Nmixx have surprisingly good stable vocals for being rookies

Agree, they are very talented.

I am a little unsure how "live" these vocals are, so I am excited to see some more performances from them in the future.

they're good + the rest are bad so they are a surprise

They did amazing. Some groups haven’t even sung live in performances at all yet.

This is live but it has a little auto tune done after the performance. If you listen to the MR removed Haewon doesn’t sing at all during her bridge.

Still, it’s a great performance from a rookie girl group.

Quote from unbannBLACPINK

they're good + the rest are bad so they are a surprise

So you think NiziU are bad singers then?

I was genuinely and pleasantly surprised by Lily tackling the singing head on! it looked like she was really looking forward to that moment and she really did a great job delivering.

The rest of NMIXX as well sounded really good, not even going to lie.

Quote from pravda

So you think NiziU are bad singers then?

For the sake of this thread and all of our sanities, please do not start an inquisition here or now. Save that for DM's or a dumpster fire thread.

Not even Beyoncé wouldn’t have been stable with that choreo. I’m sure they sing some lines but I think it’s mostly back track

Quote from Kataphract

For the sake of this thread and all of our sanities, please do not start an inquisition here or now. Save that for DM's or a dumpster fire thread.

Hmmm okay. And your not doing the same comment on his response that basically took a dump on all the other JYP groups because?

Quote from pravda

Hmmm okay. And your not doing the same comment on his response that basically took a dump on all the other JYP groups because?

1.) I don't want to derail this thread

2.) Whether or not any group is insulted on a not that well known western-based forum/community site is highly unlikely to actually offend, hurt, or hinder the actual groups.

3.) If I were actually mad, its still a waste of time and energy fighting over something so inconsequential.

Bro I’d easily like them if they sang like that Superman part for a whole song…good thing is their career just started so I’m sure we will see many different things from them.

JYPe has been concentrating on their live vocals for the last two groups so this is not a surprise. What I'm actually happiest about isn't really Lily's voice because I already knew it was going to be good but her dancing. She never really showed dancing ability until now. Even in the showcases from all the reports she just sang an sang beautifully. So her dancing and singing is awesome.

If jyp is smart they’ll let lily m and Haewon release some solo songs In the future or some unit songs like what they did in twice last album. I want to hear more of these 2

They re so talented. I think their vocal line became one of my fav in this gen

Their vocal line is unexpected for a JYP girl group at debut. good job