Do you prefer self-produced groups?

Not if their music is awful for e.g Gidle haha. 💀

The music should be good first. If the music is good perhaps being self produced will make me love that aspect of them.

I don’t really know who produces what when I just listen to songs that I like on shuffle.

Doesn't matter as long as the song is good. What good is a self produced song if it's mid.

A song being self-produced means nothing if I don't vibe with it

On the other hand,if I do like the song,the self-produced factor probably would contribute to the enjoyment cuz it would feel more ''authentic'',I guess.

nope doesn't matter
that is one of the least of my requirement to be idol
or to stan a the artist/group

yes but prefer a mix so it allows more variety of styles

Also I think new jeans contribute to their music. Most of their songs are created with a member’s contribution.

tumblr_no3loeMauQ1ut6yv4o1_500.png

It doesn’t really matter to me I don’t even look at producers or writers for songs 😭

but I think if they r writing or producing it makes the message of song more personal

I don't have preferences. As long as I enjoy their music and the group itself, It's all that matters. Like Tic said, self-producing music I like would be just one more aspect I love about them.

But I think It's cool every idol that has the opportunity and is interested in contributing to their music. It doesn't need to be to the same extent as IDLE. But just to be there in the credits is a step in a restrictive industry like that, knowing they don't have any obbligation in being skilled at this as idols.

I'm in the same boat, really. I'm more interested in the content rather than the container, if that's make any sense. I mean, in the end, I do appreciate the fact that Soyeon or Wonho are extremely talented and fully involved in the process but I'm solely attracted by the streaming outcome :)

I tend to gravitate more toward self-produced groups but it's not one of my requirements as long as I love the music.

Isn't that kind of the same question if you ask? Do you care if your walls and roof are built by the same group? Does it matter as long you have well built house? We live in society where everyone is specialized to something and do what we are cabable to do the best. It is bonus if you can build whole house from floor to roof, but it is enough if are only good electrician. Specializing in one thing can bring you exponentially more money than being average at everything.

i just want good songs. i don't really care who writes it

It's not a requirement at all and it doesn't mean the music is better but I find it very impressive and it immediately makes me interested in the group. Self composed and written songs often feel more personal and authentic for me especially the ones from Minnie or Chaein (Purple Kiss)

it depends if it's just a fun song it doesn't matter but if they try to convey some kind of meaningful message with it that they believe in being involved in the making of the song helps me belieive that it was their intension not just a corporate marketing tactic

I find it cooler & a bigger reason why to stan.

I actually stan 2 self-producing groups : Stray Kids & BTS who are amazing.

But they need to self produce good & have a diverse discography with different sounds & self-producing groups ig put more fore fans ig and i like it better when they self-produce

Idrc if the song ain’t good