[CONTROVERSIAL][PC][enter-talk] THE IDEAL PART DISTRIBUTION FOR GIRL GROUPS

source: [enter-talk] THE IDEAL PART DISTRIBUTION FOR GIRL GROUPS

BlackPink

Jennie, Rose - focus
Lisa - only in charge of rap
Jisoo - as little parts as possible

Twice

Nayeon - as many parts as possible
Jihyo - supports Nayeon
Jeongyeon - gives a bit of parts
The rest of the members in charge of killing parts or 1 line at most
Dahyun - as little parts as possible
Momo - 0 second

Red Velvet

Wendy, Seulgi, Joy - focus
Yeri, Irene - as little parts as possible

Mamamoo

Moonbyul - minimize the rap & low notes only
The rest - as many parts as possible

(G)-idle

Their individual voice colors are all strong so evenly distribute them
Shuhua - definitely as little parts as possible

ITZY

Yeji is hardcarrying
Lia in charge of lower notes

Aespa

Winter > Ningning > Karina > Giselle distribution

StayC

Sieun - as many parts as possible
Isa - many parts
Seeun, J - in charge of killing parts
Yoon, Soomin - their voice colors suck so as little part as possible

Oh My Gitl

Seunghee, Hyojung - as many parts as possible
Binnie, Jiho, YooA - average parts
Mimi - instead of giving her rap, don't give her a lot of parts (except for Nonstop case)
Arin - as little parts as possible

post response:
[+256][-142]
original post: here

1. [+165, -16]
What a f*cked up post, but it's true that if they want to save those groups, this is what they should do

2. [+135, -9]
I want to f*cking swear at you, but you're saying the truth. If the member is talentless, there's no need to give them that many parts

3. [+127, -11]
The perfect parts distribution for idols is when everyone gets a chance to stand out and there's nobody who gets a negligible part. Shuhua's parts are the shortest, but she also gets the parts with the most impact so she's able to live a strong impression. This is why I think Jun Soyeon is seriously amazing

4. [+50, -49]
Yeri and Irene are not to the point of receiving no partsㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ but they shouldn't receive any rap lines

5. [+48, -15]
StayC one is a bit wrong no?

6. [+47, -5]
Huh, this is true though?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

7. [+37, -30]
Yeri and Irene's harmony are quite important in their songs

This post is pissing me off. Jihyo and NingNing are the best singers in their groups but OP gave parts to the more popular members. How is that ideal? Same for Lia. Jisoo has a pleasant voice! Some people they were giving 0 seconds to or no lines at all aren't actually bad, but they're straining their voices and being forced to sing in fake voices or wrong keys to sound cuties.

Quote from aclassyteaparty

the audacity to shade yoon like that? i can see why sumin's "vocal color" may have mixed opinions, but yoon? and this post is rude as hell for what lol

I don't know much about StayC but this post is both wrong and rude!