Why some users ignore idle flopping

We love idle even in their flop era

bc they were never a threat to ppl's favs

Nugu privilege

We've already accepted that we're in our flop era.

I think the major reason why nobody is saying much because Nevies rarely engage in stan wars. That resulted in not many fandoms making fun of the group not charting.

To be honest idle are in their how many year now 8 or 9? They came from a company outside big 4 and had been doing well consistently, better than most groups from big4

Also I think it would be better to wait until our favs reach their 8/9 year and compare then The reality is most groups fall off before their 5 year!

It’s hard to compare a group flopping after 8/9 years to a group flopping in their 2/3rd year!

They have massive Chinese fansites, yet their Chinese members have renewed to stay in the group, they are gonna be around forever.

Whom in particular did you want to speak on this?

Looking at Nevies on Twitter... They're the most normal people out there. They don't drag others, and rarely get into arguments with other fandoms.

There was another thread about it, right?

I mean, it's been acknowledged, but what else should be done about it?

Point and laugh?

They'll probably come back with some good music next time.

Maybe they are fans that don't care or normal people that have never cared about the group so ignore the posts about them.

Merge?

Thread

idle is not charting anywhere .. not even top 100 .. what is happening ?

this is really shocking considering they are among the gg with multiple hits last year, even have better digital performances compared to IVE.. and then suddenly dip into the bottom of chart rank, even worst than NMIXX .. what is really happening ? Good Thing is not even that bad

girlgroupstan21

May 25th 2025

Or

Thread

Am i the only one not hype by IDLE comeback ??

I've always loved everything G-idle release (yeah i act like nxude doesn't exist)
and it's always a group that always hyped me with their release

but i don't know this whole "rebranding" is throwing me off

with the whole "bury" teaser, them removing the G, completely erasing Soojin by releasing back all their old song OT6

i don't know this whole comeback era is giving " TRY HARD" energy and not in a good way and it's really throwing me off and make me not expect the comeback as much than their…

SooYoung

May 7th 2025

I liked their recent comeback and that's good enough for me

obviously would I have liked that they charted higher - yes but sometimes the song just doesn't capture the GP's attention

Quote from BIGnorBANG

Looking at Nevies on Twitter... They're the most normal people out there. Thy don't drag others, and rarely get into arguments with other fandoms.

girl..

I dont think anyone believe idle is a threat to anybody!!!

everyone will flop eventually, thats normal.

So it is what it is o guess 🤷

Because they don't have crazy haters to begin with.

I don't feel like it's needed to express joy over a group's misfortune. It's really rare that anyone deserves it. So this is not a good or happy topic for me even if I dislike the idol group flopping. And it may be not the end, just a bad comeback.

Quote from butterbutterfly

bc they were never a threat to ppl's favs

/ end thread