The most popular member in Twice?

I think this only means Sana has the most hardcore fans.

No Sana no Life, what can you say

I'd say...

Sana: Japan

Tzuyu: Internationally

Nayeon: Korea

I think it's harder to analyze members' popularity

I will say she’s the most popular member alongside tzuyu because she’s top 2 everywhere and her sales are showing it. She definitely has the biggest fandom

It's hard to go off the sales number in this case because Tzuyu's is out of stock. There was more demand than supply. We don't know how many more it would have sold if they printed more.

Sana is not even close to the popularity of tzuyu

Sana's definitely popular but the demand for Tzuyu's photobook was crazy. Japanese women name Tzuyu as an ideal face for their ps and she often trends. Even today Tzuyu's second hand photobooks are being sold for over $100.

Quote from hueningkaiskai

Sana is not even close to the popularity of tzuyu

There is not a big gap and the sales show it so you saying she isn't close makes no sense. As for the OP's question, it's Tzuyu.

Another reason why I think Sana's PB sales are higher is because it was released after M&M and ICSM which are their two biggest songs internationally. The fandom has grown.

Quote from fdblink

It's hard to go off the sales number in this case because Tzuyu's is out of stock. There was more demand than supply. We don't know how many more it would have sold if they printed more.

Me!!

I have been waiting for the restock for months for the Tzuyu photobook

Tzuyu

At the moment fandom wise I would say it's Sana. Huge amount of Tzuyu fans got fed up with her treatment over the years and left from the endless disappointment.

Another thing to point out is that when Tzuyu's photobook was released, the Korean posts didn't work so we had to use different delivery option. In my case I had to use DHL and the photo book cost me around $90 Because of it I couldn't buy both versions

It's hard to say with all the stocking issues, but I personally feel Tzuyu has a larger dedicated fandom while Sana is extremely popular but the 'bias wrecker' of many.

Besides just comparing the members I think the overall popularity of all the girls can't be accurately gauged just yet because of stocking

Source: I am salty and have tried to buy many things too late

Quote from txt-housemaid

I think it’s Sana, look at the (yes I am)sales even when she’s the latest one

79BB1F4B-6D62-491C-BEFA-FFAEB48F50B4.jpeg

Sales: 7071

83C3A0A3-BC48-4D4A-BF0B-1995479F90E8.jpg

Sales: 6998

716CAE68-A962-4C6B-A5F2-9D36AAAB614F.jpeg

Sales: 4431

Display More

Hmm this original post isn't an accurate indicator of their popularity? You are basically indicating numbers based on one or two days and the numbers could vary depending on the stock available but pre-orders can keep coming.

Besides, it's known that Tzuyu's photobook was sold out or ranked high in sales in many major websites, and her photobook was selling out even after 6 months from the initial release. Hence I think in terms of overall sales, Tzuyu's pb sales might actually perform better.

God knows

Actually.... everybody knows, it is Tzuyu, Nayeon and Sana close second

Quote from Angelakoh

Hmm this original post isn't an accurate indicator of their popularity? You are basically indicating numbers based on one or two days and the numbers could vary depending on the stock available but pre-orders can keep coming.

Besides, it's known that Tzuyu's photobook was sold out or ranked high in sales in many major websites, and her photobook was selling out even after 6 months from the initial release. Hence I think in terms of overall sales, Tzuyu's pb sales might actually perform better.

Tzuyu has the biggest fandom I think every onces agree even Mina has a bigger fan base than sana or nayeon

But sana is one the main attractors of the group

I think sana nayeon and tzuyu are probably the most popular

Sana and Dahyun are interesting maybe not but basically their stans are a bit easygoing and dont take things like votings, debate, talents, etc too seriously therefore they dont seem that popular but trust me, they were the stan attractors of the group, just look at reddit poll lol.

everyone in twice is popular btw