is it safe to say that Blackpink's Jump is in overall the most succesful song (both locally and globally) by a girl group (or non fictional group ) released this year?

I mean yeah. Everyone knows this. They’re the only group to conquer global and Korea 9 years into their career.

Not at all. Didn't even hit #1 in Korea and its Billboard success was just so-so. It's about to fall off the chart entirely while Twice is still rising and Golden is making history.

I expected better.

hımm, jump don't give me the hit vibe of the year so far but yeah it is safe to say.

Ended by Golden

Yes

But it is as empty as calling IU as the most successful non-group female singer from Korea

Quote from Yama-Chan

Not at all. Didn't even hit #1 in Korea and its Billboard success was just so-so. It's about to fall off the chart entirely while Twice is still rising and Golden is making history.

I expected better.

Nice try. But as mentioned takedown will not outstream JUMP no matter how many weeks it spends on billboard lol.

JUMP will end the year as the most streamed kpop GG song. and you know it as well that’s why you’re denying it so hard.

Also you need to stop over estimating takedown. It’s not golden no one thinks it’s one of the biggest kpop songs. 😭

Quote from ISaidISaid

Nice try. But as mentioned takedown will not outstream JUMP no matter how many weeks it spends on billboard lol.

JUMP will end the year as the most streamed kpop GG song. and you know it as well that’s why you’re denying it so hard.

Also you need to stop over estimating takedown. It’s not golden no one thinks it’s one of the biggest kpop songs. 😭

Jump is going to be an afterthought once we leave 2025 and move into 2026, 2027 and so on

Takedown is absolutely going to remembered far, far longer and has a MUCH bigger impact.

Cry about the KPDH buff all you want, but being associated with what has become a culture phenom in the U.S. is pretty much impossible to overcome.

Jump will fall off the charts soon. Takedown and even Strategy continue to rise, and both will stick on the Hot 100 longer than any BP song ever, even the one that was hard carried by Selena Gomez.

Lmao.

Quote from Yama-Chan

Jump is going to be an afterthought once we leave 2025 and move into 2026, 2027 and so on

Takedown is absolutely going to remembered far, far longer and has a MUCH bigger impact.

Cry about the KPDH buff all you want, but being associated with what has become a culture phenom in the U.S. is pretty much impossible to overcome.

Jump will fall off the charts soon. Takedown and even Strategy continue to rise, and both will stick on the Hot 100 longer than any BP song ever, even the one that was hard carried by Selena Gomez.

Lmao.

Display More

Takedown Twice Ver is an afterthought as well.

You keep talking about takedown like as if it’s golden it got some buff because of KPDH but it’s no more memorable than JUMP.

So save it Yama.

Quote from Slayurfaves

didn't you read the title? I said girl group or non-functional group.

obviously kpop demon hunter is hot right now but it's an animnated musical film it's kind of t a different criteria imo and I want to focus on regular kpop groups.

this is kind of an appreciation thread besides blackpink is really doing well and I was not expecting it

Display More

People are jealous a group can be this relevant after so many years. Imagine being relevant both in Korea and internationally in their 9th year. ZERO GGs can relate to this.

Do I like JUMP? Not particularly no.

Is Blackpink without a doubt the most influential and successful kpopGG ever? Also yes.

Quote from ISaidISaid

Takedown Twice Ver is an afterthought as well.

You keep talking about takedown like as if it’s golden it got some buff because of KPDH but it’s no more memorable than JUMP.

So save it Yama.

Yeah, that's cap. I'm not even using a memoji on that one. Takedown is magnitudes more impactful and memorable than Jump. Imagine thinking that a song that plays during the ending credits of THE biggest movie and soundtrack in the country today, with the Twice members themselves on-screen performing said song, won't be more memorable than a BP song about to fall off the BBH100. Come on, fam.

Quote from Yama-Chan

Yeah, that's cap. I'm not even using a memoji on that one. Takedown is magnitudes more impactful and memorable than Jump. Imagine thinking that a song that plays during the ending credits of THE biggest movie and soundtrack in the country today, with the Twice members themselves on-screen performing said song, won't be more memorable than a BP song about to fall off the BBH100. Come on, fam.

Takedown twice verison is a complete after thought whether you like it or not. It’s not even the one trending. It literally has nothing going for it other than being included in the main sound track. It’s not even played in the main movie ffs 😭

And you know this too. You’re just being a delulu because you hate BP lol.

Quote from ISaidISaid

Takedown twice verison is a complete after thought whether you like it or not. It’s not even the one trending. It literally has nothing going for it other than being included in the main sound track. It’s not even played in the main movie ffs 😭

And you know this too. You’re just being a delulu because you hate BP lol.

BP doesn't stand a chance. You are really, really, really underestimating the force multiplier effect of Twice being involved in KPDH.

The kids here LOVED KPDH. Did you not see the viral clips of them signing along to every single song this past weekend? That includes Takedown.

Give it up. This is Twice's year.

Quote from Yama-Chan

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

BP doesn't stand a chance. You are really, really, really underestimating the force multiplier effect of Twice being involved in KPDH.

The kids here LOVED KPDH. Did you not see the viral clips of them signing along to every single song this past weekend? That includes Takedown.

Give it up. This is Twice's year.

Display More

See the way it’s an after thought 😭

Quote from Slayurfaves

I didn't want to reply but you have to be serious. Selena was losing popularity she wasn't as hot you know very well the song was carried by blinks. Selena Gomez fanbases were coming to blackpink fanbases for streaming. D

don't waste your time I won't reply but the desperation is real that you have to use twice to downplay blackpink and you get annoyed when people discredit nj

well bp still did better than nj in hot 100

External Content x.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content x.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Display More

You're the one desperate for BLACKPINK validation, to the point you're trying to downgrade an artist who was far more popular than BLACKPINK in the U.S. Like, are you kidding me? Lmao.

There is a reason that it's still the longest charting BP song on the Billboard Hot 100. All the others didn't have Selena Gomez. One did.

Just like it's silly to ignore the KPDH buff for Twice, but the fact remains their song completely overshadows Jump in the biggest music industry in the world, and they're a part of a literally historically successful Netflix movie now, that was just the #1 movie in the box office the past weekend.

Yeah, BLACKPINK didn't flop, but Jump wasn't some world beater song. It simply did OKAY in the U.S., and it also has just done ALL RIGHT in Korea. Not like it was a D4 level hit there.

I call it how I see it. You should've just made this a straightforward praise thread, if you didn't want people questioning the question YOU posed.

Quote from ISaidISaid

See the way it’s an after thought 😭

If there is another KPDH sing along weekend, go to it. Watch how many kids sing along to Twice's version of Takedown.

It's quite safe to say, you'd have to be a generational BP hater to think other wise.

Quote from Yama-Chan

If there is another KPDH sing along weekend, go to it. Watch how many kids sing along to Twice's version of Takedown.

Ofc they know the lyrics 😭😭😭😭

Because it’s also in the main version 😭😭😭

But people don’t seek this verison and people don’t care about it. It’s an after thought.

Anyway it’s successful but you pretending like as if it’s vastly more successful than every kpop songs and deserves the same reverence as golden is insane and delulu.

Quote from ISaidISaid

Ofc they know the lyrics 😭😭😭😭

Because it’s also in the main version 😭😭😭

But people don’t seek this verison and people don’t care about it. It’s an after thought.

Anyway it’s successful but you pretending like as if it’s vastly more successful than every kpop songs and deserves the same reverence as golden is insane and delulu.

Display More

sis come on. Please try harder. 7 weeks on the Billboard Hot 100 is already better than any BP song not carried by Selena Gomez.

Obviously it is safe to say so, since the success of Jump is undeniable. Many posts showed it made great waves locally and internationally.

Who will even refute that?

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

Obviously it is safe to say so, since the success of Jump is undeniable. Many posts showed it made great waves locally and internationally.

Who will even refute that?

Me.

They've released better music and have had songs that charted much better.

But since Blinks keep provoking me, I guess I need to make a thread about something once I've had my dinner.

At last Jump is a BlackPink song, not just some sub unit cover. Maybe you should try comparing Strategy to Jump no at least?

Anyway, yes Takedown may be more relevant culturally than Jump (in anglo saxon countries/ mostly usa) but it is primarly known as an Huntrix song not as a Twice song. And the version that is trending is the Huntrix version. People even confuse the ending credits face reveal as if it was the real Huntrix singers. Crazy as it is, Twice is still making no noise, no name despite INSANE amount of exposure.

Proof is, their original 2025 released songs floped massively. Can you imagine +10 songs flopping like that?! That kinda underperformance is career ending typa sh*t.

How is Twice bigger than BP? Takedown may be in some context, but that doesn't mean Twice > BP in 25. That just means Takedown > Jump in the USA.

On the other hand, Jump is an original BLACKPINK song riding fully on BP's name and hype with ZERO promo, not even the most basic stuff. And doing better on the charts than their biggest hits. And doing better globally than Takedown. BP also proved to be an unparalleled force in ticket selling this year, filling up statiums around the world and in western countries.

So in the end Blackpink as a group is still more impactful and relevent than Twice even in 2025. Even with just 1 new song. Now wait their ep drop!

Quote from Yama-Chan

They've released better music and have had songs that charted much better.

Unfortunately the question wasn't "is Jump BPs most successful song", the question is whether or not it is the most successful girl group song of the year, not counting Golden, and it obviously is.

And if your only argument against that is a Twice subunit cover of an extremely popular song from an extremely popular movie, then you have no argument.

Quote from Tru-Multistan

Unfortunately the question wasn't "is Jump BPs most successful song", the question is whether or not it is the most successful girl group song of the year, not counting Golden, and it obviously is.

And if your only argument against that is a Twice subunit cover of an extremely popular song from an extremely popular movie, then you have no argument.

And BLACKPINK'S most successful song in the west needed Selena Gomez to make it happen. That didn't stop Blinks from using Ice Cream against me in arguments back in 2023.

I'm not here to debate what songs "count" or not; I'm just looking at the overall success and impact of the songs.

Fact of the matter is that Jump is plummeting in the biggest music market on Planet Earth, while both Takedown and Strategy are soaring upwards, riding the incredible momentum of KPDH.

As I've said time and time again, let it have been BLACKPINK featured on KPDH, and Blinks wouldn't suddenly be coming up with arbitrary reasons to discredit the song's accomplishments.

I will never care about how a song charts in some tiny ass music market compared to charting in the U.S., Korea and Japan. Not for K-Pop at least. And no matter how much people argue with me, the rest of the K-Pop world feels the same, because especially for first two of the three get 99.9% of the headlines and attention for achievement posting.

Read em and weep.

Quote from Yama-Chan

And BLACKPINK'S most successful song in the west needed Selena Gomez to make it happen. That didn't stop Blinks from using Ice Cream against me in arguments back in 2023.

I'm not here to debate what songs "count" or not; I'm just looking at the overall success and impact of the songs.

Fact of the matter is that Jump is plummeting in the biggest music market on Planet Earth, while both Takedown and Strategy are soaring upwards, riding the incredible momentum of KPDH.

As I've said time and time again, let it have been BLACKPINK featured on KPDH, and Blinks wouldn't suddenly be coming up with arbitrary reasons to discredit the song's accomplishments.

I will never care about how a song charts in some tiny ass music market compared to charting in the U.S., Korea and Japan. Not for K-Pop at least. And no matter how much people argue with me, the rest of the K-Pop world feels the same, because especially for first two of the three get 99.9% of the headlines and attention for achievement posting.

Read em and weep.

Display More

If this visual does not help you understand the difference between these 2 songs, than nothing will.

Screenshot 2025-08-27 at 6.16.25 PM.png

Had to zoom out quite a bit to get this:

Screenshot 2025-08-27 at 6.18.17 PM.png

Normally I let you do your thing but like it's just crazy to claim that Twice's Takedown is bigger than Jump. More longevity on a few charts? maybe.

Quote from Tru-Multistan

If this visual does not help you understand the difference between these 2 songs, than nothing will.

Screenshot 2025-08-27 at 6.16.25 PM.png

Had to zoom out quite a bit to get this:

Screenshot 2025-08-27 at 6.18.17 PM.png

Normally I let you do your thing but like it's just crazy to claim that Twice's Takedown is bigger than Jump. More longevity on a few charts? maybe.

Display More

Not the Slovakia Top 100

Quote from Yama-Chan

Not the Slovakia Top 100

and Ecuador Anglo Airplay, your faves could never

YES IT IS SAFE TO SAY

Quote from Tru-Multistan

and Ecuador Anglo Airplay, your faves could never

NGL I actually laughed out loud going through that list, but I don't want to be too disrespectful.

Not even onces will try to deny lol

Not the old man using twice to shade BP. omg shut up and focus on your disbanded group.

Where's the poll, so I can say No?

Quote from Slayurfaves

I didn't want to reply but you have to be serious. Selena was losing popularity then she wasn't as hot as previous years you know very well the song was carried by blinks.

If you say so.

Quote from Slayurfaves

is twice doing better locally than blackpink though? because my question is about doing better overall both domestically and internationally as a whole this year? Twice might be doing better in the US for what I'm gathering ( but bp doing very good globally) tbh I didn't know about twice' takedown until I made this thread ( I know it's my fault for not being super updated) I am now lol

all I know is that there is a huge hype about kpop Demin Hunters and that their song is an ost of a very popular animated flim, meanwhile blackpink is just a random pre-release. If it was the other way around and Blackpink released a soundtrack for a popular film people would be saying it's thanks to that. I'm actually glad another 3rd gg is doing well but it's crazy how you don't see how well Jump is doing. Objectively speaking they are.

It doesn't matter which group is doing better, because neither has the most succesful song overall.

Why is this a Takedown vs Jump battle? Are y'all suffering from amnesia?

I havent followed K Charts for a year now but isnt this the only Kpop group song in 2025 that charted multiple weeks at #1 on Gaon/Melon and earned PAKs? To me, this ended both Takedown and Jump tbh.

Quote from killthisfenty

Not the old man using twice to shade BP. omg shut up and focus on your disbanded group.

Not the washed up forever bitter girl group stan, who's probably older than me, throwing a temper tantrum because the one song BLACKPINK released in 3 years underwhelmed and underachieved.

You'd better hope NewJeans actually disband, because your favorite group will be treated like an afterthought again if NewJeans returns to the stage.