ULTIMATE DISCOGRAPHY RATING

It’s time for the Ultimate Discography Rating!

This rating is specifically designed to give every group the best possible shot of a good score while being thorough and fair. It’s up to the music to be good enough, now!

Here’s How It Works!

Part One is a score of the group’s TOP 10 SONGS

Part Two is a measure of whether their discography is VERSATILE

Part Three is a score of the SONG QUALITY while being VERSATILE

Part Four is a measure of SLAYABILITY

Part Five is a measure of the SKIPABILITY

At the end, all of this will be scored up like this:

Average Song Score: x/10.0

Versatile Song Score: x/10.0

Versatility: x%

Slaybility: x%

Skipability: x%

— Best of Luck to everyone! Scores CAN be recalculated using different songs or newly released ones. OSTs and different language songs are allowed. Unit songs are allowed, but solo songs cannot represent the group. Songs with a feature or collab are allowed. Remixes are allowed. NOT allowed: solo songs representing the group, a different artists song where the group features on it*, predebut songs

We’ll begin soon!

*the feature explanation, an example:

lady gaga featuring blackpink, not allowed

blackpink featuring cardi b, allowed

blackpink and selena gomez, allowed

hope that clears it up

I don’t know which artists I want to start with

Quote from dryheat

Do TXT and BTS

That sounds fun! BTS have a ton of songs but i’m sure i’ll be getting through some big discographies eventually, anyway. might as well do one early

Quote from YouChanDoThis

Sounds fun. If you're up for a lot of listening, why not try Stray Kids?

-JYP

OMG YOUR ACCOUNT LOL

a lot of people are divided over their discography and i haven’t heard much of it so i’m excited to try!

Quote from Jichu

dreamcatcher pls

or blackpink if you want it to be quicker

why not both?

Quote from dryheat

stellaview should the top 10 be the most popular in general or you just saying the most universally liked on AKP?

well since it’s a discography rating, i’ll be asking for the “best” songs in the fans opinions and the top 10 most agreed on will be used!

so some fans might want to sort of strategize on what songs to use in the top 10 and for the versatility rating! you can re-use songs, too! just whatever the fans think is the “BEST”

Quote from russianvelvet

Oooo how about Golden Child!!!

i don’t think i know any of their songs so sure, i’m intrigued!

Quote from YouChanDoThis

What can I say? Happy April Fool's Day!

I can't wait to see what you say as I tend to love most (key word: most) of their songs and the meanings behind them. The self-producing and talented part is nice as well. Have a great day/night!

thank you! you, too! and thanks for the laugh

Quote from Jichu

too lazy can I just say the top 10 I think are the best

I doubt a fandom unless small can reach a consensus

yeah i’ll need to figure out the smoothest way to get the fans choices from them

Quote from dryheat

Yasss BTS first!

this has like almost everything thats on spotify including jpn tracks and side projects

External Content open.spotify.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

NICE!! thank you! now i just have to figure out the smoothest way to get armys song choices from them. there’s so many, making the thread is going to take some thought

Quote from YouChanDoThis

Question: What kinds of songs can we suggest? Do we count Japanese songs/versions? What about remixes? Collabs? OSTs? Solo songs? I wouldn't want to suggest songs that don't count and get in trouble.

i’ll try to put it somewhere easy to read whenever i make the thread so that no one misses out but any song by them is acceptable! so any language songs and ost songs are okay. remixes are okay. collabs and songs with a feature are okay.

the only two that won’t work is

1) solo songs representing the group. unit songs are allowed, but not solos

2) a different artists song that the group had a feature on. so for instance blinks couldn’t use the lady gaga FEATURING blackpink, but they could use the bp song FT cardi b or the collab song WITH selena

does that make sense?

Quote from dryheat

Kk I'll do a separate thread for this

ooh are you going to help me get the song choices from all the army?

Quote from YouChanDoThis

That makes sense. One last question I almost forgot about: are pre-debut tracks counted as well, or only songs after/on their official debut?

good question!!! i’ll only be using songs from debut and onward

Quote from dryheat

Yeah i do threads like this all the time lol I can do one for TXT too later down the line once you are ready for theirs

my hero

Quote from YouChanDoThis

Sounds good, thanks for the clarification! I'll let my guild know about this, so they can help me decide which songs to send.

omg i forgot about guilds! that’ll make it a lot easier to get song choices from bigger groups fans!

Quote from itiswhatitisss

red velvet & exo would be interesting

i’m especially excited to do red velvet! the songs of theirs that i’ve heard are usually really good!

Quote from crazydoll86

We can make a poll or a thread for this one and summon the Moas. Songs can be repeated but maybe it’s better to show a bigger variety of songs so we might need to talk this through.

bts will probably take me a few days, and i can intersperse smaller discographies while i do it! i can probably get txt done as the first one if you guys have song choices soon