KPOP Exposed IDOLS LIVE SINGING IS WORST THAN WE THOUGHT

This video pretty much shows even the best singers have off days, they're all humans so I hope people would stop always posting that one "off day" video and claiming an idol can't sing.

Quote from KangK

This is true. But did you notice why most the best always stable and better than worst?

Kpop has always sell us the perfect singing but in reality it's no where close.

Hmm...I can't say I notice it. I had to look through the comments, I'm guessing you mean one is singing live and other is in a more controlled environment?

That part I've always known about, I saw in some video from an ex kpop idol that they often add something like an autotune to it. But I've also seen many idols sing acapella and were great

jimin is a unique case of really bad live singing

i remember he used to be really good back in like 2015 but yeah has been really really hard on the ears for a few years now

btw whats considered good vocals in kpop is the bare minimum i'd expect from a professional

and what's worst is worse than most average people

truth be told....

Quote from Nyaz

truth be told....

Display Spoiler

they're still better than me

you havent tried hard enough

trust me, try to truly sing and you'll find the average person ( not tone deaf ) can carry a tune pretty well for one verse atleast

I mean, I am pretty sure all of groups mentioned their have at least one clip of them singing live and dancing at the same time perfectly fine. Some of yall exaggerate a little too much.

My favs are good no problem

Some of these group have actually very rarely had good days. I seen some videos of fans “defending” their favs and sharing an audio and oftentimes they’re all equally as bad.

Kpop fans do not care about good or in tune singing. They just pretend mediocre not even passable level singing skills are extraordinary lol.

Quote from unbannBLACPINK

you havent tried hard enough

trust me, try to truly sing and you'll find the average person ( not tone deaf ) can carry a tune pretty well for one verse atleast

oh but i swear, I couldn't sing if my life depended on it I'm absolutely dreadful at it!

Thankfully, i have other talents, like cooking and partying Better than nothing ig!

Quote from Nyaz

oh but i swear, I couldn't sing if my life depended on it I'm absolutely dreadful at it!

Thankfully, i have other talents, like cooking and partying Better than nothing ig!

yep

just dont be bad at your profession, that should be good enough

i cant watch kpop live performances anymore cause everytime i think, these people are getting paid to do that

Quote from KangK

It iss not. I would bet you would have find most of the good vocal are not live just like the video I posted in the op. It is worst than we we thought if we keep digging it.

there are plenty of good vocals that are live

Quote from unbannBLACPINK

yep

just dont be bad at your profession, that should be good enough

i cant watch kpop live performances anymore cause everytime i think, these people are getting paid to do that

well, i guess in the end, we all get paid to do something but yeah, i agree with you, some of them aren't exactly delivering the gold! lmaooo

Quote from ArmyBlinkOnce0

there are plenty of good vocals that are live

that's also True!

My faves have been killing it live from the start until now

Quote from Nyaz

well, i guess in the end, we all get paid to do something but yeah, i agree with you, some of them aren't exactly delivering the gold! lmaooo

yeah we should get paid our due

but would you pay for a fridge that only works 10% of the times?

or would you pay an athlete who only performs well once a year?

Quote from unbannBLACPINK

yeah we should get paid our due

but would you pay for a fridge that only works 10% of the times?

or would you pay an athlete who only performs well once a year?

nope, i would not! lmaoo

that being said, armyblink does have a good point tho, some...... have stellar live vocals! They exist! I would pay them for sure!

Quote from Nyaz

nope, i would not! lmaoo

that being said, armyblink does have a good point tho, some...... have stellar live vocals! They exist! I would pay them for sure!

yeah sure

at the end of the day, you often have to choose between music and skill

and i choose music so i avoid live stages

some have value to offer though, like Butterfly I watch purely for the amazing choreo and setup

Quote from icyruios

My faves are stable

they're not in the video, too nugu like mine

The ‘worst ones’ are bad moments but the catch is that compared to most of the ‘best’, they are all LIVEs without a loud backtrack. If you watch most of those bad moments’s full stages, the rest of it sounds good but they made a mistake or had started off wrong (I say most not all, some like non-vocalists just doesn’t have singing skills and it shows). I prefer those LIVEs and wish Kpop fans don’t get nit-picky when the rest of the performance is good.

Mmm this feels like copium man idk

Say thank you to TWICE for popularizing the encore

Quote from unbannBLACPINK

yeah sure

at the end of the day, you often have to choose between music and skill

I choose both! Rolling Quartz LIVE is all you need!

Worst were mostly encore with no backtrack

best were performance with backtrack

It was like comparing Apple to oranges