Old Twice vs New Twice

Yes, I like Twice.

Quote from horizonshard

Yes, I like Twice.

I think I agree with you on this one. Twice is just Twice and it's almost all good.

i skipped a lot of songs in the no skip era but they got good ones like this

Hmm this is hard.

Had you asked this 1-2 years ago, I would definitely have said old cute Twice.

I didn't really like songs like More and More, I Can't Stop Me, Cry For Me, and while I like Fancy and Feel Special now, at the time I didn't care for too much for them since they didn't really feel special to me. 2019 to 2020 was looking pretty dark for me and I was feeling pretty pessimistic about future releases.

And then Twice started having a crazy "quality" streak starting from 2021 with The Feels, Talk that Talk, Scientist, and them their Japanese quality went through the roof, Kura Kura, Perfect World, (except Doughnut...ugh...) Celebrate.

In terms of title tracks, old Twice was the best but then new Twice bsides make old Twice bsides look like their songs were "made in China". Old Twice was "quantity over quality" where as new Twice is just pure "quality" everywhere.

So think it comes down to a question of if I prefer better title tracks or just a better discography as a whole.

I think if I had to only pick one or the other to listen to, I would pick old Twice, I stan Twice because of the feelings I get when I listen to their music and iconic tracks like What Is Love, Heart Shaker, Like A Fool, just to name a few. I would pick old Twice

But if I don't have to sacrifice any music and simply just a preference, because the old tracks are always there for me to go back to if I need to feel happy, sad, nostalic, etc and those songs are not going anywhere, I would prefer new Twice music moving forward.

Unpopular opinion but Talk That Talk is one of my favorite tracks and I just love that sound and style, unfortunately due to how poorly it did on charts, I doubt JYP will continue with something like it which leaves me still a bit uncertain about future releases, if they release anything like 4th gen, this mellow kinda of music, I'm going to be really sad.

Good thing comeback is just around the corner and I won't be left guessing for too long on how future Twice will be.

Cute TWICE by a miles

New Twice - Fancy, Feel Special and ICSM are their holy trinity as a non-stan

I can’t choose because I love songs from both Twice and their no skip era is like a natural progression from their first period.

I’ll be lying to say I didn’t enjoy their initial era more

Hrd to say, I am a visual stan

Quote from Armedryu

Hrd to say, I am a visual stan

Ok then which era did they look cuter in? Lol

both

Quote from kwonjiyong92

both

Choose

Quote from fdblink

Ok then which era did they look cuter in? Lol

The later one. Cheer Up, LOA and Signal are kinda mid

Quote from fdblink

Choose

I can't

a

literal

impossible

question

for

me

...

Just Twice

Hmm, this is a hard one. Like, with old Twice, I liked almost ALL of their songs. LOA, Cheer-Up, TT, Signal, Likey, Heartshaker, DTNA, YoY. It was also a lot of fun in their earlier career because everything felt so new like I was discovering more about them, and they also promoted more outside of just YouTube so it was fun seeing them interact with other idols.

NGL, new Twice has been hit or miss for me. Didn't hate but didn't love Feel Special, M&M, ICSM, The Feels, or Alcohol Free. I like Scientist, but it's no TT.

However, the songs I DO like from new Twice, are miles above the songs for old Twice in my opinion. Fancy, TTT, and Cry For Me are literally my favorite Twice songs.

Quantity wise, old Twice wins. Quality wise, it's new Twice for me.