Aespa proving why their the Best Vocal Group of this Generation. It's not even close

the power they have is amazing

Wut? Yuri (aka the next IU) exists.

Ningning my beloved she is a singer !!!!

Look, I don’t mean to be the dick here, as they are actually excellent singers, but I have issues with this sort of video… the notes this video claims they are hitting are NOT the notes they are hitting. They are way out…

I don’t want to diss on them because they are hitting these notes with decent stability (and also I know full well from watching other vids of them they are capable of so much) but this sort of vid is making out almost like they’re hitting Mariah/Ariana whistle tones when for the majority they’re smack bang in the middle of your usual female register.

Giving them the benefit I think they may think they’re applying typical male vocal register to female register but middle c on a piano is c1 on a piano and this is claiming these are, even at the beginning, virtually 3 octaves above that!

Just let their actual abilities speak for themselves.

Actually, I’m going to put a disclaimer here, because that came across as possibly more dickish than I intended, that there might be a difference in Uk notation to US standard notation I’m not aware of.

Suffice to say, I’m not trying to crap on their talent, they’re great.

Those allegations about them not being able to sing have always been dumb af

Quote from Storm_Bloom

Literally no one is claiming the notes on the video were legit since it's just a fan posted video but fact is they ALL can SING, have ranges and can hit notes as evident on their BTS

Just one of those things that bug me, and I gave a disclaimer after- I would hope it was obvious that I was still saying I have a very high opinion of their vocal abilities.

Quote from penepol

Giving them the benefit I think they may think they’re applying typical male vocal register to female register but middle c on a piano is c1 on a piano and this is claiming these are, even at the beginning, virtually 3 octaves above that!

Middle C of a piano is C4

Quote from Storm_Bloom

They have vocal abilities that's for sure

Yeah, look, I genuinely believe them to be exceptionally talented. I just had a moment where I got too pissy because I think things that *overstate* can end up backfiring when I think that , actually, their stability in this case should be enough in its own to speak for itself, and I concede that maybe trad western vocal notation may actually be an octave lower than I am used to in a Uk-based classical setting, which wasn’t fair. I’m actually genuinely not sure about together that is the case ! but it wasn’t necessary.

I have a habit of liking things to be too black and white depending on what I’m used to.

Quote from omnimorphism

Middle C of a piano is C4

Not in English classical notation! But I’ve backed down so no worries!

I'm proud of what they've done this year and for a new fan they've won me over. I think they're amazing.

Quote from penepol

Not in English classical notation! But I’ve backed down so no worries!

not in mine too. i just googled and learned what c4 is for, i assume american classical notation, it is c1 here.

interesting. i always wondered why is c5 so casually mentioned when here barely anyone can hit it. gotcha.