So, looks like Babymonster is the group with the best vocals of 4 and 5 GEN.

Quote from Coldhit

1. Unknown group

2. Unknown group

3. Nmixx

4. Aespa

5. Baemon

The unknown groups got it worst as nobody really talks about them but they are out there. Idek them.

Display More

1.NewJEans

2. IVE

Yes i crack the code youre welcome

Quote from Sergeantx

That would be good but yeah not many kpop stans who are mostly tone deaf and able to hearing good supported notes. Need trained ears

I followed OH vocal threads thread too (now its gone sadly) and one of the member made youtube channel about kpop 4th gen gg vocals. There is still ongoing vocal discussion of it on its community post.

https://www.youtube.com/post/U…Rt8ULZhN0IJ6ACo7vjp5HyfOA

Basically Nmixx >> Aespa >>>> Baemon

Display More

Didn't even know they were still active.

Based on this, NMIXX are in a class of their own with two above average vocalists.

Which doesn't surprise me. I knew they were legit after I saw them cover one of Mamamoo's more vocally demanding songs, Decalcomanie

Quote from versatile

That crew was a bunch of tryhards.

Not like you could do any better

Quote from versatile

If I wanted to I could, very flawed in their obsession with thick loud voices like Ailee and kyuhyun.

No, you couldn't. You can't tell the difference between a head voice and a chest voice. Let alone different notes. I've never seen you show the capacity to give meaningful vocal analysis.

Prove me wrong.

Quote from versatile

I said if I wanted, if I was making blogs with millions of pages I'd at least know what I was talking about.

Their rankings were pretty shocking. To them loud thick voice = great vocalist. Despite people naturally having different tones and voices.

People shouldn't take amateurs with blogs seriously. Maybe an SM vocal coach or something.

I mean, the stage is yours. Talk and no action is nothing but empty calories, my friend.

"I could if I wanted to but I won't" is like the most common catchphrase of people who hope they can fake it till they make it.

"loud thick voice = great vocalist" is not a promising beginning to your vocal analysis career

You're free to create your own tiers and post it for critique.

NMIXX has proven they all have great live vocals while dancing (through their Performance Practices) and great harmonization through their a cappella album melodies, unless other GGs can show this level, NMIXX are the standard.

Maybe Nmixx can be analysed, but there is hardly anything available for Aespa and BM.

Mamamoo > then all of them, and I recall they were rated as average or slightly above average. So all in all, its mostly stans talking up their group.

I'm sorry, but until we hear Babymonster sing live, this isn't even worth talking about. Aespa, NMIXX, not to mention Kiss of Life, is much better. These girls have a lot to prove. We can't say things like this after 2 MV.

Quote from purnhub

Where is the lie! Been following kpop since 2009 and I think they are the most talented group in all generations, Spica is close.

Nice troll comment.🤣

Quote from kirishiki

I don't know but I think their vocal line become better after Ahyeon join to the group

She is great vocalist

Ahyeon is a great vocalist, BUT one person can't make a whole team better. They sound great, especially in the new MV, but the studio version is always better. With most groups, at least.

Quote from YamaChwan

AKP needs the vocal analysis crew that OH used to have. Basically the digital thread equivalent but with vocals.

I'm not technically trained enough to truly assess who has more skill as a vocalist outside of what just sounds better to me.

You can find a LOT of review from vocal coaches and singers on Youtube, but most of them are too nice because they want more views. I have the vocalist background, but I don't think people would like to see me criticizing Kpop singers.😅

Also, this website is excellent, but they're not active anymore:

K-pop Vocalists' Vocal Analyses | A compilation of vocal analyses in K-pop (kpopvocalanalysis.net)

Quote from purnhub

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

In the first video, they're obviously lip-syncing. The second is much better, but doesn't feel like a real live singing, you can't even hear their breath, it's too clean.

Just no.

NMIXX and Aespa are already better and we haven’t heard Babymonster actually sing live yet.

Quote from Sergeantx

I followed OH vocal threads thread too (now its gone sadly)

i think some of that thread pages were save on the internetarchive, and the regular posters are still active in OH's discord

Good vocalist or not, as long as papa Teddy keep making their songs like BP, there's really no chance to show off vocals. Look at Jennie on Hyori's Red Carpet. Her tone matches so well with Miss Korea, but we didn't get to see that often in the 7 years of BP.

All they sang were dudududu, yayayaya, tatatata. Pray Baemons doesn't get those songs, and we can actually hear some vocals.