Does charting means good music?

Rollin didn't chart well for 4 years

No. I agree with what SooYoung said. I also want to say that a lot of the big fandoms just stream because it was released by the people they stan.

lol

Something being popular doesn't mean it's good.

Something being good doesn't mean it's popular.

Things can also be both popular and good.

Not always.

No, being obsessed with charts is one of the stupidest things kpop fans do.

This is such a moving target. People shout that your group didn’t succeed/doesn’t matter because they don’t chart. Then when they do chart, it’s not high enough. Or not long enough. Then when they top the charts, clearly there is some scheme/conspiracy. Or a discussion about the shit taste of the audience. The taste which was just fine and the arbiter of all things when your group wasn’t charting. Or the it’s the fandom, not the GP argument.

So to answer your question, it’s whichever way the wind is blowing that day.

charting means more people are listening to it ie. the popularity of the music...

whether a music is good or not is subjective...

what I find good might be different to what you find good

Nope

Quote from the101

This is such a moving target. People shout that your group didn’t succeed/doesn’t matter because they don’t chart. Then when they do chart, it’s not high enough. Or not long enough. Then when they top the charts, clearly there is some scheme/conspiracy. Or a discussion about the shit taste of the audience. The taste which was just fine and the arbiter of all things when your group wasn’t charting. Or the it’s the fandom, not the GP argument.

So to answer your question, it’s whichever way the wind is blowing that day.

OP mark this best answer.

no

Charting will not always align with personal taste. That’s a fact. But it does show which song is being loved by more people. I think songs get popular for a reason even if I may not like it. So I won’t mark off the significance of charting. It still means a lot

At the end of the day an opinion made by the masses will hold more value than one made by a random user on akp

Yes. The Spotify Top 50 has the best music in the world.

Everyone else should stop making bad music.

Not necessarily, so many good quality music get ignored bcoz people don't even bother to check it out so whoever is popular with public charts well

Some songs blew up not because of the song itself but because of the mv, choreo, line, member or an iconic moment.

Charting doesn't mean a song is good, it means that it's popular.

for kpop its simple. if your fave is doing well on charts it means its a good music. if your fave is doing bad on charts that means gp is tasteless. but there are exceptions of course