Top 10 idol group hits in korea since 2019 according to my observation of charts (outdated)

  • I’d switch LSG and HYLT but it seems accurate

    U consider lsg's longetivity in top10 superior to hylt going #1 everywhere?

    ■■■■■■■■□□□ 𝓢𝓔𝓔𝓤𝓝 □□□■■■■■■■■

    0032d3e09166cb9a968ac75ab188ee513bc60563.gifv 6d8dfa2357ab0fdf5eaeb13dd6f7ce62bb23689d.gifv 83e7fb07461095e0251d47aebcc2c6cfcba8a272.gifv

  • fancy is questionable.

  • I think the list is pretty accurate but as someone else said, it's hard comparing songs pre-reform to songs post-reform which is why I usually avoid posts like these lmao. We've really only got Gaon Points/ULs to compare, when those are also at an all time low due to COVID-19.


    Can we expect LSG to surpass HYLT eventually? :/

    imo it has been below HYLT up until a bit recently. With LSG getting 14M in it's 22nd week compared to HYLT's 13M in it's 22nd week despite digital points being at an all-time low(a small difference but..), I can actually see LSG outcharting HYLT in the long run. Even on the Daily Chart it's starting to outchart HYLT.


    Honestly it depends on whether you put more emphasis on #1s or on longevity....

  • Can we expect LSG to surpass HYLT eventually? :/

    imo it has been below HYLT up until a bit recently. With LSG getting 14M in it's 22nd week compared to HYLT's 13M in it's 22nd week despite digital points being at an all-time low(a small difference but..), I can actually see LSG outcharting HYLT in the long run.


    Even on the Daily Chart it's starting to outchart HYLT(HYLT had 175k ULs in it's 158th day compared to LSG having 210k on it's 158th day).

    Lsg is going to stay on the charts for much longer without a doubt. It'll even have more digital index by the end.

    It becomes difficult to compare two songs that were released some months ago itself. Lol

    ■■■■■■■■□□□ 𝓢𝓔𝓔𝓤𝓝 □□□■■■■■■■■

    0032d3e09166cb9a968ac75ab188ee513bc60563.gifv 6d8dfa2357ab0fdf5eaeb13dd6f7ce62bb23689d.gifv 83e7fb07461095e0251d47aebcc2c6cfcba8a272.gifv

  • I just have a question. What’s a digital index and where can i check how many digital index points a song has?

    They're the metric Gaon uses for the digital chart(They calculate data from the streaming chart, BGM chart and downloads chart) and those will be reflected in the weekly Gaon points.


    You can use guyso or the official Gaon website.

    http://gaonchart.co.kr/main/se…ationGbn=T&serviceGbn=ALL

    https://xn--o39an51b2re.com/gaon/jisurecord

  • well i find it pretty hard to compare post reform songs to pre reforms one. songs after have waaay more longevity. this is the only hick i have, otherwise, i doubt Fancy can compare to On, the latter has way more longevity.

  • Gaon has some weird stuff happening to its digitals from time to time (eg. all songs suddenly jumping up in digital score from one week to the next, or all suddenly dropping down structurally with 20-30% in digitals), so my guess is they're doing some recalibration of their compiled digital totals algorithm or formula from time to time.


    I wasn't aware Dolphin was having that great digitals? (did it?)

    Not so sure if # of weeks in Top 10, Top 5 or at #1 is that telling, since it's heavily dependent on luck or who your competition is in released songs.


    I'm still convinced Psycho should end up higher on that list, but unfortunately it suffered from the abrupt promotion cut off right at the start, RV's year of non-activity and the competition of the #1 and #2 on Gaon's 2020 annual chart (Zico's Any Song + Changmo's Meteor) that came out around that same timeperiod.

  • I'd put Psycho over Dalla Dalla, and Nonstop over Hip. Psycho did very well and have great longetivity despite don't have proper promotion + UL loss + no support from comeback. It stayed longer in top 10 than Dalla Dalla. As for Nonstop and Hip, just look at the stats, despite the UL loss, Nonstop spent 13 weeks inside top 10 just like HIP, in its 44th week, Nonstop rank 48th and gained 7m+ digital index with a total of 667 m+, while HIP rank 83rd, gained 5 m+ digital index, with total of 649 m+. Both group had long hiatus. RV, Mamamoo, and Oh My Girl did very well and had great longetivity despite long hiatus.

    And I'd put Lovesick Girls over How You Like That.

  • Why?

    on seemed to perform better despite the covid setting as well. fancy had less longetivity and fancy did not hit 1. but, hard to compare just my thoughts.

  • In evaluating digital performance, GAON digital points are the best measure. Ranking or number of weeks on top100 is relative measure as they highly dependent on competition.


    Fancy doesnt felt that big to be on top 10.

    ON obviously had the better digital points+ longevity.


    LSG did not hit #1 but doesnt mean it is not performing good. It was blocked by Dynamite which i believe at that time no one can overtake it (not even BTS themselves). LSG is already outcharting HYLT in term of longevity (before someone say because of reform, im talking about digital points on GAON)

  • Wasn't ON's charting a bit bumpy? I would say dynamite kinda breathed a new life into it and made it have good longevity.

    ON was charting for a while on its own, even before Dyna. And regardless, it charted for longer than FANCY and outpeaked it.

    Is he.....you know?

    투모로우바이투게더 방탄
    레드벨벳엑소샤이니에이티즈

  • I'd put Psycho over Dalla Dalla, and Nonstop over Hip. Psycho did very well and have great longetivity despite don't have proper promotion + UL loss + no support from comeback. It stayed longer in top 10 than Dalla Dalla. As for Nonstop and Hip, just look at the stats, despite the UL loss, Nonstop spent 13 weeks inside top 10 just like HIP, in its 44th week, Nonstop rank 48th and gained 7m+ digital index with a total of 667 m+, while HIP rank 83rd, gained 5 m+ digital index, with total of 649 m+. Both group had long hiatus. RV, Mamamoo, and Oh My Girl did very well and had great longetivity despite long hiatus.

    And I'd put Lovesick Girls over How You Like That.

    Well-explained. I can agree with Nonstop over HIP.

    Is he.....you know?

    투모로우바이투게더 방탄
    레드벨벳엑소샤이니에이티즈

  • The list seems fine, we'll have to wait a while b4 we can see how LSG compares to HYLT. For now it is definitely lower than HYLT esp with the total gaon points with the same weeks past.


    Imo there isnt really much difference from 5-9.

    Dolphin's status is elevated bc it is a bside. But if it and Nonstop continue doing well maybe they will be where they are now on the list and maybe nonstop will be even higher than Hip.


    Dalla Dalla had the greatest gaon digitals because it did consistently well during its first 20weeks despite not peaking too high, so u could say it didnt have the longetivity but did have the start. Altho 2019 gaon digitals surely helped, none of the 2020 songs were afforded the ability to stay stable in its first 20 weeks due to COVID, the biggest losers in that aspect being On, Psycho, HYLT and LSG, so they couldnt really gain more digital points from the start and was already at a disadvantage bc of it. I think its fair to say that DD and Psycho are of the same level despite the 100M+ gaon points difference

  • Here's how all the nominated songs compare in terms of music show wins:


    Dynamite - 32 wins

    Boy with Luv - 21 wins

    On - 16 wins

    How You Like That - 13 wins

    Dalla Dalla - 9 wins

    Psycho - 9 wins

    Nonstop - 8 wins

    Hip - 7 wins

    Lovesick Girls - 6 wins

    Fancy - 3 wins

    Dolphin - 0 wins

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!