Why foreign members re the least popular in aespa ?

Fancam views arent important, i dont get why kpop stans obsess over it so much.

It's fine if they're the least popular members. People are more attracted to the popular members for a reason(personality, charisma, stage presence, etc.)

Also i thought Karina and Ningning were the most popular ones?

Quote from izoniee

Ning Ning is really underrated in fandom and non fans don’t care her...

Giselle is pretty popular in fandom but winter&karina re the most talked members in Aespa esp karina(her hype is weird I prefer winter).

Idk, i see a lot of ppl, specifically non-fans, talk abt her. im not rlly active within the fandom.

Karina has the most charisma imo so yea she'll stand out and people will be drawn to her.

Okay? They're the most talked about members because more people like them more than the others and that's okay. As i said, they draw attention for a reason(visuals, stage presence, personality, etc.).

Wait until their fanbase gets bigger and their popularity grows, there will be an increase of ppl talking about giselle and ningning.

Quote from izoniee

Yes I wish equally popularity

there will always be the more popular member

They just need to show their charm or have a breakthrough moment like Sana and Cheng Xiao.

It seems like Giselle is the least popular member, unfortunately. Kpop stans only used her predebut photos for hit tweets but they don't actually care about her like MYs do.

Guess Giselle is the least popular member.

But I got a feeling she will shine in the next comeback.

I stan Giselle but she’s defo the least popular well was her popularity has been increasing dramatically! Especially on YouTube / Twitter videos, all comments are mostly about Giselle and Karina now!

I guess every comeback will just be a rotation, it’s only their debut so nothing to worry about at all :)at the end of it aespa slay as a group

Quote from izoniee

Ning Ning is really underrated in fandom and non fans don’t care her...

I'm a non-fan and she's my fav

It's not surprising though, with the exception of Mark from NCT companies usually never push the foreign members

Visuals.

Quote from evo-evolution

I stan Giselle but she’s defo the least popular well was her popularity has been increasing dramatically! Especially on YouTube / Twitter videos, all comments are mostly about Giselle and Karina now!

As they should be

Winter and Karina are basically neck and neck in Korea/East Asia with Winter having the edge cause her 2 solo stages that gave off her vocals Karina is 2nd for her visual Ningning is more popular than Giselle but both are nugus in Korea with Giselle slightly more favored. internationally Winter is number 1 and Karina and Ningning are 2nd with Karina only being unpopular in America cause dumb kpop Stans

winter world domination

Isn't it too early to be discussing who is the least popular member when they've barely debuted?

Given them time to establish themselves and their personalities and talents.

NingNing and Giselle didn't had the chance to show their full potential jet and I think their popularity will go up with the time

Quote from i9son

NingNing and Giselle didn't had the chance to show their full potential jet and I think their popularity will go up with the time

yes exactly I love winter but why hasn't our main vocal been able to sing some covers yet? I under stand winter is Korean and popular but still SM

What were you confused about when it came to my comment, OP?

Quote from izoniee

Cause sm promoted only korean members

you do realise that the chinese members are some of the most successful right? Victoria is absolutely killing it in China as well as Lay and Luhan

From what I've seen Giselle is the least talked about with Karina and Ningning as most popular 🤔 but Winters popular too. They just need a chance to shine, for me Ningning and Karina really stood out in the performances but they were all gorgeous 🥰

Quote from izoniee

In china if ningning is promoted like main vocalist

absolutely but she doesn't need to be promoted there she can just return when her contract is done

I men she's pretty she seems nice and she's young

As long as she can hold a tune and given SM's excellence in training vocalists I have no doubt that she will do great.

And besides they have only debuted so I see good things for all them unless SM does some stupid AI reality shit to screw them over.

Quote from izoniee

Finally thing

This is first time I’m agree with you

well its no fun if we agree all the time right then what would say to each other? lol

The point is for people with different opinions and perspectives to discuss things share a different point of view - challenge our believes so that we may be better.

And besides I enjoy our discussions izoniee - you seem to stan izone and I like Izone as well - we may just see the same thing from two different lens :P

at least ningning is popular in international

when they posted a picture in their official fanpage winter got the most rts and ningning is the 2nd so i think ningning’s popularity is not bad as you think but giselle i agree with you

Not sure. I like NNing's aura the most. I'm just waiting to see how it picks up in future MVs.

non visuals bruh...

Quote from lovable-15

Fancam views arent important, i dont get why kpop stans obsess over it so much.

It's fine if they're the least popular members. People are more attracted to the popular members for a reason(personality, charisma, stage presence, etc.)

Also i thought Karina and Ningning were the most popular ones?

Yeah, people said Jihyo is the least popular member of Twice but she has a Fancy fancam with the most views than all of Twice members' fancams...so it wouldn't really make sense.

I would say Giselle, but aespa is so fresh their indivudal popularity is inconsistent since everyone is still getting to know them

I think ningning is a bit more popular than winter internationally now esp with nonfans. But overall it’s Karina and winter. Even in China judging by bar members is Karina/winter/ningning/Giselle which is surprising I thought nn will be the most followed.

We still need more music and activities

Imo Giselle will always be the least popular. Ningning has a chance to be a lot more popular

Mainly because SM is pushing Karina as the center and Winter got some promotions

Giselle. I hope she will be pushed on their comeback.

WE NEED RAPSELLE

Quote from acepa

Giselle. I hope she will be used on their comeback.

WE NEED RAPSELLE

Rapselle

OMG I'm stealing that

Cause Koreans are xenophobic against non Korean idols.