Be honest... Who has a better vocal colour? ... Winter vs NingNing

I like Ningning's

she sound like a princess

NN I love her voice

I picked Ningning but tbh, it's Karina.

definitely ningning for me

ninging's tone sounds warm so I prefer hers

winter's voice isn't very warm imo but that makes them sound good together

NingNing and tbh her pronunciation sometimes remind me of GD. It's stylish and i like it.

Her voice is mesmerizing!

I Think ningning but like they sound really similar to me still

Karina Giselle Winter Ningning

Can't decide tbh

Yes, I like Giselle.

TBH, I think they both have similar color, but Ningning is a bit warmer. I went with Ningning, but I don't have a strong argument for one over the other.

Ningning for me cause her

Voice is warm and rich but Winter voice is also charming

Ninging tbh I used to think winter but I realized her voice is too high-pitched for me Ninging voice is more full if that makes sense.

I would say they're about equal to me in terms of how much I like their voices, but I feel like Winter tends to sound really piercing when she sings high so ima give it to NingNing

NingNing

I prefer NingNing's warmer, richer tones, but they're both great vocalists!