i-dle - Good Thing MV - bop or flop?

Blop. First song since Tomboy I kinda like.

BOP!

New Kpop fans: "Oh, this is so fresh!"

2nd gen fans: "FINALLY, Kpop is back, bitches!🤟"

The whole album screams 2nd gen, and that's why I love it so much!

Also, crystalblues please merge!

Thread

I-dle "Good thing" : BOP VS FLOP

youtube.com/watch?v=hAONx6nuEgI

SooYoung

May 19th 2025

I'ven seen so many people saying this is like 2NE1, but actually it's more like 4Minute!

I want to like it but as usual I’m put off by their awkward English. This time the chorus. I wish they would get a native speaker to work with them on the lyrics. Blop for me.

Is she singing about a d*ck? The lyrics are as usual cringe af. And Soyeon doesn't have the face to pull off that hair. Looks hideous. Flop for me.

Quote from BIGnorBANG

I liked it, but i think the teaser kinda ruined the song, as it's the most repetitive part of the song (I'm not really a fan of teasers. I'd prefer it if groups didn't have teasers and surprised us with their songs instead).

i feel the same and ive never listened to a song teaser. why dont you just not listen?

Blop

Their last good title track Oh My God

Bop

This is one of their best title tracks in their OT5 era. The pre chorus is strong and I don’t mind the chorus even though very repetitive due to teasers.

My top 3 for the album

unstoppable

chains

Good things

i voted flop initially but listened again and its not bad, blop for me. Sounds like a 2ne1 song

Quote from Yohanee

i feel the same, and I've never listened to a song teaser. why dont you just not listen?

It's so hard not to! 😭😂

it's pretty good honestly

flop for me. similar to nude and queencard but not nearly as iconic.

BOP! as aesun said, n-o-s-t-a-l-g-i-a

It is a weak song

A lot of people do not know Gidle changed its name to Idle, and think it is a new act

Quote from WhyKnock

It is a weak song

A lot of people do not know Gidle changed its name to Idle, and think it is a new act

Nobody thinks that ya friggin Clown Shoes

but ehhh, it's not that great

Quote from WhyKnock

It is a weak song

A lot of people do not know Gidle changed its name to Idle, and think it is a new act

It is in fact a new act. Though coincidentally, they just so happen to have the exact same members.

blop