In defense of “CLIK CLAK” by BABYMONSTER

I enjoy hip hop/rap music but I don't know why I didn't like this song.

Maybe it was the lyrics or the music I had an issue with. I'm still not sure.

Or I was expecting more of a continuation of Batter Up or Sheesh concepts.

I guess I was caught off guard. I don't know.

Maybe I expected this tough concept to be used down the line.

Again, I don't know.

Well said! I was thinking the same thing about the first argument you mention, it's just kind of silly to gripe over that when in reality much of kpop is manufactured, and there's nothing wrong with that. And I really don't think their age makes much of a difference either. For me it's really just I felt some members of the group seem forced into the concept. I'd probably say the same thing if Jisoo or Rose went full rapper, I just don't think the concept would suit them. The song is good though other than some issues with the lyrics.

my native language is not english so ı can't say anything about that, when it comes to the ' they are too young' thing, ı can't really understand. for me this is a kpop thing most of the ıdols too young. another point ' they don't suit...' is invalid for me. cause ı think the youngest,rora and chiquta, are the one of the outstanding members for me. but ı really can't judge people, after all, there is a consensus among nonfans and native english speakers so yeah ı understand but kpop is not like that for me. ı'm open the cringe and weird stuffs

BABYMONSTER just isn't there for me, yk? A lot of their songs feel recycled to me. Just like SHEESH sounded like something BP would release, Clik Clak sounds like something 2NE1 would release. And I agree when Tru-Multistan said that some of the members don't fit. To me, the whole "badass" vibe feels so forced on them. I may be wrong, though.

honestly? clik clak is not that terrible apart from the chorus. i like it more the more I listen to it.

I didn't like the end part, it doesn't fit the song at all. Other than that the clik clak is just another onbrand YG hip hop track that lacks any nuisance and deep meaning. I mean there's like a zillion songs about flexing and money so it's super boring to see YG making the same music over and over again. The one thing I can say about the song is it has fun choreography and it made me bias Chiquita and Rora.

I think it's awful, but well, I'm also a hater of xg and young posse's music.

naw thats a reach.

honestly I think click clack is good ( it's a matter of preference ) I would only change some parts of the lyric but the concept itself is not bad because the girls can pull it off with their charisma. We can't deny the girls are at least good performers People need to understand that every company have their style which in yg is more hip hop ish

Also based on YouTube reactions some people like it at least I haven't seen negative feedback

We can agree to disagree. BM failed to sell that concept to me, I cringe every time Chiquita says living large. Most of the girls do not match the concept, it feels, looks anda sounds wrong to me. Regardless of my opinion, someone has to like it, right. Good other people do, cause if it would depend on me, Clik Clak would have never seen the sun light, not even for 2NE1 - maybe just for Minzy and CL duo.

Quote from superyeah

David33 said the girls are too new to the industry to be bragging so much, but I disagree. K-pop is manufactured, and that’s not something to shame or reject. It’s something to embrace. K-pop openly and unapologetically portrays lore. It’s something we won’t always find in other genres, but it’s abundant in K-pop.

There’s also the argument that the girls are too young to act so badass. I disagree. I think it might even be worse to see some older people doing this concept because, by that time, they should have outgrown that “swag” phase. “Swag” is a young person’s game after all.

I still think they're too new to do this, but not gonna lie, the song is kinda grown on me over time. My biggest problem, is that this isn't their 1st or even the 2nd cringy diss track. Doing once is okay, doing twice, sure, why not, but doing it the 3rd time in the span of 1 year is just way too much.

But I have to disagree on that last part. It's not about their age. If that would be the case, I wouldn't stan Young Posse.

IF there's anything this song is good for, it is that people finally see why I always say Rami is the real ACE of the group.

The real funny thing is that most people, even their own fans hate "TOKYO", but I love it.😂

3rd in best song of the year