Me to your attempts at shading
I don't attempt, I just say the truth
Me to your attempts at shading
I don't attempt, I just say the truth
Alright then, what's your analysis of the two best vocalists of both groups?
Of course Gidle has better vocals
Miyeon has bigger range and better resonance
Miyeon has bright forward voice with twang
Rosé’s placement is more chesty and heavy compared to Miyeon but Rosé is also a nasal singer(it is a technique it doesn’t mean a bad thing)
But Rosé has Cursive voice which is not a good thing and it irritates many people’s ears but I think she will never stop singing like from what I have listened from her recent album and performances.
For kpop idols
Rose is below average singer and I wouldn’t put her in top 15 best YG vocalists(before blinks come at me YG had a lot of amazing vocalists from previous gens like Gummy, Big mama, Akmu and others)
Miyeon is average for kpop idols
Feb, that's Hearts2Hearts debut month
im kidding
I don't attempt, I just say the truth
I could never
Display MoreOf course Gidle has better vocals
Miyeon has bigger range and better resonance
Miyeon has bright forward voice with twang
Rosé’s placement is more chesty and heavy compared to Miyeon but Rosé is also a nasal singer(it is a technique it doesn’t mean a bad thing)
But Rosé has Cursive voice which is not a good thing and it irritates many people’s ears but I think she will never stop singing like from what I have listened from her recent album and performances.
For kpop idols
Rose is below average singer and I wouldn’t put her in top 15 best YG vocalists(before blinks come at me YG had a lot of amazing vocalists from previous gens like Gummy, Big mama, Akmu and others)
Miyeon is average for kpop idols
Respect.
I agree, that's a more fair comparison.
To be fair, Miyeon and Jisoo are very similar, they look similar, they sound similar, I still think that's one of the main reason Miyeon left YG!
The biggest difference between Miyeon and Jisoo is the companies. Or more like their producers. YG don't give a damn about vocal lessons, BP is the prime example, neither of them are better vocalists now than they were 9 years ago.
But Soyeon actually did a good job with Miyeon, and now she's average. She's not the best technique wise, but her tone and performance can cover up her flaws.
With proper training, Jisoo could do the same, that's why I always said, she had the biggest potential in Blackpink. She has the best vocal tone, not a typical Kpop voice, but it's obvious that singing is just a hobby for her.
Actually all of them are on the same level, but technique wise, Minnie is better. If I really want to make a ranking, this would be the most accurate, probably.
Minnie
Miyeon
Yuqi - Soojin
Neither of them are worse than below-average, Gidle is far from a vocal group, but they are well-balanced for sure.
people must be really bored if they are being baited by troll topics from the 2010s
then ig you're bored.
I'm thinking about it, actually.
But by this response, I'm guessing you think Miyeon is the better vocalist.
Honestly, I only made this cuz I've always thought of Minnie as the strongest vocalist of GIDLE but ig not
Sakura!! She can sing without moving her mouth!! The best vocalist ever!
And she makes it look easy
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!