Apparently NewJeans member Hyein is a 2008 liner? Min Hee Jin is nasty for this idgaf

Yeah I do agree that's pretty young. We'll just have to watch and see what concept they get and who they're targeted to. If it's obvious that they're targeted to teens and younger children I could accept it. But it is kinda uncomfortable at the same time.

debuting minors is weird af in every case but depending on what direction their music takes it could be weirder so far their mv was giving teen music

Quote from motichan

theres a part in the mv where a laptop falls and the focus is right on the lower parts of their bodies while they are dancing in shorts

People might think i'm a weirdo for this but idc it immediately made me uncomfortable bc i've been following them for a while and thought they all were 16-18

oh hybe

barely a teenager kpop life isn't easy when they are that young imo they should wait at least 2 years to debut them

is this the start of 5th generation?

Quote from motichan

People were PRAISING Min hee jin bc shes this genius and hybe paid her the most out of all companies since women are not paid that much compared to men. Fans were overjoyed since shes a woman and she will do better and bc of the lsf issue and that director of theirs being a weirdo(s&m photo). I was excited too but she does THIS??? Bruh

Have you see SHINee's sherlock concept photos that min hee Jin did?

She makes whoever was in charge of LSFRM concept a Saint lmao

Quote from motichan

People were PRAISING Min hee jin bc shes this genius and hybe paid her the most out of all companies since women are not paid that much compared to men. Fans were overjoyed since shes a woman and she will do better and bc of the lsf issue and that director of theirs being a weirdo(s&m photo). I was excited too but she does THIS??? Bruh

isn't min hee jin also responsible for the weird shinee teasers

Thread

The photoshoot that almost got Min Hee Jin canceled for good in Korea, a case of male gaze applied to boygroup

Since we are discussing over sexualization in kpop and male gaze, Id like to present a case of female gaze done by female director.



Edit: I am corrected by compelling arguments from other users that this is still male gaze.


This photoshoot was extremely controversial at the time and almost got her canceled for good.



While SHINee members were not minors, they were very young. So whats your opinion on this? Controversial or overreaction?



Shawols DO think SM was/is fucking out of their mind for…

Lulu_Key

Apr 9th 2022

Quote from Lulu_Key

Have you see SHINee's sherlock concept photos that min hee Jin did?

She makes whoever was in charge of LSFRM concept a Saint lmao

we posted same thing

Maybe you're not the target audience for this group? How old are you? I can't really follow any group whose members are born in 2000 lol it's like I'm that fellow kids meme but I listen to the music

Quote from motichan

What did she do? I googled and a couple of half naked photos showed up

But Taemin was 19-20 there so idk

Garam and Eunchae are 15-16 and were dancing in weird outfits and that humping the floor thing was too much

This girl is only 14 too

That concept is icky very icky

The whole vibe

And I'm saying that as a SHINee fan

Plus in the interview she admitted to lie to Taemin about the concept to catch him off guard. She thought that gives the photoshoot the vibes she wants.

wasn’t 2008 like six years ago

Quote from mygsbeat

wasn’t 2008 like six years ago

Kpop is weird knowing that my fav has a longer career than kids in it now

Sike time to peace out

Quote from Lulu_Key

Kpop is weird knowing that my fav has a longer career than kids in it now

Sike time to peace out

just the circle of life i guess

Quote from motichan

It has nothing to do with the target audience but debuting a 08 liner

If it doesn't make you uncomfortable after knowing the whole industry is not a good space for kids then Idk

Of course it has, half of K-pop songs are meant for teenagers. I'm someone on my 20s I wouldn't expect K-pop to cater to my demographic and debut someone around my age, it's like tuning on disney channel and complaning everyone is a kid.

How old are you?

So if they were supposed to debut last year then that means that she would’ve debuted at 13..

Quote from nct-exo

So if they were supposed to debut last year then that means that she would’ve debuted at 13..

Yeah thats just too young..this isnt an easy job, these kids have to give up so much and get to be under the public's eye 24/7 scrutinized for everything..not even gonna go to the sexualization...i hope they'll be fine.

Quote from nct-exo

So if they were supposed to debut last year then that means that she would’ve debuted at 13..

12 actually if she is 14 now

Isn’t baby monster gonna be the same concept? Very young girls

Quote from dummi

14 they better not go for the uncle fans

You know they'll be there no matter what

She’s known for that stuff tho Kek.

Quote from sheryllee3

Isn’t baby monster gonna be the same concept? Very young girls

It's a rumor

Quote from dummi

14 they better not go for the uncle fans

The mv has that cliche love interest story, they're probably evaporating just seeing the girls looking in that dude's direction.

Or at least I hope so.

wasn't this group supposed to debut last year or 2020? so they wanted to debut a 12 years old?

I can never take yall selective outrage seriously I'm sorry.

you people need to go out more. They're dressed like your average teenager in summer and yall are the ones sexualizing the heck out of something so normal.

Quote from bobsyouruncle

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Why does the youngest look the oldest out of them

I'm stanning them, this is so unique. I hope their songs and debut are good.