Red Velvet & BlackPink Rumoured To Be Disbanding Yet Twice Is Still Standing Amongst The Fall Of 3rd Gen

Well twice flopping since 2020 so their disbanding or being active doesn't really matter cos nobody gonna be seeing them on charts anyways

Each BP member probably makes as much money as those groups do as a whole.

You’re comparing apples to oranges.

BP literally was saying they have planned things for their 8th anniversary? like kpopers, read the room and stop fantasying about shit that won't happen.

Quote from chilean-stan1

BP literally was saying they have planned things for their 8th anniversary? like kpopers, read the room and stop fantasying about shit that won't happen.

What if bp actually ends up disbanding what u gon do then?

Quote from Beesknees

Each BP member probably makes as much money as those groups do as a whole.

You’re comparing apples to oranges.

Bffr. I dislike talking about how much money Kpop groups make because that's none of my business but you have to be very delulu to believe BP individually are making more money than TWICE as a whole.

Quote from thebadguy

Well twice flopping since 2020 so their disbanding or being active doesn't really matter cos nobody gonna be seeing them on charts anyways

Twice only disbanded in the Korean charts.

Quote from BEG4DAWIN

Twice only disbanded in the Korean charts.

Also in relevance in kpop industry

You stay in a company for one of 2 reasons:

1. Your company treats you really well

2. Nobody wants you

Onces keep nagging about JYP mistreatment , so must be number 2. Nobody wants a high maintenance group that keep floping every time they release a song

Quote from thebadguy

Also in relevance in kpop industry

I wish my faves were as irrelevant as twice.

Quote from BEG4DAWIN

I wish my faves were as irrelevant as twice.

Does anyone actually cares about these seat numbers ? Why are y'all so boring

Quote from thebadguy

Does anyone actually cares about these seat numbers ? Why are y'all so boring

The producers of the shows care, they make more money.

Quote from chilean-stan1

BP literally was saying they have planned things for their 8th anniversary? like kpopers, read the room and stop fantasying about shit that won't happen.

people so eager for them to disband too bad it won't happen literally the girls are hinting for having more concerts in the future they probably aren't allowed to speak about it but they still have been giving hints they will continue when blinks send them messages on weverse and stuff

Quote from vzal

Bffr. I dislike talking about how much money Kpop groups make because that's none of my business but you have to be very delulu to believe BP individually are making more money than TWICE as a whole.

edit: nvm I thought you were talking about twice making more money than bp as whole lol

Quote from BEG4DAWIN

The producers of the shows care, they make more money.

I never claimed twice to be bankrupt poors

Quote from thebadguy

What if bp actually ends up disbanding what u gon do then?

Would be crazy to see... There are so much Blinks, if YGE really tries to pull that 2NE1 move, disband BP and then Debut Baemon... OMG, there will be so much hate. And don't forget, the maknae is literally 14

Quote from vzal

Bffr. I dislike talking about how much money Kpop groups make because that's none of my business but you have to be very delulu to believe BP individually are making more money than TWICE as a whole.

No you don’t.

The difference in brand value is huge

Quote from Catgirl

Would be crazy to see... There are so much Blinks, if YGE really tries to pull that 2NE1 move, disband BP and then Debut Baemon... OMG, there will be so much hate. And don't forget, the maknae is literally 14

it would be better for babymonster's future if bp disbands cos if bp renews then baemon will remain as number 2 priority of yg and will be getting only bare minimum, if bp is gone yg will put all its attention into making baemon a success

Quote from thebadguy

it would be better for babymonster's future if bp disbands cos if bp renews then baemon will remain as number 2 priority of yg and will be getting only bare minimum, if bp is gone yg will put all its attention into making baemon a success

They definitely won't be having a successful debut tho, their song probably won't chart well... Blinks will be boycotting them if YGE really pulls that move. However, the hate probably will be over after a few months or a year

Once again, the RV rumor has no legs as of now.

Quote from Daisy_Queen

Are people supposed to comment saying they're mad twice is still here or...?

I don’t know if you were supposed to, but that’s exactly what everyone is doing. This thread brought out all the salt, in the form of haters’ uncontrollable tears.

Quote from thebadguy

Also in relevance in kpop industry

I'm really curious. Do you truly believe if a group that does well on the Korean charts but can't do tours in stadiums and sell a million album is better off than Twice? Do you really think there is currently another girl group other than BP that generate more income than Twice?

Quote from supa

I'm really curious. Do you truly believe if a group that does well on the Korean charts but can't do tours in stadiums and sell a million album is better off than Twice? Do you really think there is currently another girl group other than BP that generate more income than Twice?

twice is not even in top 5 gg when it comes it comes to relevance in kpop scene. Sure they make a lot of money but so does elon musk and he's not relevant in kpop industry either.

Quote from Catgirl

They definitely won't be having a successful debut tho, their song probably won't chart well... Blinks will be boycotting them if YGE really pulls that move. However, the hate probably will be over after a few months or a year

Blackjacks vs BlackPink all over again.

Now Blinks vs babymelon.

Quote from thebadguy

twice is not even in top 5 gg when it comes it comes to relevance in kpop scene. Sure they make a lot of money but so does elon musk and he's not relevant in kpop industry either.

Good thing "relevance" don't pay shit. TWICE is in show BUSINESS.

Quote from barnaby

Good thing "relevance" don't pay shit. TWICE is in show BUSINESS.

JYP happy for all them $$$ going to his bank account

Gidle Stan speaking when their flops can't even sell out literal bingo halls and got dropped by Republic after less than a year while Twice just sold more tickets in 1 hour than they have in 5 years lol.

Quote from thebadguy

JYP happy for all them $$$ going to his bank account

I know you choose obtuse as your language. But, the split is in TWICE favor now. So, of course JYPE is raking in money. TWICE is earning more.

Quote from BEG4DAWIN

I wish my faves were as irrelevant as twice.

Use touring data at least.. Not the biased account.

Quote from vzal

Bffr. I dislike talking about how much money Kpop groups make because that's none of my business but you have to be very delulu to believe BP individually are making more money than TWICE as a whole.

If we're talking about profits that actually went into their bank accounts, I think lisa has more than all twice members combined.

Edit: my reasoning: tour income bp double twice concerts, bp has less members to divide. Plus their brand deals individually

Wdyt about their relevance? Who do you think bigger, lisa or other bp members individually vs twice? Just curious

Lisa is dating a Billionaire, do we include that into the maths?

Quote from TheBotter

Gidle Stan speaking when their flops can't even sell out literal bingo halls and got dropped by Republic after less than a year while Twice just sold more tickets in 1 hour than they have in 5 years lol.

I am pretty sure we had this argument before, G-idle is doing shows in the same North American venues as Aespa and Red Velvet. So not Bingo halls anymore.

My faves on the other hand, they can't even sellout Bingo Halls.

Quote from justscrolling

Use touring data at least.. Not the biased account.

If we're talking about profits that actually went into their bank accounts, I think lisa has more than all twice members combined.

Edit: my reasoning: tour income bp double twice concerts, bp has less members to divide. Plus their brand deals individually

Wdyt about their relevance? Who do you think bigger, lisa or other bp members individually vs twice? Just curious

Display More

Twice also has other revenue besides touring. Comebacks and fanmeeting for example. "Lisa has more than all 9 of them combined" Really? Including their respective solo, subunit and all 9 members' endorsement deals altogether this year? Let alone the past 8 years, I very much disagree

Twice is getting outcharted by even the mid tier groups like stayc etc

Quote from Armedryu

Twice also has other revenue besides touring. Comebacks and fanmeeting for example. "Lisa has more than all 9 of them combined" Really? Including their respective solo, subunit and all 9 members' endorsement deals altogether this year? Let alone the past 8 years, I very much disagree

Bp brand deals level are different tho

I'm talking about present times, since I don't keep up with their activities, but nowadays some compared their tours. Tbf I would say Taylor era tour out revenue the whole bp since debut too.

Quote from thebadguy

twice is not even in top 5 gg when it comes it comes to relevance in kpop scene. Sure they make a lot of money but so does elon musk and he's not relevant in kpop industry either.

Out of all the dumb things you’ve said, this is definitely one of them. No question.

RV might disband next year(doubt it tbh) but BP ain't going anywhere for the next 7 years lol

Quote from thebadguy

Twice is getting outcharted by even the mid tier groups like stayc etc

Honest question, if you have a choice to be in a group like Twice or be in a group like Stayc, which one would you choose?

Kpop fans always expose how pathetic they are during contract renewals. Some folks really want to see groups completely cease to exist because of whatever beef with their fans

Quote from supa

Honest question, if you have a choice to be in a group like Twice or be in a group like Stayc, which one would you choose?

Neither, can't deal with all super cringe fanservice, aegyo stuff and stupid kpop stans