I feel like Winter is wasted in aespa and would be better in NewJeans

maybe she lost confidence since the kpop stans love critized her stage presence

Quote from bluebird1984

I genuinely think that Winter is wasted in aespa. She just doesn’t suit the concept. It's too taugh and dark for her. She is basically drowning in this heavy loud overproduced rap tough sound and concept. So then we can wonder if she lacks stage presence. But i personally think she just doesn’t SUIT the concept. All the othet 3 girls do but she doesn’t.

Also i think i would have prefered Sullyoon as the 4th member instead of het. Because even tho Sullyoon has such a sweet vibe to her, visually she just looks like a living ae. And i personally think aespa needed a more 'classical' visual like Sullyoon. Karina is more like the Seulgi of the group. Sullyoon is more on Irenes level.

Anyway to staybon Winter tiopic, i just think she would suit a concept like New Jeans or f(x) much better. I can’t imagine how heavenly she could have sound on Ditto for example. She could have taken NJ ok the next level musically.

She has this ethetal feeling about her and in her voice. And she is cute and bright. I think she would have been perfect in NJ.

Se would have been the leader, main vocal and in charge of short hair. Lol.

WDYT?

Display More

I agree
I hate the concept /song of AESPA
but definitely
I like Winter visual
I think I prefer her in Red Velvet

aespa aren't allowed to collaborate with other groups outside SM or covering songs outside SM . So how do you sure that Winter will fits them better?

even with how SM limiting aespa members potential, winter still one of the most popular so it's nonsense talk if she doesn't suit the concept.

hmm... not sure if I agree.

I feel winter does kind of have this sort of... more soft/sweetness to her vibe, but that doesn't necessarily mean she doesn't fit. She's still comes off badass and I like the slightly sweet vibe she adds to concept.

Nope. She slay harder in savage era

nah nj concept is too young for her

She fits the concept just fine. The real problem is SM making her sing those awful high notes in certain songs like Savage.

She has one of the most beautiful voices in kpop, why make her sing like that?

Yea. I agree. She doesn't suit the concept. Karina, Giselle, and Ning Ning would make a great trio. At this point, Winter should leave. Not trying to be rude or anything. Kyujin (NMIXX) would make a much better member but I don't want another member of NMIXX to leave. My friend is right beside me saying Giselle to leave. DO NOT AGREE! I am OT4! I love winter and giselle but, they both sort of don't fit the concept.

But yes, I do think Winter suits the concept a little bit especially in Savage. If she was in NJ she would be great!

Quote from beomgyu-x-chaeng

Yea. I agree. She doesn't suit the concept. Karina, Giselle, and Ning Ning would make a great trio. At this point, Winter should leave. Not trying to be rude or anything. Kyujin (NMIXX) would make a much better member but I don't want another member of NMIXX to leave. My friend is right beside me saying Giselle to leave. DO NOT AGREE! I am OT4! I love winter and giselle but, they both sort of don't fit the concept.

She fits like a glove for me. As for the piercing high notes, I don't think even Winter likes them since she expressed how high the scream was in Dreams Come True. She pulls the high note in next level well so the problem isn't in her singing imo but in the type of parts she is given.

Quote from beomgyu-x-chaeng

Yea. I agree. She doesn't suit the concept. Karina, Giselle, and Ning Ning would make a great trio. At this point, Winter should leave. Not trying to be rude or anything. Kyujin (NMIXX) would make a much better member but I don't want another member of NMIXX to leave. My friend is right beside me saying Giselle to leave. DO NOT AGREE! I am OT4! I love winter and giselle but, they both sort of don't fit the concept.

But yes, I do think Winter suits the concept a little bit especially in Savage. If she was in NJ she would be great!

*Creates new acc to troll*

*Needs to look legit so must add a dp and a sig*

*No time for searching pictures before posting so just rob off someone’s badge*

She fits the concept very well.

No. Winter fits in perfectly and Karina is visual enough.

don't know about the nwjns thing

Quote from sanas-armpits

She fits the concept just fine. The real problem is SM making her sing those awful high notes in certain songs like Savage.

She has one of the most beautiful voices in kpop, why make her sing like that?

i liked winters high notes in savage ( if it isnt in her register that's one thing, but her high notes were pretty in the song)

i do perfer NingNing high notes over Winter tho so idk if that speaks any volume

i think Winter is too mature for Newjeans

i could see her in Lesserafim ( the way her hair is reminds me of Chaewon )

if anything i think SM is almost giving up on Giselle, yes my girlie made lots of mistakes, but what doesn't kill her will make her stronger and SM is failing to help her

and i think Giselle might be loosing confidence in herself and is so worried about messing up that she does and it dwells on her ( my personal theory) and i feel like Winter is giving her best but haters are getting to her slowly