey area now that I think about it
That said I don't think not being the first of the only one ever undermines Soyeon's achievement considering how difficult this is -
This is basically normal for Idol Composers as their music is usually screened by the Company.
Screening means that the Song is going through a process that the company deems fit for the Artists' Image.
-
It’s actually a really cool achievement, so I am very happy for her. I will say though that I think lyrically, it’s not her best - but the way everything came together has worked out really well and she deserves her accolades.
Agreed
Hope that many more women follow
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
