Posts by stellaview

dryheat

Okay, I’ve gone through the TXT songs thread and I think these were the most agreed upon songs for top 10 and for the genre categories!

I wanted to finalize it with Moa before I start scoring!

If you don’t know what I’m talking about, check this thread!

Thread

ULTIMATE DISCOGRAPHY RATING

It’s time for the Ultimate Discography Rating!

This rating is specifically designed to give every group the best possible shot of a good score while being thorough and fair. It’s up to the music to be good enough, now!

Here’s How It Works!

Part One is a score of the group’s TOP 10 SONGS
(Hidden Content)


Part Two is a measure of whether their discography is VERSATILE
(Hidden Content)


Part Three is a score of the SONG QUALITY while being VERSATILE
(Hidden Content)


Part Four is a measure of SLAYABILITY
…

stellaview

Apr 1st 2022

Welcome! The Ultimate Discography Ratings are beginning and I wanted Idle to be one of the first artists whose discography being rated!

See the original post about how the rating system works > HERE <

What I need from Nevies:

Just scroll through, leave a positive reaction or comment on anything you agree with, and then leave any of your own recommendations!

Quote from dryheat

crazydoll86 maybe we should tag

bring me the moas!!!!!!!!!

Quote from dryheat

You beat me to it lol thx

i’m excited to start listening!

Quote from imgnrytrvllr

it's not as big as BTS' or EXO's, so it's quite approachable for the start. The whole discography is about 4-5 h of listening. Here you can check a playlist on spotify:

External Content open.spotify.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

thank you so much!

dryheat  crazydoll86

I made a thread? Let’s see if it needs tweaking since it’s the first one lol

Welcome! The Ultimate Discography Ratings are beginning and TXT is one of the first artists whose discography is being rated!

See the original post about how the rating system works > HERE <

What I need from Moa:

Quote from imgnrytrvllr

Sounds interesting! I recommend Loona's discography

that’s another one i’m excited about! do they have a big discography?

Quote from Eldeweiss

I would like to know what you think about Mamamoo discography. Your thread is a great idea. We need more discussions about music here.

i’ll definitely be doing mamamoo in all of this!

Quote from daniel-cruz

I am interested to hear your opinion on EXO's discography.

i’m excited to check it out!

Quote from YouChanDoThis

Is there a specific time you want me to submit the Stray Kids songs to you?

i think i’ll end up making a thread, so just whenever i make it :)

Quote from tenfour

Versatility is a descriptor rather than a qualitative thing.

Which is to say, marking down a discography because it is not versatile just seems wrong to me.

you should reread the post more carefully. there are 5 different scores and they aren’t all combined at the end, they stay separate. so not being versatile won’t bring down the score in any category EXCEPT for the category about how versatile they are. it’s all separate.

a score for average song quality

a score for the quality on their “versatile” songs

a score of how versatile their discography is

a score of what percentage of their songs are slays

a score of what percentage of their songs are skips

Quote from crazydoll86

Cool. We can just choose the songs ahead then so it’s ready for you.

should i make a thread and tag you guys?

Quote from crazydoll86

We can make a poll or a thread for this one and summon the Moas. Songs can be repeated but maybe it’s better to show a bigger variety of songs so we might need to talk this through.

bts will probably take me a few days, and i can intersperse smaller discographies while i do it! i can probably get txt done as the first one if you guys have song choices soon

Quote from itiswhatitisss

red velvet & exo would be interesting

i’m especially excited to do red velvet! the songs of theirs that i’ve heard are usually really good!

Quote from YouChanDoThis

Sounds good, thanks for the clarification! I'll let my guild know about this, so they can help me decide which songs to send.

omg i forgot about guilds! that’ll make it a lot easier to get song choices from bigger groups fans!

Quote from dryheat

Yeah i do threads like this all the time lol I can do one for TXT too later down the line once you are ready for theirs

my hero

Quote from keyboardwarrior7

Just listened, and yes, to me memeM sounds both experimental and noisy.

They did a lot in that song. Not necessarily bad, but definitely a lot.

agreed! there were some good moments, some not so good. mostly it was just too much and not very cohesive

Quote from Alex_Murphy

Sure, I assume what you wrote. Of course. I literally quoted you to show the things you said that you claim you didn't say. But ok, whatever.

You're off to a great start on the forum!

i didn’t say it though… as we both mentioned before, you made an assumption EVEN AFTER i reiterated. that’s your own problem lol