Looks like Twice will be the last successful big girl group unless "YG's SNSD" surprises us

Sm can if they debut big gg with snsd early debut concept

the last successful big gg was pristin

I'll be at the back flying a flag for SlayC

I really hope YG’s group debuts soon! I can’t wait to see what they release.

okay is yg really debuting big group ??? is it really confirmed ???

Quote from jinaland

okay is yg really debuting big group ??? is it really confirmed ???

I’m unsure. I forget if we have official confirmation or not. I know we have hints they might do it soon, but knowing how YG works, soon could mean next month or next decade.

The benefits of debuting a larger group over a smaller one is pretty much non-existent now so makes sense.

Well, the trend will rise again, its a cycle

The mythical YGNGG is currently rumored to have 7 members. So expect 5-7 members on 2030.

Quote from kpopace26

The mythical YGNGG is currently rumored to have 7 members. So expect 5-7 members on 2030.

NMIXX is already 7 member group.

blackpink was supposed to be that YG's snsd so nope I don't think it will happen anymore

Lightsum is going from 7 to 5 members so could be a good gauge to the theory that less = more

Quote from moolaa

Sm can if they debut big gg with snsd early debut concept

but they haven`t . Last 3 gg from SM had been less than 6. Even SNSD members said that is not easy to be in a gg with a lot of members. In general those groups does not last so long. SM had luck with SNSD but even then they are 9-1.

And JYP always said that Twice members was chosen taking consideration of the members personality. JYP does not like problematic girls i guess.

I wonder if YG will try something different with his new gir group, but I doubt.

Nmixx a contender? I think you're giving JYPE way too much credit.

Especially with how easily people are able to dig out idols' past these days, I dont think large size groups are worth the risk.

Quote from Person01

I wonder if YG will try something different with his new gir group, but I doubt.

Nmixx a contender? I think you're giving JYPE way too much credit.

NMixx will be a factor …big 4 and great live performers…music still work in progress, but they will be in the mix of top gg(s)

I think iz*one disbanding was the official death of super successful large girl groups in this era of kpop

Quote from zylan

NMixx will be a factor …big 4 and great live performers…music still work in progress, but they will be in the mix of top gg(s)

The squad is pretty incompetent in promoting/managing the group.

The whole division separation is pretty inefficient, because if you have one guy that does really well in some area, why not let him work his magic in all the groups?

You have a good example of what a strong creative person does for a group's success, like Jaden Jeong and his new group Triple SSS, coming from a smaller company with fewer resources is already doing better in all the metrics that matter like, music, styling, creative direction, and so on. Imagine if they had the resources that JYP has.

That is the difference between an experienced and creative team and one that barely knows what they are doing.

People say Nmixx has a strong fan base, but I think It all comes down to them being in a big company, without that their numbers would be even worse. Sure, they are talented, but it is clearly being wasted with mediocre management.